Nestled away as a quaint gem, Antonio's Neighborhood Cafe is your go-to for authentic Italian fare with a creative twist. This cozy spot welcomes you with hearty portions and dishes reminiscent of old-world charm. The locally sourced bison with divine beblanch sauce and a rice pudding straight from grandma's recipe book are must-tries. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, epitomizing family-style service. The highlight? A visit from the chef himself, whose passion for his craft and care for his patrons shines through every dish. Don't miss out on the outdoor covered tent, perfect for summer evenings under the stars. Antonio's is not just a meal; it's an experience wrapped in the warmth of hospitality. A true hidden treasure, perfect for family and friends. Can't wait to return!
Jennifer Holman
I'm not a fan!! I've tried this place a couple of times and they just fail. My pizza was cold. I picked it up with the time frame. Also, they told me I couldn't get a thinner pizza? So chop some dough off and make it thinner. I worked as a pizza maker. You can always make it thinner. It was okay. But where they place the mozzarella is a thing. The owner should ask what the people want. Not what he wants. 2nd time I tried and he's lost at least this customer. I'm not stupid. He just refuses to make it the way his customers want it. I got carbonara pasta last time it was fatty and gross. He doesn't take time to do the work. time he didn't render proper. It was ick. What else is left to say? It's his way or the highway and You're left paying the bill. Mediocre at best. I wouldn't Even give it that.If you notice 3 pieces don't have cheese on them and when you do pick it up and the other slices have no cheese because it sticks with the other slice. Very little sauce so the rest the pizza has nothing. How is this good, Said no one ever.It's important to let others choose how they want pizza. Not how you want them to eat their pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Carbonara
Edward Bargel
I have been here twice, and both times were excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jeff dutter
Ordered a supreme pizza and it had no sausage.
Billy R.
I dropped in tonight and ordered a 12 inch meat lovers pizza. A simple order fairly priced. I did take out. I thought the pizza was a really solid medium crust pizza exquisitely made with quality ingredients. It was well balanced. Even the leftovers were delicious!
Hessam H.
Excellent pizzas. The Gluten Free crust is very good. The regular pizzas are fantastic. Fresh ingredients and great quality. They really take pride in the food they serve. Clean restaurant, comfortable seating and nicely decorated. The staff is friendly and attentive to your needs.
Cyndy R.
Four of us went to dinner here last night and loved it! Every entree we ordered was delicious! Our waiter, Josiah, went out of his way to make it a memorable meal. Great service! We enjoyed the Eggplant Rollatini, Veal on pasta which was exceptional (I allow myself to have veal once a year), and Branzini (mild fish). Everything was delicious! Can't wait to go back. Next time I'll order the Tiramasu for dessert!
Richard Forrest Phillips
Good food. It's a mid-level Italian place, but has a fairly diverse menu. If I have one criticism, it's that the service is sometimes slightly slow because they seem to be understaffed.
Really enjoyed our lunch here. I eat very healthy and they accommodated nicely - big salad. Family had pizzas which they enjoyed. Service was efficient and pleasant. Nice little Italian place with upscale ingredients.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads
G K
Owner or manager is very very rude. He needs to step out of the way because he's got great people that work for him they're always very cheerful and always very polite.
I have lived in Colorado for 17 years and LOVE Italian food, this is now my favorite place!!! Exceptional food (baked ziti and chicken fettuccini), service we unassuming, professional, efficient, friendly. The lunch was so filling we all took leftovers home and also purchased four different deserts, all were delicious! Will definitely be back! Thank you!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
K Niles
Absolutely loved it! The staff was great and the good was wonderful and a great atmosphere!!! We did the bottomless mimosa/bloody Mary brunch at I highly recommend it. Plenty of food! It was great to be able to make a reservation as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leah P.
It was okay. We went for brunch which was maybe our mistake. I haven't tried their pizza, so maybe they do that really well. Brunch was not a big hit. They kept bragging about their green chili, and I found it to be a bit sour. I got the Mob Boss frittata and it was over cooked and the tomato sauce was extremely watery so my frittata ended up swimming in tomato water by the first bite. The menu states all the ingredients for the frittata and then says served with roasted potatoes which I expected to be on the side with how it was worded. They were in the frittata. My daughter got the kids traditional breakfast and the bacon was over cooked and she asked for an egg over easy and got a plate full of scrambled eggs. When we asked for over easy eggs, they brought out a bowl of two eggs over easy by swimming in a pool of truffle oil! We hate truffle oil! They never told us that was going to be poured on top, and even our server was confused why the cooks served it that way. It stunk up our table so we have our server remove it and my daughter never did her her eggs. Their bacon was also way over cooked. The type of bacon that was just under burnt and wouldn't snap, but rather crumble when you take a bite. Bacon should have a chew. My son had the breakfast burrito which was decent. Overall, I don't think we'd be back for brunch, but maybe for a slice someday. All the waitstaff were extremely friendly and helpful. Food also came out quickly. Their tables are way too small for a part of 4. It was hard to put all the food down without knocking into something.
Kimberly Bannick
There is passion in this restaurant. From the food to the service. It seems like it hasn't gotten enough notice, but I can honestly say that I'm glad it's near home and we'll definitely be back!
Nestled away as a quaint gem, Antonio's Neighborhood Cafe is your go-to for authentic Italian fare with a creative twist. This cozy spot welcomes you with hearty portions and dishes reminiscent of old-world charm. The locally sourced bison with divine beblanch sauce and a rice pudding straight from grandma's recipe book are must-tries. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, epitomizing family-style service. The highlight? A visit from the chef himself, whose passion for his craft and care for his patrons shines through every dish. Don't miss out on the outdoor covered tent, perfect for summer evenings under the stars. Antonio's is not just a meal; it's an experience wrapped in the warmth of hospitality. A true hidden treasure, perfect for family and friends. Can't wait to return!
I'm not a fan!! I've tried this place a couple of times and they just fail. My pizza was cold. I picked it up with the time frame. Also, they told me I couldn't get a thinner pizza? So chop some dough off and make it thinner. I worked as a pizza maker. You can always make it thinner. It was okay. But where they place the mozzarella is a thing. The owner should ask what the people want. Not what he wants. 2nd time I tried and he's lost at least this customer. I'm not stupid. He just refuses to make it the way his customers want it. I got carbonara pasta last time it was fatty and gross. He doesn't take time to do the work. time he didn't render proper. It was ick. What else is left to say? It's his way or the highway and You're left paying the bill. Mediocre at best. I wouldn't Even give it that.If you notice 3 pieces don't have cheese on them and when you do pick it up and the other slices have no cheese because it sticks with the other slice. Very little sauce so the rest the pizza has nothing. How is this good, Said no one ever.It's important to let others choose how they want pizza. Not how you want them to eat their pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Carbonara
I have been here twice, and both times were excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a supreme pizza and it had no sausage.
I dropped in tonight and ordered a 12 inch meat lovers pizza. A simple order fairly priced. I did take out. I thought the pizza was a really solid medium crust pizza exquisitely made with quality ingredients. It was well balanced. Even the leftovers were delicious!
Excellent pizzas. The Gluten Free crust is very good. The regular pizzas are fantastic. Fresh ingredients and great quality. They really take pride in the food they serve. Clean restaurant, comfortable seating and nicely decorated. The staff is friendly and attentive to your needs.
Four of us went to dinner here last night and loved it! Every entree we ordered was delicious! Our waiter, Josiah, went out of his way to make it a memorable meal. Great service! We enjoyed the Eggplant Rollatini, Veal on pasta which was exceptional (I allow myself to have veal once a year), and Branzini (mild fish). Everything was delicious! Can't wait to go back. Next time I'll order the Tiramasu for dessert!
Good food. It's a mid-level Italian place, but has a fairly diverse menu. If I have one criticism, it's that the service is sometimes slightly slow because they seem to be understaffed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Insalata Caprese
Really enjoyed our lunch here. I eat very healthy and they accommodated nicely - big salad. Family had pizzas which they enjoyed. Service was efficient and pleasant. Nice little Italian place with upscale ingredients.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads
Owner or manager is very very rude. He needs to step out of the way because he's got great people that work for him they're always very cheerful and always very polite.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I have lived in Colorado for 17 years and LOVE Italian food, this is now my favorite place!!! Exceptional food (baked ziti and chicken fettuccini), service we unassuming, professional, efficient, friendly. The lunch was so filling we all took leftovers home and also purchased four different deserts, all were delicious! Will definitely be back! Thank you!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely loved it! The staff was great and the good was wonderful and a great atmosphere!!! We did the bottomless mimosa/bloody Mary brunch at I highly recommend it. Plenty of food! It was great to be able to make a reservation as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was okay. We went for brunch which was maybe our mistake. I haven't tried their pizza, so maybe they do that really well. Brunch was not a big hit. They kept bragging about their green chili, and I found it to be a bit sour. I got the Mob Boss frittata and it was over cooked and the tomato sauce was extremely watery so my frittata ended up swimming in tomato water by the first bite. The menu states all the ingredients for the frittata and then says served with roasted potatoes which I expected to be on the side with how it was worded. They were in the frittata. My daughter got the kids traditional breakfast and the bacon was over cooked and she asked for an egg over easy and got a plate full of scrambled eggs. When we asked for over easy eggs, they brought out a bowl of two eggs over easy by swimming in a pool of truffle oil! We hate truffle oil! They never told us that was going to be poured on top, and even our server was confused why the cooks served it that way. It stunk up our table so we have our server remove it and my daughter never did her her eggs. Their bacon was also way over cooked. The type of bacon that was just under burnt and wouldn't snap, but rather crumble when you take a bite. Bacon should have a chew. My son had the breakfast burrito which was decent. Overall, I don't think we'd be back for brunch, but maybe for a slice someday. All the waitstaff were extremely friendly and helpful. Food also came out quickly. Their tables are way too small for a part of 4. It was hard to put all the food down without knocking into something.
There is passion in this restaurant. From the food to the service. It seems like it hasn't gotten enough notice, but I can honestly say that I'm glad it's near home and we'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
Great service. Food is delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5