I was excited to try this place but was sketched out by the menu. There are too many options (a very good thing if you're staying and have a big party like we did, so not a complaint!) Tried the pizza with green chili and cream cheese (I don't want to butcher the name) and it was PHENOMENAL. Cheese was so stretchy. It was hot but not a burn the roof of your mouth hot. It was literally perfect. A gorgeous nostalgic stop as well, I might be a 90s kid, but good lord, everything here brought me back to how my mom and dad raised me. I'm definitely coming back if I end up in Fort Collins. (!!Apologies for not moving all the tables back before I left, I was unsure of where some of the tables came from and there was another party where the others were supposed to go and didn't want to intrude!!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Root Beer Float, Green Chile
GilletteSkater
Strange place. We ordered one appetizer and a large pizza, total was $38 without drinks. There were no open tables at the time, so we asked to do takeout. A party behind us notified us that they won’t be needing their table, the cashier overheard and handed me a number to take to the table. The table was quickly taken by other customers before we could get there since it’s free for all situation. We witnessed 2-3 parties leave, and staff didn’t clear or clean tables. After 10 minutes, I cleared and cleaned a table when I spotted some cleaning supplies by the soda machine. We waited for over a half an hour and watched people get their food who ordered after us. I walked up to the front and the lady grabbed my pizza from the back. It was cold and soggy. I complained and they remade our appetizer. We ate the pizza anyways, and it was mid. I came here based on the good reviews, but have y’all never had decent pizza? Ingredients were lacking in quality. Plus I could see into the kitchen easily. Nobody was wearing gloves. I saw a lady scratch something off of her shirt, and then grab a huge amount of cheese and throw it on a pizza. Gross. Bathrooms were also not well maintained. Grimy lil place for kids and man-children. At least the crust and ranch weren’t half bad. Genuine arcade cabinets help the atmosphere, TMNT Turtles in time was fun to revisit. But clean your restaurant guys. I’m surprised the health inspector hasn’t shut them down.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ariel Alexander
Great service, yummy pizza, and the 80s memorabilia was so cool! The autographs were awesome to see and I enjoyed playing the arcade games. My mom and I will definitely visit again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Totally 80s Supreme Pizza
Kevin Green
Second time being here. Drive 2 hours just for the nostalgia. Service was ok. Noone at the counter at the counter for the first 5 minutes. Biggest issues was cleanliness of the restaurant and the bathrooms are now run down. With millions in one of a kind collectibles I would think cleanliness of the dinning area would be top notch. Not just around the merch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Specialty Pizza, New Wave Rave Pizza, Flamin' Hot Cheeto Pizza, Yippee Ki Yah Mother Clucker Pizza
Kelsey Rogers
Honestly the atmosphere is what really makes this place stand out. From all the 80s classic memorabilia covering almost every inch of the walls. Accompanied by 80s music videos playing in the background. Definitely brings back all the nostalgia. I also really like the unique merchandise they offer. Overall I would say their pizza was decent. I like the wide variety of specialties they have to choose from. I had the Yippe Ki Yay Mother Clucker and I wasn’t a huge fan of the garlic sauce base. I did enjoy the unique topping combinations though. Almost felt like it was lacking something. Perhaps a bit more drier than I expected. Wish I would have switched to the red sauce instead.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Megan Jones
Fantastic! Great pizzas, wonderful museum of 80s memorabilia with movie props, food product containers and music items. I loved it and they play 80s music videos the whole time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pizza
Kyla T
Awesome/fun place with really good food
Christina Hoffman
Highly recommend this place!!The atmosphere is therapy their food is the Perfect mixture of Eccentric and Delicious!It doesn't matter if this place triggers every great childhood moment or makes you wish you were from the 80'sYou get a slice of Outta this world experience every single time!It never gets old!!Fort Collins Staple And MUST See to Eat hands Down!!!
Randy Guthmiller
They were busy when we arrived, so the service was not that great. Food and atmosphere totally made up for it though. Had a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Flamin' Hot Cheeto Pizza, Wings
4 Star pizza, but a 5 star atmosphere. Genuinely a good time, though the pizza itself isn't the draw here. It's good, not
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Chris M
This place is just pure fun. Pizza is delicious, the crew is friendly, and while it can be busy there's so much to look at that the time flies by. Can't recommend this place enoughKid-friendliness: Our 6 year old son loves the 80's montage videos, the star wars action figures, the arcade and prize dispenser as well. There's some 80's-style "raciness" to some of the videos, but nothing over-the top, and cerrtainly not racy by today's standards.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Totally 80s Supreme Pizza
Robin Alvarez
We would highly recommend this pizzeria to any visitor seeking out the best
Food: 5
Sabrina Newman
One minute I'm visiting my son in Colorado at a pizza joint,, and then im transported back to high school dances at Union Grove ISD #classof90. #80spizza. Grandgirls love the bathroom, grandson loved grouch,, so your never too old or young to visit...everyone was awesome there as
I was excited to try this place but was sketched out by the menu. There are too many options (a very good thing if you're staying and have a big party like we did, so not a complaint!) Tried the pizza with green chili and cream cheese (I don't want to butcher the name) and it was PHENOMENAL. Cheese was so stretchy. It was hot but not a burn the roof of your mouth hot. It was literally perfect. A gorgeous nostalgic stop as well, I might be a 90s kid, but good lord, everything here brought me back to how my mom and dad raised me. I'm definitely coming back if I end up in Fort Collins. (!!Apologies for not moving all the tables back before I left, I was unsure of where some of the tables came from and there was another party where the others were supposed to go and didn't want to intrude!!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Root Beer Float, Green Chile
Strange place. We ordered one appetizer and a large pizza, total was $38 without drinks. There were no open tables at the time, so we asked to do takeout. A party behind us notified us that they won’t be needing their table, the cashier overheard and handed me a number to take to the table. The table was quickly taken by other customers before we could get there since it’s free for all situation. We witnessed 2-3 parties leave, and staff didn’t clear or clean tables. After 10 minutes, I cleared and cleaned a table when I spotted some cleaning supplies by the soda machine. We waited for over a half an hour and watched people get their food who ordered after us. I walked up to the front and the lady grabbed my pizza from the back. It was cold and soggy. I complained and they remade our appetizer. We ate the pizza anyways, and it was mid. I came here based on the good reviews, but have y’all never had decent pizza? Ingredients were lacking in quality. Plus I could see into the kitchen easily. Nobody was wearing gloves. I saw a lady scratch something off of her shirt, and then grab a huge amount of cheese and throw it on a pizza. Gross. Bathrooms were also not well maintained. Grimy lil place for kids and man-children. At least the crust and ranch weren’t half bad. Genuine arcade cabinets help the atmosphere, TMNT Turtles in time was fun to revisit. But clean your restaurant guys. I’m surprised the health inspector hasn’t shut them down.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
Great service, yummy pizza, and the 80s memorabilia was so cool! The autographs were awesome to see and I enjoyed playing the arcade games. My mom and I will definitely visit again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Totally 80s Supreme Pizza
Second time being here. Drive 2 hours just for the nostalgia. Service was ok. Noone at the counter at the counter for the first 5 minutes. Biggest issues was cleanliness of the restaurant and the bathrooms are now run down. With millions in one of a kind collectibles I would think cleanliness of the dinning area would be top notch. Not just around the merch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Specialty Pizza, New Wave Rave Pizza, Flamin' Hot Cheeto Pizza, Yippee Ki Yah Mother Clucker Pizza
Honestly the atmosphere is what really makes this place stand out. From all the 80s classic memorabilia covering almost every inch of the walls. Accompanied by 80s music videos playing in the background. Definitely brings back all the nostalgia. I also really like the unique merchandise they offer. Overall I would say their pizza was decent. I like the wide variety of specialties they have to choose from. I had the Yippe Ki Yay Mother Clucker and I wasn’t a huge fan of the garlic sauce base. I did enjoy the unique topping combinations though. Almost felt like it was lacking something. Perhaps a bit more drier than I expected. Wish I would have switched to the red sauce instead.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Fantastic! Great pizzas, wonderful museum of 80s memorabilia with movie props, food product containers and music items. I loved it and they play 80s music videos the whole time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pizza
Awesome/fun place with really good food
Highly recommend this place!!The atmosphere is therapy their food is the Perfect mixture of Eccentric and Delicious!It doesn't matter if this place triggers every great childhood moment or makes you wish you were from the 80'sYou get a slice of Outta this world experience every single time!It never gets old!!Fort Collins Staple And MUST See to Eat hands Down!!!
They were busy when we arrived, so the service was not that great. Food and atmosphere totally made up for it though. Had a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Flamin' Hot Cheeto Pizza, Wings
Really cool experience! Would recommend ?
Restaurantji Recommends
4 Star pizza, but a 5 star atmosphere. Genuinely a good time, though the pizza itself isn't the draw here. It's good, not
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
This place is just pure fun. Pizza is delicious, the crew is friendly, and while it can be busy there's so much to look at that the time flies by. Can't recommend this place enoughKid-friendliness: Our 6 year old son loves the 80's montage videos, the star wars action figures, the arcade and prize dispenser as well. There's some 80's-style "raciness" to some of the videos, but nothing over-the top, and cerrtainly not racy by today's standards.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Totally 80s Supreme Pizza
We would highly recommend this pizzeria to any visitor seeking out the best
Food: 5
One minute I'm visiting my son in Colorado at a pizza joint,, and then im transported back to high school dances at Union Grove ISD #classof90. #80spizza. Grandgirls love the bathroom, grandson loved grouch,, so your never too old or young to visit...everyone was awesome there as
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really cool place to visit and excellent pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5