Silver Mine Subs

1281 E Magnolia St, Fort Collins
(970) 493-6200

Recent Reviews

Sort by
S H

My son likes it so 5 star

Service: 4

Allison Smith

Name, name, name.

Abigail Morgan

I keep ordering sandwiches and they keep leaving off the olives and pickles. Ugh! They are ingredients listed on the DoorDash app. Won’t be ordering again.

Chase Knoll

I know how hard it is to make it in the food world so I rarely take the time to leave a negative review on any food business, this is actually my first negative review for a restaurant ever. The “homestake” was hands down the worst attempt at a cheesesteak I’ve ever eaten, and for $17.50 for a moderately sized sandwich, I’m astounded people opt for this restaurant over literally any other option I’ve ever had in Fort Collins. Bread smells like stale rice, the steak has the same dog food vibe that Burger King has. How is this your best selling deluxe sandwich?

Nici Barrett

Ordered ahead and our sandwiches were ready when we entered. We sat outside in the sunshine and enjoyed the portion size and flavors of our subs.

Parking: Easy access as it is located in a large shopping complex.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Angelo Theofanous

Came in for the first time while I was on my break. Got a Cowboy on wheat bread and a powerade. The older gentleman was incredibly friendly and honest as he helped me decide what to get, and the food turned out pretty damn good! They have a huge selection to choose from and a pretty cool decor of older western aesthetician. Would recommend to anyone looking to try a new sub shop. I'll definitely be returning.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

john wilson

Very disappointed. You use to be my go to late night. Never again will I eat here. Subs were horrible. Soup bad. Salad was the only fresh was the salad from the factory.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

jeffreydw1983

Ordered a dodge city with easy oil because last time they put way too much making the bread soggy and it was leaking everywhere. They put the same amount of oil on anyways, but this time the bread wasn’t cooked all the way. It was doughy in the middle and tasted awful. The other locations have been fine, but I’ll avoid this store in the future.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Maddie C

We originally ordered through DoorDash and didn’t get our order. We did get a refund through DoorDash. The managers also reached out and apologized for our experience and went above and beyond to make it right. We reordered our meal for delivery and everything was great! The sandwiches were huge and the potato salad was delicious! We will definitely be ordering again, we’ll just order through their website or call in instead of using DoorDash.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Broccoli Cheese Soup

Ethan Le

BEWARE OF THIS LOCATION!!! I came in 6/2 around 2:40 to order the most simple sandwich: a ham and cheese, and was met with overwhelming resistance. Two employees were working at the time, and nice older man and a very hostile, condescending, and unbothered lady. This lady cares more about insulting the customer than her job! She was the most
unaccommodating and unfriendly employee, and should be kept in the back far, far away from customers! This person creates terrible look for this location.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Lea Mikkelsen

Took my daughter here for lunch and we ordered two sandwiches. The kids sandwich had one slice of sandwich meat. The King Bullion I ordered had two slices of sandwich meat on it. We were majorly disappointed. I wish I had taken a picture of the pitiful kids sandwich with bread and one slice of meat that didn't even cover the whole piece of bread. We used to like it here but sadly we won't be back.

Anon

Locally owned and operated sandwiches made to order and and the more recent years they have added more healthy options to put on the sandwich

Vegetarian options: Sandwiches are made to order and can be customized however you like

Parking: Shirt parking lot with other businesses, I usually have no difficulty finding a spot close by

Wheelchair accessibility: The nearest business in the shopping center to the handicap parking spaces with wheelchair isle, wheelchair accessible entrance.

Food: 5

Dan Shannon

I had the Dodge City and it was amazing!!! The food is awesome!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melissa Shannon

Salads are amazing, and great service!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ray Walters

Ordered a sub from door dash the other day, and it was the fastest delivery I ever had, also the sub was fantastic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...