Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop
4212 S College Ave #101, Fort Collins
(970) 775-3321
Customers' Favorites
Birthday Cake
Key Lime Pie
Wedding Cake
Menu
Photos
+36 photos
+35 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We ordered a custom Paw Patrol cake for my son's 3rd Birthday and were not disappointed! The cake was exactly what we wanted, and they put so much care into making it special. It also tasted great! You can tell they use high quality ingredients. Thank you Buttermilk Bakery for making Birthday magic for my son!
I contacted this bakery four days before a surprise party and asked for a 3D cake that looks like a beholder monster from dungeons and dragons. I was a little worried that it might be too weird for them to get right, but holy smokes, they did a great job. The folks who work here were nice and pleasant to work with. Cake was delicious, too.
Buttermilk Bakery came through for us in a pinch. We called them a week before our baby shower to see if they could make us a few dozen dino and shark sugar cookies. They fit us into the schedule and the cookies turned out amazing! They looked just like the inspo we sent them and tasted amazing. We highly recommend them!
You May Also Like
Blackjack Pizza & Salads - 4206 S College Ave #107
![]()
Pizza, Salad, Chicken Wings
Starbucks Coffee Company - 4218 S College Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Chili House - 4200 S College Ave #110
![]()
Chinese, Thai