Mary's Mountain Cookies

I love Mary’s Mountain Cookies!

I wish I could post more and better picture of the amazing looking cookies but they have mysteriously vaporized!!! The picture I'm posting is all that is left. Kidding aside these are the best cookies on the front range. Better than Crumbl. Better than anything. Simply the best cookies.

And the service at the shop is friendly and helpful! I love this place. In fact I love it TOO much. I wish I could come here every week but being pre diabetic I have to stay away. I want the folks at this shop to know how much I love your cookies but I simply can't control myself when I'm around them. They are just addictive! 🤑🤑🤑🤑

I highly recommend these cookies! If I had one wish it would be that I could eat a cookie from this shop each week. But sadly 😭 I can't control myself and even if I could that's too much sugar for my health. But God dam these are good cookies and if I was going to risk a diabetic coma it would be for these cookies. Did I mention I love 😍these cookies? 🤣

Amazing cookie shop

Not only are the cookies absolutely delicious, the team is excellent as they helped us build a custom order for our wedding. Our wedding guests continue to talk about how delicious the cookies were. If you haven't been, you need to stop by when you're in Old Town Fort Collins!

Um wow. Crumbl who? So much better!!These cookies looked too amazing to pass up and I had to go for the oatmeal cream filled and it was literal heaven! Please do yourself a favor and stop here for a sweet treat! They even cut the cookie in half for my friend and I to share ❤️

Mary’s has the best cookies! And this location is the best for both customer service and taste! Highly recommend!

I have been into this specific Mary's Mountain Cookies many times before in my youth, but I have recently come into this place and have seen just how far this place has gone downhill.

First and foremost, I would aspire to state that the Cookies, even with the changes in pricing are still great and massive for the reasonable price they provide, not only are the Cookies massive, but at the location in Downtown Fort Collins, they give you 2 extra Cookies with the purchase of a half dozen Cookies.

Second, the staff is really nice and is willing to service you, as seen with Meredith, the cashier oriented at the front of the store, who helped to service me as I slowly chose the Cookies.

But that is where the compliments end, the main issue that I had with this location has been the issue with the sanitation of the facility, a fly landed on one of the Cookies in the display case and proved to leave me with a bit of a sour taste in my mouth that I felt as I entered into the store, something I have never seen in this location before. In addition, the cookie variety could be improved, as they could add varieties, such as a Ginger Snap to the lineup in the future or other Cookies that will make the experience better for individuals.

If they do not improve upon their mistakes, I may question coming back here in the future, but I will come back if the Cookies are a redemption anecdote.

Yuuuummm!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great cookies, laid back atmosphere, fair prices. We enjoyed our “dirty panda” and classic frosted sugar cookies.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They use MARGARINE in their cookies. Disgusting

Sugar craving?
This is the joint
All cookies extra sweet and soft. Perfect pre-snow day treat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Their almond glaze cookie is my guilty pleasure. It's drier than their other cookies, but it tastes like marzipan. I love it.

I can also whole heartedly recommend their snickerdoodle cookie!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

One of my favorite places to indulge in the juiciest cookie! I absolutley love this place the vibes are excellent! The staff is very respectful when I order a million cookies! I absolutely love s’mores cookie! Cheers to a gre business.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: S'Mores Cookie

Love this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great cookies in a great environment with the friendliest staff! Love this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5