Island Grill

2601 S Lemay Ave #12, Fort Collins
(970) 266-0124

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jake Ehrlich

We arrived to be told that food orders would be at be delayed at least 30 minutes. We should have walked out at that point but unfortunately we remained hopeful. We ordered the Big Burrito, a burger, and the fish and chips. It took a very long time for the food to come out. In fact some other customers left due to the lack of service. Most of our food arrived cold. I say most as the burger never arrived. It was very disappointing experience.

Jarod VanNatta

Nice spot to try. Enjoyed it.

Alexander Hargleroad

Met a cute girl named Marcie

Drew Fellers

10/10 cstering experience - we ordered relatively last minute for a larger party (Ordered on Weds, party on Sat), and had a wonderful experience. Kenny kept engaged with me up through the party to ensure everything was was on point. Food was amazing, great service - I've always loved the location itself and our first catering from them was top notch!

Elizabeth Nicola

So many great options and service is always great

Samuel Whitaker

Nothing on this menu will disappoint. The jambalaya is the greatest ever.

S S

I joined a friend to watch a football game and the place was packed! The hostess was great about helping us find a good spot so we could enjoy the game. Our waitress was wonderful, she was so kind and responsive and the food was great! I definitely recommend and will be back, the food and atmosphere but especially your excellent staff made it a great visit!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jorge Flores

Been to the grill the bartender I had DL was very nice and respectful also made a great drink. Had a nice time looking forward to going back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Nathan Hall

I’ve been there twice now, once on New Year’s Eve. Atmosphere was ok. But both times I’ve been there, the drinks were the weakest I’ve ever been served in public. I thought maybe the first time was a fluke, but it wasn’t. My recommendation if you go… Don’t expect much out of the bar or the bar staff.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Thomas Reeves

Found a twist tie on the bottom of my burger. Needles to say I didn't finish my meal. I informed the server, she apologized, but never took my meal of the check. I will not be returning to this establishment, and the food was subpar at best.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Riley Reeves

Went there today for lunch, and my son found a plastic twist tie imbeded at the bottom of his hamburger. I informed my server, who apologized, but they didn't take my sons meal off the ticket, nor did they offer. Food was mediocre at best, will not be back here again.

Dave Boyles

Had a couple of beers and listened to a good band. Place was hopping with lively dancing. Older crowd and very positive and active.

Atmosphere: 5

Imani Williams

Underrated, in my opinion this was one of the best meals we've had in Fort collins. Fish batter is amazing. Wings were on point, considering chicken qsrs don't even serve them this meaty. Service was great inbetween the two servers who switched off. We were checked on multiple times. All specials were mentioned, drinks stayed full, desert was offered.Even the bartender had come over when she saw us checking the menu out up front. Beer tastes like lines are cleaned regularly 👌 easily 10/10

Kid-friendliness: Catered to my kids request!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, Fish and Chips

Brian Curtis

Great food good atmosphere💯

A. Jinnie McManus

Went because of high reviews and the most random menu I've seen in a bit... tacos, burgers, stir fry and Mexican? It started OK, staff didn't notice we walked in but seated us when we walked up to them chatting at the bar. The server recommended a milkshake, which was prepared kind of like a virgin daiquiri. Didn't taste bad, but was definitely not a shake. Waiter offered to remake it promptly and without being asked, but it was still more slush than shake.

Our orders (half an order of fish and chips, and a burger) took a weirdly long time. I ordered medium rare and got well done. Waiter never came back to check on us after food, I eventually had to walk over to the staff still chatting at the bar, told him enough time had passed that I'd pay for it but wanted him to know it was wrong. He offered a discount, which ultimately turned out to be a paltry 10%. He then finally returned to our table and said the chef had been cooking since 6am (!). It was 9:30pm at the time. The burger did have good flavor, so at least it wasn't inedible like the milkshake.

We again had to go to the chatty staff at the bar to ask for our bill after a solid half hour and didn't get an itemized one until our second ask. That's when I found out I'd been charged for the "milkshakes" and the hilarious burger "discount".

It was late, the staff were young and we did tip them more than they clearly deserved, but we won't be returning. Waste of time, money and calories.

The live band was great.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...