Mary's Mountain Cookies

123 N College Ave STE 106, Fort Collins
(970) 482-5655

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Ice Cream Sandwich
Salted Caramel
S'Mores Cookie
Snickerdoodle
Cookie Heaven
Lemondoodle
Darth Vader
M&ms Cookie
Dirty Panda

Menu

Cookies 1/4 Pounder
Chocolate Chip Classic Cookie
Snickerdoodle
Sugar cookie topped with cinnamon and sugar
M&M
Kids love em'
Peanut Butter Classic Cookie
Oatmeal Raisin
A classic!
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Oats, chocolate chips. No raisins!
Almond Glaze
Sugar shortbread cookie with our famous almond glaze. Cookie will reflect seasonal shapes.
Frosted Sugar
Sugar shortbread cookie topped with buttercream frosting. Cookie will reflect seasonal shapes.
Smores
Chocolate chip cookie topped with marshmallows, hershey chocolate bar, graham cracker drizzled with milk chocolate.
Salted Caramel
Customer favorite! Sugar cookie with caramel bits, drizzled with in house salted caramel glaze and sprinkled with cinnamon and sugar.
Turtle
Soft and chewy! It has chocolate chips, caramel bits, pecans and drizzled in milk chocolate.
Dirty Panda
Customer favorite! Fudge fantasy cookie half dipped in white chocolate and topped with crushed Oreo's.
Snoopy
Chocolate chip cookie half dipped in milk chocolate.
Brownie
Customer favorite! Soft and chewy, topped with powdered sugar.
Salt Mine
Customer favorite! Our classic salted caramel cookie drizzled with dark chocolate and a pinch of sea salt.

Rotating Flavors
C.O.W.W
Customer favorite! Craisins, walnuts, white choclate and Oats
Lemondoodle
Sugar cookie topped with house made lemon glaze.
Chocolate Frosted Brownie
Our original brownie topped with chocolate buttercream frosting.
Molasses
A soft gingersnap cookie rolled in raw sugar. Perfect blend of ginger & cloves!
White Chocolate Mac
This cookie is soft, chewy and loaded with macadamia nuts and white chocolate chips
Doodlechip
Snickerdoodle + Chocolate Chip = Doodlechip

Sandwich Cookies
Vanilla Avalanche
Classic chocolate chip cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle.
Chocolate Avalanche
Classic chocolate chip cookies with chocolate buttercream frosting in the middle.
M&M Daydreamer
Two M&M cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle.
White Out
Two snickerdoodle cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle.
Mary O
Two fudge fantasy cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle.
Chewbacca
Two fudge fantasy cookies with peanut butter frosting in the middle.
Darth Vader
Two fudge fantasy cookies with chocolate buttercream frosting in the middle.
Cookie Dough Delight
Two chocolate chip cookies with edible cookie dough in the middle.
Wookie
A fudge fantasy cookie and chocolate chip cookie with edible cookie dough in the middle, dipped in milk and white chocolate.
Oatmeal creme pie
Oatmeal raisin cookies with buttercream frosting

Gluten Free, Keto and Vegan
Gluten free Chocolate Chip
Soft and chewy! Made with Pamela's gluten free flour. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
Gluten free Snickerdoodle
Sugar cookie topped with cinnamon and sugar. Made with Pamela's gluten free flour. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
Gluten free Salted Caramel
GF sugar cookie topped with caramel balls, drizzled in salted caramel glaze and sprinkled with cinnamon sugar mix. Made with Pamela's gluten free flour. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
Gluten free M&M
GF chocolate chip cookie topped with M&M's. Made with Pamela's gluten free flour. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
Gluten free Vanilla Avalanche
Two GF chocolate chip cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle. Made with Pamela's gluten free flour. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
Vegan, Gluten and Soy free Chocolate Chip
Soft and chewy. Made with Pamela's vegan/gf flour. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
Keto and Gluten free Chocolate Chip
Soft like a muffin! Very low in sugar and carbs. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.

Edible dough cups and Take and Bake dough tubs
Edible Chocolate Chip
Safe to consume raw, there's no eggs.
Edible Just Dough
Exactly how it sounds :)
Edible Chocolate Chip Brownie Batter
Edible chocolate chip dough with brownie batter mixed in. Brownie batter contains egg whites.
Edible M&M Just Dough
Edible cookie dough with M&M's.
3lb Chocolate Chip dough tub
Our classic chocolate chip dough that makes 48 - 1oz cookies.
3lb M&M dough tub
Our classic M&M dough tub makes around 48-1oz cookies.
3lb Rollout dough tub
Shortbread cookie dough that you can turn into any cutout shape you'd like. Add frosting to make the perfect frosted sugar cookie.

Gift Option and Special Order
BIG Cookie
12" Chocolate Chip cookie with frosted message *please specify what you would like written on cookie
Avalanche BIG Cookie
2 - 12" Chocolate Chip cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle. *please specify what you would like written on the cookie.
Small Party Tray
50 - 1oz nice assorted cookies. Perfect for parties or work meeting.
Large Party Tray
100 - 1oz nice assorted cookies
Best Seller's Box (12)
12 - 1/4lb cookies, 2 Almond Glaze, 2 Salted Caramel, 2 S'more, 2 Turtle, 2 Brownie, 2 Vanilla Avalanche
Best Seller's Box (24)
24 - 1/4lb cookies, 4 Almond Glaze, 4 Salted Caramel, 4 S'mores, 4 Turtle, 4 Brownie, 4 Vanilla Avalanche
Cookie Basket (12)
12 - 1/4lb individually bagged and sealed cookies. Need a personal message attached? Just include what you want it to say.
Cookie Basket (24)
24 - 1/4lb cookies individually bagged and sealed. If you'd like a personal message please let us know when ordering.
Gift Card
Gift card valid at Old Town location only
Cookie Box (12)
12 - 1/4lb cookies. 2, Chocolate Chip, 2 M&M, 2 Snickerdoodle, 2 Oatmeal Raisin, 2 Brownie, 2 Vanilla Avalanche
Cookie Box (24)
24 - 1/4lb cookies, 4 Chocolate Chip, 4 M&M, 4 Snickerdoodle, 4 Oatmeal Raisin, 4 Brownie, 4 Vanilla Avalanche

Beverages
Milk
Pint of Farmer's All Natural 2%
Chocolate Milk
Nesquik - 8oz
Red Bull
8.4 oz can
Sugar Free Red Bull
8.4oz can
Arrowhead Water
23.7 oz bottle
Coconut Water
11oz
Coke
12oz can
Diet Coke
12oz can
Sprite
12oz can
Dr. Pepper
12oz can
Mountain Dew
12oz can
Spindrift

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+68 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+67 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

These cookies are delicious and very large. Good luck trying to leave with only 1. Also love the rewards punch cards. Buy 6 get 1 free is fun! So many choices, they have something for everyone.
September 2025
I wish I could post more and better picture of the amazing looking cookies but they have mysteriously vaporized!!! The picture I'm posting is all that is left. Kidding aside these are the best cookies on the front range. Better than Crumbl. Better than anything. Simply the best cookies.

And the service at the shop is friendly and helpful! I love this place. In fact I love it TOO much. I wish I could come here every week but being pre diabetic I...
June 2025
Not only are the cookies absolutely delicious, the team is excellent as they helped us build a custom order for our wedding. Our wedding guests continue to talk about how delicious the cookies were. If you haven't been, you need to stop by when you're in Old Town Fort Collins!
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Austin's American Grill - 100 W Mountain Ave
American, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar - 123 N College Ave
Seafood, American, Cajun/Creole, Gluten-Free, New American
Comet Chicken - 126 W Mountain Ave
Chicken, Salad, American, New American, Vegan

Mary's Mountain Cookies

123 N College Ave STE 106, Fort Collins, CO 80524
(970) 482-5655