Such delicious desserts! I come here frequently and enjoy every single pie I've ever tried. It seems a bit small, but I've never seen it too crowded where I couldn't sit down. Such an amazing place to go for a cheap dessert!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies, Banana Cream Pie, Caramel Apple Pie, Lemon Meringue Pie, Assorted Pies, Blackberry Pie, Boston Cream Pie, Chocolate Cream, Blueberry, Rocky Road Pie
DEX Comedy Magic
These really are the best pies in Denver metro. Cherry and blueberry pies are the bomb here. Super friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charles Cox
This neighborhood place is my go-to place for cookies, and has been for 20 years. Always friendly service. They carry Magills ice cream in store as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Rebecca McGill
Lovely shop. Great employees. Awesome food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna Gutierrez
We stop by on occasion for a slice of pie and coffee if we are in the area running errands and have usually enjoyed the pie. This time, we stopped for lunch and decided to split a sandwich, a cup of soup each, a drink and we were going to share a slice of pie (we hadn't decided on the flavor so we were going to order it separately). The person rang up the pastrami on rye with Swiss as $19.99. I asked if this was correct and she said yes but you could just each get the meal which includes half a sand, cup of soup and slice of pie for $16.99 each.Long story short, lunch was $40 with tip. For a half sand and cup of soup with pie. And the sandwich was a few slices of meat, nothing spectacular. If we ever stop here again, it surely won't be for a lousy lunch.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Sue Perez
I got a gf cherry pie during Cider Days and decided to call to order one for Christmas...a week ahead of time. You can't order gf online and when you call you are told a week is not enough time. There is literally nothing online to say when to order one. If you aren't gf apparently they can serve you.
N W
The guy at the counter was super rude and acted like a paying customer was a nuisance for asking basic questions. Pie is pretty expensive and when we got home and actually tasted the peach pie we got the peaches were not fully cooked and didn’t have much flavor. Super disappointed. Wanted to support a small business but probably won’t be back
Becky Staggers
Best pies in the Denver metro area. Delicious sandwiches/soups and other sweet treats are also available. I would highly recommend anyone try this place. You won't be disappointed.
I have been coming hear for years since I was a child pies are always great and service is also great. I have comment for Yolanda review if you really want to impress your friend make your own pie. If not stop sending nasty
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rosie cheeks
I had to give this a 1 star because of the owner. I came in today to pick up a pie order and he's yelling at his employees as they were running around trying to work as hard as they could. If im being honest, because of the owner, ill NEVER order from here again.
I have been coming here for years and the Owners are wonderful. They make handcrafted pies that are unique, high quality, and priced fairly. I suggest ordering in advance for the holidays because they sell out quickly and easily every year. Thanks again!!!
James V.
Food was below average this time around. Pecan pie crust was hard, dry, and bland. The filling was fairly good but didn't care much for the molasses after taste. Cherry pie filling was fairly good. The crust again was bland but did have better texture than the pecan pie. Perhaps they are using a cheap processed shortening for their pie crusts?? The toffee cookie was pretty bland with no noticeable flavor off toffee. Again, tastes like a cheap shortening they are using for the desserts. About 2 stars for the food and 4 stars for the service.
Joe P.
Great service and amazing pie!!! Will definitely be back when I'm In the area. Had the double crust cherry pie with a vanilla latte!!!
Ross Warnell
Best Key Lime pie this side of Key West. Just one word of caution though - going into the store is walking into a culinary ambush. Will power is useless, you might as well enjoy the delights therein.
Tatiana Gubenko
Really, really good tasting pies... Docking a star because I had a hair in mine... I get it, it happens... Wear a hair net?
Such delicious desserts! I come here frequently and enjoy every single pie I've ever tried. It seems a bit small, but I've never seen it too crowded where I couldn't sit down. Such an amazing place to go for a cheap dessert!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies, Banana Cream Pie, Caramel Apple Pie, Lemon Meringue Pie, Assorted Pies, Blackberry Pie, Boston Cream Pie, Chocolate Cream, Blueberry, Rocky Road Pie
These really are the best pies in Denver metro. Cherry and blueberry pies are the bomb here. Super friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This neighborhood place is my go-to place for cookies, and has been for 20 years. Always friendly service. They carry Magills ice cream in store as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Lovely shop. Great employees. Awesome food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stop by on occasion for a slice of pie and coffee if we are in the area running errands and have usually enjoyed the pie. This time, we stopped for lunch and decided to split a sandwich, a cup of soup each, a drink and we were going to share a slice of pie (we hadn't decided on the flavor so we were going to order it separately). The person rang up the pastrami on rye with Swiss as $19.99. I asked if this was correct and she said yes but you could just each get the meal which includes half a sand, cup of soup and slice of pie for $16.99 each.Long story short, lunch was $40 with tip. For a half sand and cup of soup with pie. And the sandwich was a few slices of meat, nothing spectacular. If we ever stop here again, it surely won't be for a lousy lunch.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
I got a gf cherry pie during Cider Days and decided to call to order one for Christmas...a week ahead of time. You can't order gf online and when you call you are told a week is not enough time. There is literally nothing online to say when to order one. If you aren't gf apparently they can serve you.
The guy at the counter was super rude and acted like a paying customer was a nuisance for asking basic questions. Pie is pretty expensive and when we got home and actually tasted the peach pie we got the peaches were not fully cooked and didn’t have much flavor. Super disappointed. Wanted to support a small business but probably won’t be back
Best pies in the Denver metro area. Delicious sandwiches/soups and other sweet treats are also available. I would highly recommend anyone try this place. You won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies, Banana Cream Pie, Strawberry Rhubarb, Coconut Cream Pie, Soups
I have been coming hear for years since I was a child pies are always great and service is also great. I have comment for Yolanda review if you really want to impress your friend make your own pie. If not stop sending nasty
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had to give this a 1 star because of the owner. I came in today to pick up a pie order and he's yelling at his employees as they were running around trying to work as hard as they could. If im being honest, because of the owner, ill NEVER order from here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I have been coming here for years and the Owners are wonderful. They make handcrafted pies that are unique, high quality, and priced fairly. I suggest ordering in advance for the holidays because they sell out quickly and easily every year. Thanks again!!!
Food was below average this time around. Pecan pie crust was hard, dry, and bland. The filling was fairly good but didn't care much for the molasses after taste. Cherry pie filling was fairly good. The crust again was bland but did have better texture than the pecan pie. Perhaps they are using a cheap processed shortening for their pie crusts?? The toffee cookie was pretty bland with no noticeable flavor off toffee. Again, tastes like a cheap shortening they are using for the desserts. About 2 stars for the food and 4 stars for the service.
Great service and amazing pie!!! Will definitely be back when I'm In the area. Had the double crust cherry pie with a vanilla latte!!!
Best Key Lime pie this side of Key West. Just one word of caution though - going into the store is walking into a culinary ambush. Will power is useless, you might as well enjoy the delights therein.
Really, really good tasting pies... Docking a star because I had a hair in mine... I get it, it happens... Wear a hair net?