Pretty solid pizza. Definitely better than Chain pizza places. The guy working there solo was super nice even though he had a ton of orders to work on. Service and food 5 star for sure.
AJ Garza
In the quiet mountain town of Pagosa Springs, long after most kitchens had closed and the stars hung heavy over the Rockies, I stumbled upon something… otherworldly.
Down on Talisman Drive—yes, the name fits—I found a lone, flickering light glowing from a tiny, near-forgotten pizzeria. Inside, in the shadows of this humble temple of dough and fire, stood a man. Not just any man. No. I had met the Obi-Wan Kenobi of pizza.
The place? Talisman Pizza. The hour? Midnight. The vibe? Mythic.
This culinary wizard worked alone, cloaked in flour and flame, his eyes holding the kind of wisdom that only comes from a lifetime of sauce-stained scrolls and sacred cheese rituals. As he crafted my pizza, he shared tales of his youth—epic, strange, beautiful tales that danced through the air like the scent of garlic and oregano. It felt less like ordering food, and more like being initiated into an ancient, delicious order.
And then—the pizza.
The crust? Crisp like truth. The cheese? A revelation. The sauce? Like liquid poetry sung by Italian angels.
I swear, the pepperoni alone could’ve made a grown man cry. I don’t know who this shaman of the slice truly is, but I left feeling blessed, changed, and desperately craving more.
I will return. Because some legends are crafting away I. The middle of the night.
Jay Cir
Awesome pizza! Loved the sauce and the fact that he uses real ingredients. Also met expectations for delivery time. I would definitely order from here again
Forrest Elliott
This pizza was delicious! We ordered for delivery and it arrived pretty quick and hot.
Zhuwane
The only place which was open late night! We loved our pizza
Armando Amaya (Mondo03)
This pizza was not my favorite. It was actually the last resort. Only place open late but I did not enjoy this at all. And pretty expensive for 1 pizza, $30.
JBF Racing
Horrible service - what a joke
Enrique Franco
I love his pizza and I love this guy's aura I felt he didn't like me but after a few times of ordering my usual cheese and pepperoni I find more about him and his energy that I love I feel good after too My girlfriend loves his pizza too some of the best in town and stays open late so that's a plus in this town The place gives me futurerama vibes and I can't tell you enough on how much I love this place I wanna just sit there and watch what he's watching I love the pizza man🔥🍕❤️
Haleigh
Excellent pizza! Crisp crust, delicious sauce and high quality toppings! Don't sleep on this place because it's awesome!
Aimee Lark
This is definitely the best pizza in town. It's been worth it every time and it's the only place that keeps consistent quality through and through.
Pretty solid pizza. Definitely better than Chain pizza places. The guy working there solo was super nice even though he had a ton of orders to work on. Service and food 5 star for sure.
In the quiet mountain town of Pagosa Springs, long after most kitchens had closed and the stars hung heavy over the Rockies, I stumbled upon something… otherworldly.
Down on Talisman Drive—yes, the name fits—I found a lone, flickering light glowing from a tiny, near-forgotten pizzeria. Inside, in the shadows of this humble temple of dough and fire, stood a man. Not just any man. No. I had met the Obi-Wan Kenobi of pizza.
The place? Talisman Pizza.
The hour? Midnight.
The vibe? Mythic.
This culinary wizard worked alone, cloaked in flour and flame, his eyes holding the kind of wisdom that only comes from a lifetime of sauce-stained scrolls and sacred cheese rituals. As he crafted my pizza, he shared tales of his youth—epic, strange, beautiful tales that danced through the air like the scent of garlic and oregano. It felt less like ordering food, and more like being initiated into an ancient, delicious order.
And then—the pizza.
The crust? Crisp like truth.
The cheese? A revelation.
The sauce? Like liquid poetry sung by Italian angels.
I swear, the pepperoni alone could’ve made a grown man cry. I don’t know who this shaman of the slice truly is, but I left feeling blessed, changed, and desperately craving more.
I will return.
Because some legends are crafting away I. The middle of the night.
Awesome pizza! Loved the sauce and the fact that he uses real ingredients. Also met expectations for delivery time. I would definitely order from here again
This pizza was delicious! We ordered for delivery and it arrived pretty quick and hot.
The only place which was open late night! We loved our pizza
This pizza was not my favorite. It was actually the last resort. Only place open late but I did not enjoy this at all. And pretty expensive for 1 pizza, $30.
Horrible service - what a joke
I love his pizza and I love this guy's aura
I felt he didn't like me but after a few times of ordering my usual cheese and pepperoni I find more about him and his energy that I love I feel good after too
My girlfriend loves his pizza too some of the best in town and stays open late so that's a plus in this town
The place gives me futurerama vibes and I can't tell you enough on how much I love this place
I wanna just sit there and watch what he's watching
I love the pizza man🔥🍕❤️
Excellent pizza! Crisp crust, delicious sauce and high quality toppings! Don't sleep on this place because it's awesome!
This is definitely the best pizza in town. It's been worth it every time and it's the only place that keeps consistent quality through and through.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Very delicious homemade pizza it’ll be your favorite one in town
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don’t sleeping on Talisman Pizza. This is great pizza from a good dude. Man’s out there making good pizza at late hours. Go get you some.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza and service. Open later than other places in town which was a nice surprise. Would definitely come back again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Supreme Pizza
We really enjoyed our pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, plus they deliver
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Medium Mighty Meaty Pizza
Loading...