Papa Johns Pizza

1275 E Magnolia St Suite H, Fort Collins
(970) 482-7979

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Heather Starkey

Always friendly staff

Claire Gregory

I truly appreciate this location. I wish I remembered her name but I believe she is a manager; she went above and beyond on customer service!! I made a mistake on my own order and she did her best to help me out! The kids and I are super happy and thankful for the brownies. Thank you for making my day better!!!

Melissa Toler

Why is there only ever two employees in the store It is so busy and the waits are so long they're 10 minutes or more. This is very inconvenient.

dylanthevilain11

Staff is cool, and food came out perfect.

Crystal Cruz

I had my pizza delivered a few minutes ago. They had door dash deliver because it would have been faster. They were understaffed and still managed to make my pizza on time and fresh it was cook to perfection! Doordash text me to update me on the details. They both did a great job! Thank you all so much. When you order food and it comes in on time and is still hot is rare these days. Keep up the good work!

Adam Schmidt

Worst Papa Johns pizza place. They need to spend an extra 15 seconds making their pizzas. It isn’t because they are busy either. Poorly managed place, with an owner that will always say that they were out when the bad pizzas happen (and they will). I highly recommend going to any other pizza location than this spot. I have received my last undercooked pizza with all of the toppings in the middle of a three inch wide crust.

This location needs a new manager or needs to be shut down.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Melo

Pizza was more crust than actual pizza. It was also undercooked so we tried reheating it in the oven only to be left with pizza slop as the crust couldn’t even hold the ingredients in it. Usually we have a good experience in this location but this was the worst and totally ruined my appetite.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Iva York

We order from papa johns a few times a week, my daughter loves pizza. It's always fresh, the employees are always nice and friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda Grindele

I’m a longtime Papa Johns lover but was really disappointed by the pizza we picked up from this location last night. Unevenly distributed toppings (should’ve been pepperoni all over, with black olives on one half and jalapeños on the other half) and the cheese was nasty thick. We each ate a slice and then agreed to just toss the rest of it. Idk if they were understaffed or what but this was very poorly made.

Tom Kofer

They outsourced my delivery to door dash. It sat in the driver's car without a hot bag for almost an hour. I received a product that was 54 degrees according to my meat thermometer. Literally inedible

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ken Greves

Just picked up my Shaq a Roni and the pizza looks like a medium instead of an XL and the wings look like they came from a baby chicken. Spent $30 and got maybe $20 value will not get anything from this store ever again.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Alex & Kevin (T.A.A.)

The first pizza I received was a disaster—undercooked in the middle, with unevenly scattered toppings and drenched in grease. The garlic butter sauce cups were crushed during delivery, leaking everywhere. I also ordered 4 extra peppers, but instead of a reasonable amount, it looked like they threw 4 handfuls into the box with no care at all.

When I called to complain, the customer service was unfriendly and dismissive. They reluctantly sent a replacement pizza, but it was still undercooked and just as disappointing as the first one. The whole experience felt like I was being punished for even speaking up.

Since then, I decided to give them another chance. The pizza was better this time, but the attitude from the staff was still apparent and not pleasant. While the quality of the food improved, the poor customer service makes me hesitant to order from this location again. They need to work on both their consistency and how they treat their customers.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Bianca Cardinale

Why is the pizza so small now! I tried to do contact form but idk order # lol delicious but way too much for shrinking pizza lol Is it just me or is everything getting smaller?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Mitchell Tanner

I walked in they asked me me name. They never went to where the pizza were ready. Stood there for 25 mins. They finally walked over to ready food. Pizza was over there the whole time. Horrible service

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

juan raymundo

I order a pizza. And the most important ingredients was missing marinera sauce and jalapeños the employee looked high and thought it was funny papajohns need new employees because this

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...