Make Your Cake
609 N Timberline Rd, Fort Collins
(970) 214-5909
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
For my son’s Grooms Cake, Rhonda made this outstanding Barn Owl on a stump cake that astonished him and our guests at the Rehearsal Dinner. They thought it was a statue! It was delicious, the bird chocolate and the stump vanilla-chocolate swirl. Rhonda is a skilled cake artist, willing to explore and stretch her abilities. She kept me informed, delivered the cake when scheduled and she was a delight to work with!
She was incredibly friendly and flexible! The cake was beautiful, exactly what I asked for, very reasonably priced, and most importantly delicious!!! I would highly recommend her to absolutely anyone and everyone!
She was incredibly friendly and flexible! The cake was beautiful, exactly what I asked for, very reasonably priced, and most importantly delicious!!! I would highly recommend her to absolutely anyone and everyone!
Rhonda answered her phone while out shopping was attentive to my last minute order due to another baker cancelling on me. She matched the college colors that I needed for my daughters college signing.Everyone was very complimentary of her baking and wanted to know where I had ordered the cake pops from. A huge thank you and big shout out.
Wow, great service and she created a amazing cake for me. Highly recommend.
Asked for this custom cake and it turned out absolutely perfect!! She did such an amazing job. Was all the talk at our Bridal Shower. Oh and tasted so good. Would definitely recommend
Ordered a camping cake, she was amazing, beautifully decorated!!! Cake was delicious as well!!!
I reached out to Rhonda about making a cake for a biology graduate who wanted beakers and test tubes. We ordered chocolate cake with ganache filling, which was incredible!! The decorations on the cake were exactly what we wanted and even better than we imagined.
I contacted Rhonda about making a horse cake for a special birthday girl and the end result was amazing!! I sent her a picture of the horse and she created such an amazing likeness of him! The attention to detail was far beyond my expectation! It was almost too pretty to eat, but we did and it was so delicious! The whole process was seamless and I will be contacting Rhonda when the next birthday rolls around!
Absolutely love our cake we got for our baby shower! Rhonda did such an amazing job! Will definitely be going back to her for any time we need another cake done!
Restaurantji Recommends
I am so happy that we found Make Your Cake!! My father is so happy with his birthday cake and it is delicious!! Everything about the service and cake itself was so smooth. Thank you for making my dad’s birthday so special!! Kim
Two years on a row! Rhonda made us an amazing cake!!!!
I highly recommend Rhonda for Make your Cake! I had a birthday cake for my partner done by her and wow did Rhonda go above and beyond! I called around and every cake store said they couldn't do one in time (even with a week ahead of time) and Rhonda told me she could! She added in such beautiful and intricate detail that made this cake stand out! Also it was so moist for being such a beautiful cake! Devils food cake was so tasty.
Rhonda, the baby yoda cake not only looked good, it was absolutely delicious! We can’t thank you enough!! Awesome work!
Rhonda is absolutely amazing! The baby yoda cake was great and the taste...a slice of heaven! Thank you so much, we are so appreciative!
Loading...