Pathetic everything. Please don’t waste your money.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jaela Poythress
I am a regular at Tony's and have been a customer for almost 4 years, along with my husband. Recently as of 4/12/2024 my husband and I had a sad experience solely because of a bouncer working at Tony's, named Robert. This bouncer was working during 11:00pm with the other bouncer Carlos. Carlos is a phenomenal bouncer that always does his job with integrity and great customer service. The bouncer Robert has been quite discriminatory towards my husband and I on numerous occasions. We've been in lines before with Robert and he has never spent as much time with other customers checking their IDs as he has ours. My husband and I both have valid Colorado IDs, and are able to access all bars in Fort Collins with ease. He inspected my husband's ID for nearly 10-15 minutes on two occasions with no valid reason as to why his ID needed this amount of time compared to the seconds he takes to check other customer's IDs. He started instigating my husband about the height listed on his driver's license. We have never seen this bouncer inspect any other customer's ID information like this, nor any other bouncer do this to another customer. My husband and the other bouncer Carlos let Robert know that this should not be an issue. The DMV has verified my husband's identification information as valid, as it is posted on his ID, so this bouncer shouldn't be questioning my husband about the validity of information on his ID that the DMV has validated.... It's very odd because this bouncer never does this with any other customer, each time we are in line. It feels very discriminatory and makes us feel like we are being singled out and are unwelcome. This is bizarre because I have met the owner of Tony's, Tony himself l, and he is very friendly and creates a welcoming atmosphere for his clientele. But this bouncer Robert is hostile. We tried to address the the situation and he acted like he did not care and dismissed us, regardless of this feedback being shared with his boss Tony himself. Carlos was the only bouncer to hear us out and validate our experience. There are plenty of respectful bouncers working at Tony's, such as Carlos and Paul who are dedicated and create a safe environment for customers, that it is sad that this bouncer Robert doesn't care at all to put the same effort for Tony's cliente. We enjoy our time here at this bar but not when this bouncer creates unnecessary conflict with us, and sadly we do not think we can continue coming to this bar due to the discriminatory and biased environment that this bouncer creates for us. I am confident that a conversation from Carlos was had with this bouncer directly, as he planned, and I hope the owner Tony is able to address this bouncer directly too. I would hate if this bouncer were to tarnish the good reputation that the Tony's bar has for being a fun and enjoyable place. I hope this bouncer can prove to be more respectful and fair with Tony's cliente in the future.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
SC Photography
let me tell you about Tony’s in Fort Collins, straight up, it’s like a slice of the Big Apple right here in Colorado. I rolled up to Tony’s, and damn, the vibe took me back to hitting up those hole-in-the-wall joints in NYC. The aroma of freshly baked pizza hit me as soon as I stepped in, and I knew I was in for a treat.Listen, if you’re craving that authentic New York City pizza experience, Tony’s is where it’s at. Their pies are the real deal, with that perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness in the crust, and the sauce? Oh man, it’s like a flavor explosion in your mouth.But yo, let’s talk about those $1 cheese slices on Tuesdays. I’m telling you, it’s like they’re practically giving away slices of heaven. Where else you gonna find a deal like that? Nowhere, that’s where.So if you’re on the hunt for legit NYC-style pizza in Fort Collins, Tony’s is the spot. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. Just make sure you come hungry and ready to devour some of the best pizza this side of the Hudson. Peace!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries, Pizza by the Slice, Carne Asada Fries
Lucas Araujo
After spending $50 I had to go through the humiliation of being kicked out because I was dancing too well. I'm never coming back here again ? at least in my house I can drink and dance to my heart's content without being kicked out. Go to Bondi instead
lacey p.
I would do negative stars but I literally ran like Jake sparrow to Tony's (fucking sober) and they said I was "too drunk" to come in and there was some drunk girl dancing on the bouncer?? Ok what the f!!! Please get some new and improved ( with a sense of humor) peeps and let us weirdos in!? Judgy much???? Only Judy can judge me. Enough said!
James Beam
Jimmie did well, buy firing the whole staph they haveca good team now i had alot of problems there bouncers abusing there authority it got me in trouble but it's a great bar and smart
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Gyro
Ben O
Classless dive. They employ petty thugs as "doormen", a euphemism for bouncers with chips on their shoulders. Unproved, they will start trouble with patrons, shoving them, running roughshod over people's civil liberties. When my buddy tried stepping in to defend me from one. They called the police claiming he "assaulted" them. Absolute lies. Fort Collins Police will immediately side with these criminal personalities regardless of facts.I encourage anyone looking for a peaceful evening with friends to avoid this place like the plague. It's only trouble. FYI: They own/run the Whiskey tasting room next door. Avoid it too.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Megan Olsen
Just got shots but they did make a good lemon drop.
Waitress was fine. DJ was a total douche. No need to be rude because I want to hear a song. Place
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
A D
Great deal for the price! Pizza by the slice and it’s wonderful! Such a unique spot to walk up and order a slice and a big one at that.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
Nicole Murphy
The workers were very nice and the food was great. The gummy bear and blue Otter Pop shots were absolutely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lunar Lycan
Manager loves his job more then himself hope he can heal one day!
Service: 1
Christine Sperry
Great if you're a teenager, annoying if you live or sleep within a 10-mile radius. They BLAST music on Monday karaoke nights- it was keeping our baby up until 2am a couple blocks away. When we eventually walked over to ask them to turn down the volume, they actually turned it UP! We couldn't believe it
Not bad for late night pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice bar, service, and atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pathetic everything. Please don’t waste your money.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I am a regular at Tony's and have been a customer for almost 4 years, along with my husband. Recently as of 4/12/2024 my husband and I had a sad experience solely because of a bouncer working at Tony's, named Robert. This bouncer was working during 11:00pm with the other bouncer Carlos. Carlos is a phenomenal bouncer that always does his job with integrity and great customer service. The bouncer Robert has been quite discriminatory towards my husband and I on numerous occasions. We've been in lines before with Robert and he has never spent as much time with other customers checking their IDs as he has ours. My husband and I both have valid Colorado IDs, and are able to access all bars in Fort Collins with ease. He inspected my husband's ID for nearly 10-15 minutes on two occasions with no valid reason as to why his ID needed this amount of time compared to the seconds he takes to check other customer's IDs. He started instigating my husband about the height listed on his driver's license. We have never seen this bouncer inspect any other customer's ID information like this, nor any other bouncer do this to another customer. My husband and the other bouncer Carlos let Robert know that this should not be an issue. The DMV has verified my husband's identification information as valid, as it is posted on his ID, so this bouncer shouldn't be questioning my husband about the validity of information on his ID that the DMV has validated.... It's very odd because this bouncer never does this with any other customer, each time we are in line. It feels very discriminatory and makes us feel like we are being singled out and are unwelcome. This is bizarre because I have met the owner of Tony's, Tony himself l, and he is very friendly and creates a welcoming atmosphere for his clientele. But this bouncer Robert is hostile. We tried to address the the situation and he acted like he did not care and dismissed us, regardless of this feedback being shared with his boss Tony himself. Carlos was the only bouncer to hear us out and validate our experience. There are plenty of respectful bouncers working at Tony's, such as Carlos and Paul who are dedicated and create a safe environment for customers, that it is sad that this bouncer Robert doesn't care at all to put the same effort for Tony's cliente. We enjoy our time here at this bar but not when this bouncer creates unnecessary conflict with us, and sadly we do not think we can continue coming to this bar due to the discriminatory and biased environment that this bouncer creates for us. I am confident that a conversation from Carlos was had with this bouncer directly, as he planned, and I hope the owner Tony is able to address this bouncer directly too. I would hate if this bouncer were to tarnish the good reputation that the Tony's bar has for being a fun and enjoyable place. I hope this bouncer can prove to be more respectful and fair with Tony's cliente in the future.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
let me tell you about Tony’s in Fort Collins, straight up, it’s like a slice of the Big Apple right here in Colorado. I rolled up to Tony’s, and damn, the vibe took me back to hitting up those hole-in-the-wall joints in NYC. The aroma of freshly baked pizza hit me as soon as I stepped in, and I knew I was in for a treat.Listen, if you’re craving that authentic New York City pizza experience, Tony’s is where it’s at. Their pies are the real deal, with that perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness in the crust, and the sauce? Oh man, it’s like a flavor explosion in your mouth.But yo, let’s talk about those $1 cheese slices on Tuesdays. I’m telling you, it’s like they’re practically giving away slices of heaven. Where else you gonna find a deal like that? Nowhere, that’s where.So if you’re on the hunt for legit NYC-style pizza in Fort Collins, Tony’s is the spot. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. Just make sure you come hungry and ready to devour some of the best pizza this side of the Hudson. Peace!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries, Pizza by the Slice, Carne Asada Fries
After spending $50 I had to go through the humiliation of being kicked out because I was dancing too well. I'm never coming back here again ? at least in my house I can drink and dance to my heart's content without being kicked out. Go to Bondi instead
I would do negative stars but I literally ran like Jake sparrow to Tony's (fucking sober) and they said I was "too drunk" to come in and there was some drunk girl dancing on the bouncer?? Ok what the f!!! Please get some new and improved ( with a sense of humor) peeps and let us weirdos in!? Judgy much???? Only Judy can judge me. Enough said!
Jimmie did well, buy firing the whole staph they haveca good team now i had alot of problems there bouncers abusing there authority it got me in trouble but it's a great bar and smart
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Gyro
Classless dive. They employ petty thugs as "doormen", a euphemism for bouncers with chips on their shoulders. Unproved, they will start trouble with patrons, shoving them, running roughshod over people's civil liberties. When my buddy tried stepping in to defend me from one. They called the police claiming he "assaulted" them. Absolute lies. Fort Collins Police will immediately side with these criminal personalities regardless of facts.I encourage anyone looking for a peaceful evening with friends to avoid this place like the plague. It's only trouble. FYI: They own/run the Whiskey tasting room next door. Avoid it too.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Just got shots but they did make a good lemon drop.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Waitress was fine. DJ was a total douche. No need to be rude because I want to hear a song. Place
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great deal for the price! Pizza by the slice and it’s wonderful! Such a unique spot to walk up and order a slice and a big one at that.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
The workers were very nice and the food was great. The gummy bear and blue Otter Pop shots were absolutely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Manager loves his job more then himself hope he can heal one day!
Service: 1
Great if you're a teenager, annoying if you live or sleep within a 10-mile radius. They BLAST music on Monday karaoke nights- it was keeping our baby up until 2am a couple blocks away. When we eventually walked over to ask them to turn down the volume, they actually turned it UP! We couldn't believe it
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1