CREAM Belmar - Handcrafted and Warm Ice Cream Sandwich

I enjoyed the selection and versatility available to craft your own dessert. Since I have a soy allergy, I was disappointed to discover that even the most basic butter cookie was NOT free of soy. This restricted my options, and I settled for their very delicious vanilla ice cream.

Good but cookies were really hard. That not what I expected with an icecream sandwich could not bite through it very hard. ???

I was really excited to visit this place from what I saw on the website. It is so much different in the store. I prefer other ice cream places. I ordered birthday cake on a waffle. My fiancé ordered the apply to my pie on a snickerdoodle ice cream. While he was eating it he found glass in his ice cream. The employee he mentioned it to didn’t seem very concerned. But she did give us a refund on his ice cream and told the other employee to check the carton for more glass.

Warmed ice cream! Talking about confusing! You can have u ice cream in a warm cookie or waffle or just ice cream!

Great for gluten free treats. Single scoop is very generous!

Kind of hit or miss. The mint ice cream I had at this location was grainy and weird, but the catered ice cream sandwich I got at a work function was great!

I went in, the employee explained the menu. I got a big order and he did great on each order. The Hot Fudge sundaes were awesome!! Everyone was totally satisfied

Pretty expensive for ice-cream and also everything in Belmar Has an extra tax charged. I do love the Cookie ice-cream sandwiches. Wish the prices were reduced a bit. I’d probably Be back more if they were. My friends all enjoyed this spot when we checked it out also.

Very interesting take on ice cream sandwiches. Very good flavors and the owner is super nice and friendly. Very highly recommend going here.

This place is AMAZING. Way better than cold stone. Everything we got here was phenomenal. The staff was really friendly too. I got a strawberry birthday cake milk shake and my boyfriend got an espresso cookie dough one and they were both soooo yummy

Okay, my review is similar to others. Cute little shop with seating and a lot of options.

Ordered 2 milk shakes, the guy who was helping us said that he only had 1 cup to make the snake. The others were dirty. Seriously. He just didn't want to go clean them, until a lady working there ask him too. Wasn't impressed with the flavor of the ice cream.

It was ok. I would rather go to Little Man or Sweet Cow though. The first sample I tried had a freezer burn taste. I asked for a cream-agato but they said they were unable to make it. I ended up with a cookie sundae which was ok.

They have options for gluten and dairy allergies!

The service was great and the concept was very unique. The owner was the one that helped us and her service and friendliness really made for a great visit. I got the brownie sandwich which was tasty and my husband tried the do'sant which he also enjoyed.