Papa Johns Pizza

731 E Harmony Rd, Fort Collins
(970) 207-1000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Terance Lewis

Pizza is sometimes too salty and sauce tastes bitter.

Joann Gonzales

Went to pick up my pizza on 7/9/25 at 4 pm . There were only 2 workers that were both setting outside smoking, marijuana and cigarettes. One guy came in with shoulder length black hair. High as kite . He goes to get my order and I asked him if I could have a few extra pepper please . He walks around.
The corner sticks his hand in the bowl of peppers and brings me a handful and puts it in the box. I look at him and said you just pick those up with your bare hand after coming from outside .not even washing your hands . He got mad at me said I'll remake. He goes and washes his hands. He starts slamming things on the counter. The other worker came in. He was very nice and very helpful. Also very high. I will not be coming back to this Papa.John's location i felt very uncomfortable 😕

jjsmobilesolution

Good pizza and service

Iryna Gorbunov

This location has the laziest workers ever!!!
Expect to wait for your order 40+ minutes while the workers sit there and chat doing nothing.

Chris

Today 2/9/2025 super Bowl i ordered a large stuff crust Pie! For delivery.. food was Hot 🔥. And came 15 earlier than expected. Plz keep Rockin!

RP6 K

Easy pick up with customer service, and I got free cheese sticks. Affordable and better quality than most pizza places in Foco.

jami warren

We order from the Papa John's quite often. Last evening I ordered a pizza for my granddaughter - they have dairy free crust and we get no cheese (dairy allergy). Anyway, they had to use DoorDash for delivery. Long story short, the driver lied and said she hand delivered the pizza. She did not!!!! I called Papa John's and the very nice manager said they'd redo it and delivery it within 40 min. 25 min later we had our pizza with tons of pepperoni! They went out of their way and it is so appreciated! Great pizza, excellent service!

Kaden Hodo

Super fast. Super tasty.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Kurtis Benedict

I picked up my pizza in stores, so I can't say anything about the delivery services. Walked in and metal music was just blasting which isn't a problem for me, but seemed odd for Papa John's lol.

From the quick interaction I had with staff, everything seemed good. This review is more about Papa John's itself.

Why was this $34? Did Papa John's forget it's place? This is a pizza chain, and nothing about it is 'quality' like 'pizza casbah', 'Krazy karls', or 'mama ronis'. The fact that you can get a local pizza that is far superior in terms of quality, and similar (if not better) for quantity, this is pathetic. Domino's is cheaper, and falls in the same category.

Again, this has more to do with Papa John's as a whole, more than this store. I used a coupon online, otherwise this would have been close to $50. What is Papa smoking? There is no way this is worth $50 even with inflation being so high.

Don't spend money on a place that clearly has become delusional with what it's products are.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Jim Grindinger

Slightly better than frozen pizza.

Food: 2

Service: 3

Rover Christenson

The Pizza was nice and fresh and cooked to perfection. Nathan did a great job as he appeared to be running the entire restaurant by himself. This location truly needs to hang on to an employee like that. Much thanks for a positive experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Mark Bonjean

The manager Eleanor is fantastic. Always ensures things are perfect

Food: 5

Service: 5

S.S

Closing cook on 6/28 @ ~11:30pm with the dark hair and birthmark was ON IT. They were swamped with last minute, closing orders but he kept the best attitude. Cheesesticks came out perfect. Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Terrie J Schuh

Sad that when I call to order a pizza in Loveland, Colorado I get a call line from another county, then that entity can’t communicate to the location in my town to get the pizza made and delivered. Funny how papa John’s has figured out how to cheaply pay people in other countries to take my money but hasn’t figured out how to relay the order. Cheap corporate greed… gross .

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

GeriLynnElizabeth Dent-Stebnitz (Big Homie)

I absolutely love that pizza actually anything they make is delicious I love it cuz they lay on the trees nice and thick the way I like it the crust just got its own unique flavor and so on your items that you like veggies meat etcetera and it all Blends into one hell of a pie and that's just not on occasion that's every time and that also applies to all the other delicious foods that they put out. Prices a r e just about the same in every pizza place, they are moderately priced and it's the same everywhere you go because of inflation. The service is awesome the people working there really care about what they're doing and you can be guaranteed you're going to get one hot pizza that's hot and steaming with delicious flavor calling your name. People of all ages are welcome come as you are or Order ahead. They're fast friendly and your food is hot and fresh come check them out and enjoy! Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Cheddar Cheesesticks, Bacon Cheesesticks, Chocolate Brownie, Pizza, Cinna Pull Apart, Double Chocolate Chip Brownie

Loading...