A Cake Come True

11169 E I-25 Frontage Rd, Firestone
(303) 834-8317

Recent Reviews

shane chatfield

I'm going to leave just one star as I never tasted the final product but here's why:My daughter lives in Las Vegas with her mother and it's been "different" for all of us going through a divorce. My daughter is coming for a visit the week of her birthday and is bringing her mom so I don't have to fly back and forth to get her and she really did not want to travel alone. The bakery near our house in Vegas is very busy but always makes time for tastings when it is birthday cake time for our two kids so my daughter asked if she could pick out her cake as is "usual" and normal. I found this place with great reviews but my daughter is arriving on Monday with her mother and leaving Friday. Birthday is Wednesday and Thanksgiving is Thursday. Shop is closed Monday and Tuesday so that really only leaves Wednesday to get a cake for Wednesday and that doesn't really allow to taste, I was told I would need to place an order without allowing my daughter the simple request of having a little normalcy. I think no response would have been better than this one-"Customers don’t typically ask me to provide a tasting I prior.I provide an amazing product and I always try to be accommodating with someone’s needs and requests. But my time is limited and valuable, so you can imagine how a small birthday cake would not interest me in giving a white glove service as I do with my wedding clients, especially during the busiest holiday of the year. "I don't care how they taste if this is how you view a little girl's birthday request, it isn't always about money and who knows how much dad would have been willing to pay had that been the response but this is what I was left with.

Brittany Brinckerhoff

Lisa at A Cake Come True did a wonderful job for our wedding cake! She had so many great cake and frosting flavors for us to pick from - it was super fun to do the cake tasting, and we knew that any flavor combo was going to be tasty. She executed the cake just like we had envisioned!

Brittany Mollica

Lisa at A Cake Come True did a wonderful job for our wedding cake! She had so many great cake and frosting flavors for us to pick from - it was super fun to do the cake tasting, and we knew that any flavor combo was going to be tasty. She executed the cake just like we had envisioned!

Ramon and Jeanettes Playlist

So it was my daughter's 25th birthday and I wanted it to be very special because she is an incredible young woman so I called a cake come true ordered a cake explained a little about my daughter and they made the most beautiful cake I could have ever asked for!!! My daughter and everyone else loved it!! Thank you so much for making this possible!! Youare a dream come true!!!

Nevin Lambert

Ordered a Signature cake online from Tucson, AZ. A couple of emails confirming details and 5 days later picked up a wonderful and beautiful birthday cake. Great taste and beautiful design, together! Hard to find. Thank you!

Natalie Zamudio

Ridiculously flavorful, super cute, and exactly what I wanted! I sent a request over their website with a description of what I wanted and they did not disappoint. Hope to use them for future events and have already recommended to friends. Thank you!

Claire Kelly

Lisa at A Cake Come True was incredible to work with - the tasting experience was so much fun, and guests raved about the cake all night. Lisa is truly an artist, and we love the hand drawn mockup of the cake she did before the wedding. We are already excited about our 1-year anniversary cake!

Allison Scott

Lisa and A Cake Come True were absolutely amazing for our special day! Our guests could not stop raving about the cake flavors and how gorgeous it turned out! Lisa was so easy to work with and made me feel completely at ease with the delivery and set up of our cake the day of. I sent her an example of what I wanted and she delivered to a T! Do yourself a favor and take go with A Cake Come True! You won't regret it!

Stefanie Morong

First of all I want to say she has amazing customer service. My husband picked up my cake today and when I opened up my front door to this BEAUTIFUL ARTISTIC CAKE my jaw dropped. This cake is absolutely stunning and I'm so happy to have this cake!!! Amazing birthday recovery!!!!

Ricardo Herena

A cake come true is amazing !! Lisa took such good care of our wedding, the cake sample kits were delicious ?. I personally ate the sample kit so fast I needed to lay down.On the day of, I was astonished at how gorgeous our cake was. Our guests ate every last bite, and we highly recommend Lisa for all your cake needs .

Adrianna Ukaj

This woman is remarkably talented and if you want art in a cake- look no further. We had a game of thrones theme cake and she did a spin off the fire and ice and nailed it. I let her surprise us and she went above and beyond. Also her cake is phenomenal. Everyone ranted and traced at how good the cake was as well. She’s a boss and I truly appreciate her being flexible about moving my date as I was a Covid bride and then got in to NP school.

Katie Stewart

We used A Cake Come True for our wedding cake! Lisa was amazing and gave us exactly what we asked for! We had a two tier cake with a different flavor for each tier. She let us try her flavors with two tasting boxes and my husband was obsessed and had the hardest time deciding what flavors to choose because they were all so good! Her designs are also incredible!! Highly recommend working with Lisa!

Heidi VanSparrentak

I love this bakery. Everything not only looks amazing but it tastes great too. I love having her make my sons birthday cakes. I give her the theme and she just runs with it and never disappoints. This year was The First Fiesta and #4 Spider-Man

Jenny R.

I was very impressed with my experience!!Lisa, the owner, was very accommodating and a gem when it came to my last minute order... Which was not a wedding cake so I'm not sure what this other review from Robin is all about that says that... I don't think that is true!My cake was absolutely gorgeous and exactly like the picture I provided. Reasonably priced. She also took the time to make macarons as a special order and I appreciated that so much because that's my favorite thing there!This place is wonderful for a small business! So much talent! I highly recommend A Cake Come True. You can tell that they put in so much effort and dedication and hard work!!!

Tamara Wilkinson

Lisa was so accommodating during the planning process! The cake was beautiful and she even offered to make my bride and groom an additional cake this week because they did not get around to eating any during their wedding. That's great service!

Load More