Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop
5748 S College Ave Unit D, Fort Collins
(720) 229-6494
Customers' Favorites
Birthday Cake
Key Lime Pie
Wedding Cake
Menu
Photos
+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I'm not really in the business of leaving reviews, but I've loved buttermilk pie my whole life and didn't expect the find the best one I've ever had in a Northern Colorado bakery. Cherish knows what she is doin' and driving past this place without stopping is a mistake.
I had forgotten to order a cake for my birthday and most shops are closed on Sunday. Even though it was last minute they agreed to make my small 6" cake for me. I couldn't be more grateful. I ordered on Friday for pick up Sunday. It wad a miracle for me. Also, it was soooooo good. I highly recommend them.
We ordered a wedding cake for our April wedding. It was fantastic! We had requested a mountain motif and we were not disappointed. They specially designed the cake for us. Their team were amazing to work with, while planning a wedding cross country. Definitely recommend the lemon filling it was so tasty. Couldn't have asked for anything else. Our guests are still talking about the cake months after the wedding.
You May Also Like
Deli Works - 6001 S College Ave
![]()
Sandwich Shop
Matt's Place - 6013 S College Ave
![]()
Bar, American, Dive Bar, Burgers, Bar & Grill
Ziggis Coffee - 6533 S College Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Coffee