Black Cat Pizza
221 E Bridge St, Hotchkiss
(970) 872-8080
Customers' Favorites
Garlic Pesto Cheese Bread
Pizza Toppings
Crawford Pizza
Meat Pizza
Hummus
Menu
Photos
+6 photos
+5 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We, like everyone else, have heard rave reviews for Black Cat for months. Perhaps because we're pizza snobs from Chicago we don't share the enthusiasm. To be fair, we didn't try any of the custom pizzas because we don't like a lot of garlic, which figures prominently in most of the menu's descriptions. We order the same ingredients everywhere we go. On our pizza they were all fresh, and the Italian sausage was better than what we usually find in Colorado....
So I’m only giving 4 starts cause of the recent change in some things. Everything is still great quality and totally worth it though.I’m not going to go into what all they changed but it just happened to be my favorite and some really unique options. One of the reasons they stood out from the other pizza places.But still all and all the place is well worth it and still has plenty of things to choose from. Definitely recommend going here if you like pizza and want fresh quality...
This place is great! Been here a few times as I travel through for work. I’ve had the pizza and wings and have never been disappointed! After I ordered my pizza today I saw they had a Philly that sounded amazing. I will definitely try it next time. They also had some great looking dessert options, but I was afraid they wouldn’t travel as well. Service was friendly and quick. Waited 10-12 minutes for an amazing, fresh, pizza to go. Would highly recommend to anyone passing through...
You May Also Like
Third Bowl Homemade Ice Cream - 230 E Bridge St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream, Wholesalers
Two Four Six Coffee - 246 E Bridge St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly
Taco Hut - 301 E Bridge St
![]()
Mexican