Old Town Churn Ice Cream
234 N College Ave Unit D, Fort Collins
(970) 689-3843
Customers' Favorites
Banana Pudding Ice Cream
Pint of Ice Cream
Ice Cream Float
Strawberry
Regular
Sorbet
Kids
Cake
Menu
Photos
+38 photos
+37 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
The ice cream was just okay, and while the seating area is a nice spot to relax, it probably won’t be our first choice next time. The cones definitely seemed store-bought, and for the price, I think they should be homemade.
The Churn in Old Town Fort Collins is a beautiful shop with a great vibe and friendly staff, but for me, the ice cream itself doesn’t quite live up to the hype. Don’t get me wrong—it’s good, and you’ll enjoy it—but if you’ve tried some of the top-tier ice cream spots in Colorado, you may notice it’s not quite as creamy, rich, or flavor-balanced as the very best out there.
The texture can be a little icy at times rather than ultra-smooth, and...
The texture can be a little icy at times rather than ultra-smooth, and...
I would have left these guys a 5 star but as a long time customer, I was disappointed in the fact they no longer do homade ice cream cones yet charge you the same price as before. As usual though they have great flavors but the waffle cones they now order are absolutely garbage.
Great and friendly staff and really they have one of the best flavors of ice cream in the fort collins area! Bring back your waffle cones!
Great and friendly staff and really they have one of the best flavors of ice cream in the fort collins area! Bring back your waffle cones!
You May Also Like
The Exchange - 200 N College Ave
![]()
Food Court
Yellow Crunch - 234 N College Ave Unit B-1
![]()
Colombian, Vegan
La piadina - Italian Flatbread Sandwiches - 234 N College Ave Unit B3
![]()
Pizza, Food Trucks, Italian