Papa Johns Pizza

1275 E Magnolia St Suite H, Fort Collins
(970) 482-7979

Recent Reviews

Andy

Garbage company

Tatyana Horton

I tried ordering a pizza and they hung up on me twice, horrible customer service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Madison Tolley

Pizza, cheese fries and chocolate chip cookie came fast! Delivery guy was super nice food was solid!!!! Zero complaints will order from them again!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephane Cosby

Gluten free crusts are not good; gluten free folk can’t be too picky, they’re never very good, but these were just gross. topping choices profoundly limited. Prices higher than average.Order was wrong (Why was 1/2 of a pizza made with white sauce?).Just a completely regrettable experience.Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free crusts available, only small size, worst I’ve ever had.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

Joe Martin

The Cheesy Calzone Epic Stuffed Crust pizza is excellent. Love the drive-up pickup feature, especially in cold weather.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Not Applicable

Charged me $60 for pizzas that were never

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Chris Kilbourne

Can’t get a delivery order correct. 2 times now it’s been wrong. Lady acts very like it’s not her fault when I call. Go somewhere

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Ray Fowler

I ordered 2 large pizzas and 16 wings with my order totaling over $60.00. Upon receiving my delivery, the order was wrong. I called the store to have them redeliver my order. I was advised the manager is not present and we need to wait until the morning. I drove to the store to ask them to remake the order or gave me a refund. I was denied a refund or remake of the order because the manager was not present. Horrible customer service! They could’ve at least remade the order, but by them not wanting to refund me is appalling. I will be contacting Corporate to refund me for my order including my delivery fee and tip.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kim Henkemeyer

I ordered a pizza, wings, and bites. Order went to door dash. I never received my order but someone else did. Called the store to find out what happened was told by manager to call door dash. I never got my refund from either place. Never ordering from either again.

Service: 1

Hembree M.

Do not waste your time ordering delivery from this location. I ordered a singular large pizza to be delivered to my home 1 mile away. I was charged and the pizza was not delivered after an hour. I called the manager, who had no idea what was going on and he had my pizza re-made and sent to me through a DoorDash driver who left pepperonis and jalapeño peppers all over my front porch. My left foot could run a restaurant more efficiently.

Yulia Avdeyeva

These guys have always done us very good with their timing and quality and friendliness ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

james miller

In the past, the delivery driver smashed my pizza by placing the 2 liter of diet pepsi on top of the pizza boxes. Which I let that transgression slide. However, today I ordered again and this time they did not bring me my 2 liter. This place is a joke and I will never order from here again. If I have a craving for pizza, I will swing by Little Caesar

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Harry Smith

I know it's not like the pictures but these are sad the jalapeños bites and the chicken parm are sad like a little kid put the togetherParking: Enough parking for the area

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Charlene Cannon

I ordered wings and I swear they went to Little Ceasars to get them they are so small no meat at all and no sauce ?

Wesley Roberson

Ordered a large stuft crust pizza, didn’t feel like driving so I had it delivered for a premium order total of $40+ for a single pizza. It shows up as pictured and I called to get another one sent out, shows up same thing as the one in the picture. Sent both pizzas back with the driver (whom I did tip cash as I felt bad for the back and forth.)Bottom line if there is a 6$ delivery fee, expectations to tip the driver and the pizza shows up looking like the two they tried delivering me all I can say is they were not able to hold up their end of the deal. So 2 hours later and no food I will say lesson learned. Just order a Slyce pizza and go pick it up, save time, probably pay less, and the pizza from Slyce is amazing.

Load More