Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
3024 N Elizabeth St, Pueblo
(719) 295-1695
Customers' Favorites
One-Topping Pub Pizza
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Chicago 7 Calzone
Hot Buffalo Wings
3 Cheese Lasagna
Chicken Tenders
Beer and Pizza
Personal Pizza
Fried Pickles
Italian Nachos
TAPROOM TAKEOUT DEALS
PARTY PACK FOR 4
Your choice of a Taproom Starter, any Large Pizza and a 6 Inch Big Cookie. Calories are per slice/piece.
PARTY PACK FOR 6
Your choice of a Taproom Starter, any 2 Large Pizzas and a 9 Inch Big Cookie. Calories are per slice/piece.
PIZZA PARTY TO-GO
Your choice of a Salad Platter and three Large Specialty Pizzas. Served with two Big Cookies. Serves 8-10. Calories are per piece/slice.
TAPROOM STARTERS
SICILIAN PEPPERONI ROLLS™
Signature dough, pepperoni, fresh green onions & cheese.
Served with signature red sauce.
BUFFALO CHICKEN ROLLS
Roasted chicken, Buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese, celery &
bleu cheese dressing baked inside our signature dough. Served with bleu cheese dressing.
CHICAGO CHEESESTEAK ROLLS
Our signature dough is rolled up with thinly sliced sirloin, onions, peppers, giardiniera, a drizzle of ranch and melted mozzarella.
TWISTED TENDERS
Chicken tenders marinated in buttermilk for 24 hours and
breaded in our Twisted seasoned flour blend. Includes choice of two sauces.
SPINACH ARTICHOKE DIP
Spinach, artichokes, mozzarella & parmesan cheeses, served with pasta chips.
BAVARIAN PRETZEL STICKS
Four Bavarian pretzel sticks served with mustard beer cheese sauce made with Guinness.
JALAPEÑO PRETZEL BITES
Baked jalapeño pretzel bites with mustard beer cheese sauce made with Guinness.
FRIED PICKLES
Beer battered and tossed in a zesty southern spice blend. Served with ranch or sweet Thai chili dipping sauce..
ITALIAN NACHOS
Pasta chips, mozzarella, pepper jack, pepperoni, pepperoncini, Italian sausage and our signature red sauce.
MOZZARELLA STICKS
Breaded and fried, served with signature red sauce.
CHEESY GARLIC BREAD
Toasted French baguette with roasted garlic and mozzarella, fresh basil and our signature red sauce.
CHI TOWN TRIO
Shareable selection of our famous Italian Nachos, Mozzarella Sticks and Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls™ served with signature red sauce.
WINGS
BONE-IN CHICKEN WINGS SHORT
Traditional bone-in, twice cooked chicken wings hand tossed in one of our signature sauces or dry rubs.
BONE-IN CHICKEN WINGS TALL
Traditional bone-in, twice cooked chicken wings hand tossed in one of our signature sauces or dry rubs.
BONELESS CHICKEN WINGS SHORT
Breaded all-white meat boneless chicken wings hand tossed in one of our signature sauces or dry rubs.
BONELESS CHICKEN WINGS TALL
Breaded all-white meat boneless chicken wings hand tossed in one of our signature sauces or dry rubs.
KEG OF WINGS
When a tall order of wings just isn't enough, the Keg of Wings features twice the wings, twice the sauce.
PIZZA - OLD CHICAGO FAVORITES
DOUBLE DECKERONI™
2x the pepperoni with shaved parmesan, a dash of hot sauce and parsley garnish.
CHICAGO 7™
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, red onions, black olives, green peppers, sliced mushrooms.
MEAT ME™
Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, Andouille sausage, pepperoni, green olive and fresh basil garnish.
FARMER'S DAUGHTER
Mozzarella, blistered tomatoes, pesto sauce, fresh arugula & a balsamic drizzle.
THE CLASSIC
Pepperoni, sliced mushrooms, Italian sausage & roasted garlic.
MEATBALL MUSHROOM
Mozzarella, meatballs, mushrooms, caramelized onions & parsley garnish.
THAI PIE
Sweet Thai chili sauce, mozzarella, pepper jack, cheddar, roasted chicken, mushrooms, red peppers, broccoli, sesame seeds, green onions & teriyaki sauce.
TUSCAN CHICKEN WITH SPINACH
Lemon garlic sauce, sun-dried tomatoes, applewood-spiced chicken, tomatoes, roasted garlic, fresh spinach tossed in a lemon vinaigrette.
VEGGIE 7
Red onions, green bell peppers, sliced mushrooms, black olives, artichoke hearts and red peppers.
NASHVILLE HOT CHICKEN
Mozzarella, alfredo sauce and crispy Nashville Hot chicken topped with ranch dressing, Sweet Thai Chili sauce and green onions.
CRAFT YOUR OWN PIZZA
Choose your crust & toppings.
TOP IT OFF
Select a sauce, served on the side for drizzle or dunks!
GRIDIRON PIZZA *LIMITED TIME*
Our thrilling beer cheese pizza sauce is topped with roasted chicken, red bell peppers, red onions, shredded cheeses and garnished with pepperoncini.
SALADS
SPINACH, CHICKEN & AVOCADO SALAD
Applewood chicken with avocado slices on spinach and romaine, tossed with sun-dried tomatoes and finished with Parmesan and black pepper. Enjoy with lemon-vinaigrette dressing.
ROASTED CHICKEN & APPLE WALNUT SALAD
Fresh greens, bleu cheese crumbles, apple slices, toasted walnuts, sun-dried cranberries and applewood-spiced chicken. Enjoy with creamy herb dressing.
OLD CHICAGO CHOPPED SALAD
Applewood chicken, peppered bacon, bleu cheese, tomatoes and fresh green onions, topped with avocado & tomato. Enjoy with creamy herb dressing.
BLACKENED CHICKEN CAESAR
Cajun-seasoned grilled chicken breast on a crisp caesar salad with shaved parmesan, diced tomatoes and croutons. Enjoy with caesar dressing.
SIDE GARDEN SALAD
Fresh greens, carrots, cucumbers, croutons & grape tomatoes. Choice of dressing.
SIDE CAESAR SALAD
Romaine, shaved parmesan, basil croutons & signature Caesar dressing.
SPECIALTY CALZONES
CHICAGO 7™ CALZONE
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, red onions, black olives, green peppers, sliced mushrooms, mozzarella, ricotta.
CHICAGO FIRE CALZONE
Pepperoni, salami, sweet Italian sausage, red peppers, red onions, pepperoncini, mozzarella, ricotta. Topped with a fresh jalapeño baked into the crust. Served with house-made ranch.
CRAFT YOUR OWN CALZONE
A blend of mozzarella, ricotta. Choose your favorite fresh toppings.
ENTRÉES & PASTA
FISH & CHIPS
Lightly fried beer battered cod served with tangy tartar sauce, coleslaw and fries.
MA'S LASAGNA
Silky ricotta, signature red sauce, Italian sausage, mozzarella & parmesan cheeses.
SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS
Italian sausage & ground beef meatballs over spaghetti, signature red sauce, fresh basil & parmesan cheese.
CHICKEN PARMESAN
Basil-parmesan crusted chicken breast, mozzarella, penne, blistered tomatoes, fresh basil & signature red sauce.
CHICKEN & BACON MAC
Cavatappi, golden beer cheese sauce, Applewood chicken, peppered bacon.
CHICKEN CARBONARA
Spaghetti tossed with garlic parmesan cream sauce, blistered tomatoes, basil, arugula, black peppercorn, and bacon.
CHICKEN PESTO ALFREDO
Penne alfredo with Applewood chicken, broccoli, blistered tomatoes, pesto and shaved parmesan.
HANDHELDS
BBQ BACON CHEDDAR BURGER*
USDA Choice ground chuck burger, signature BBQ sauce, melted cheddar & peppered bacon.
CLASSIC CHEDDAR BURGER*
USDA Choice ground chuck burger, melted cheddar on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato & mayo.
CRAFTED BEER BURGER*
USDA Choice ground chuck burger grilled with a light lager & smothered in caramelized onions & beer cheese sauce made with Guinness, crispy onion strings.
CALIFORNIA CHICKEN SANDWICH
Grilled chicken breast, Swiss & avocado, lettuce, tomato & a dab of house-made ranch on a brioche bun.
ITALIAN MELT
Sliced turkey, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella, on a toasted French roll with roasted garlic mayo, extra virgin olive oil, red wine vinegar, lettuce, tomatoes, & pepperoncini.
MEATBALL SUB
House-made meatballs, signature red sauce, torn basil, mozzarella.
CHICAGO CHEESESTEAK
Thinly sliced sirloin steak, sautéed peppers & onions, pepperjack & giardiniera.
TWISTED TENDER SANDWICH
Crispy chicken tenders with pickles and ranch.
NASHVILLE HOT TWISTED TENDER SANDWICH
Nashville Hot crispy chicken tenders with pickles and ranch.
DESSERT
DARK CHOCOLATE FUDGE CAKE
Four layers of chocolate cake & rich fudge frosting, whipped cream, powdered sugar & a strawberry.
CHEESECAKE WITH FRESH BERRIES
New York-style cheesecake on a graham cracker crust, fresh strawberries & blueberries, drizzled with strawberry sauce.
SCRATCH MADE COOKIZZA
All-butter cookie dough with giant morsels of chocolate freshly baked in our deep-dish pizza pan. Calories are per slice.
DRINKS
FOUNTAIN DRINKS
ICED TEAS
LEMONADES
Your choice of Classic, Strawberry, or Pomegranate.
RED BULL
Red Bull, Red Bull Sugar Free or Red Bull Watermelon
BAG OF ICE - 8 LB
KIDS MEALS
KIDS CHAMPION CHEESE PIZZA
A kid-sized version of our famous Chicago-style pizza.
KIDS BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA
Build your own kid-sized version of our Chicago style pizza. Pick any 2 toppings below.
MIGHTY CHEESEBURGER
Served with your choice of one side.
SPAGHETTI
Served with your choice of one side.
PENNE ALFREDO
Served with your choice of one side.
MAC N' CHEESE
Served with your choice of one side.
GRILLED CHICKEN TENDIES
Served with your choice of one side.
FRIED CHICKEN TENDIES
Served with your choice of one side.
COOKIE SUNDAE
Two scoops of vanilla ice cream with
chocolate syrup, whipped cream, chocolate
chip cookie chunks and a cherry on top!
KIDS GLUTEN SENSITIVE
*GS* MIGHTY CHEESEBURGER
A tasty cheeseburger served with your choice of one side. Go bunless or add a Smart Flour Foods Gluten Free bun for no additional charge.
*GS* TWISTED GRILLED CHICKEN TENDERS
Served with your choice of one side.
GLUTEN SENSITIVE
*GS* CLASSIC CHICKEN WINGS SHORT
Traditional bone-in, twice cooked chicken wings hand tossed in one of our signature sauces or dry rubs. Served with celery sticks and your choice of
house-made ranch or bleu cheese dressing.
*GS* CLASSIC CHICKEN WINGS TALL
Traditional bone-in, twice cooked chicken wings hand tossed in one of our signature sauces or dry rubs. Served with celery sticks and your choice of
house-made ranch or bleu cheese dressing.
*GS* BBQ BACON CHEDDAR BURGER*
Our steak burger brushed with our signature BBQ sauce, topped with melted cheddar cheese and peppered bacon strips. Go bunless or add a Smart Flour Foods Gluten Free bun for no additional charge. Served with deli-style pickles and choice of side.
*GS* CLASSIC CHEDDAR BURGER*
Our steak burger loaded with melted cheddar cheese. Go bunless or add a Smart Flour Foods Gluten Free bun for no additional charge.
Served with lettuce, tomato, mayo & deli-style pickles and choice of side.
*GS* CALIFORNIA CHICKEN SANDWICH
Grilled chicken breast topped with Swiss cheese and avocado, served atop lettuce, tomato and a dab of signature house-made ranch. Go bunless or add a Smart Flour Foods Gluten Free bun for no additional charge. Served with deli-style pickles and choice of side.
*GS* BLACKENED CHICKEN CAESAR
Cajun-seasoned grilled chicken breast on a crisp Caesar salad with Asiago cheese, diced tomatoes and croutons. Enjoy with Caesar dressing.
*GS* ROASTED CHICKEN & APPLE WALNUT SALAD
Fresh greens, bleu cheese crumbles, apple slices,
toasted walnuts, sun-dried cranberries and
applewood-spiced chicken. Enjoy with creamy herb dressing.
*GS* OLD CHICAGO CHOPPED SALAD
Applewood-spiced chicken, peppered bacon, bleu
cheese, tomatoes, and fresh green onions topped
with avocado and tomato. Enjoy with creamy herb dressing.
*GS* SPINACH, CHICKEN & AVOCADO SALAD
Applewood-spiced chicken with avocado slices
on spinach and romaine, tossed with sun-dried
tomatoes and finished with Parmesan and black
pepper. Enjoy with lemon vinaigrette dressing.
*GS* SIDE GARDEN SALAD
Fresh greens, carrots, cucumbers & grape tomatoes. Choice of dressing.
*GS* SIDE CAESAR SALAD
Romaine, grated Parmesan, and signature Caesar dressing.
CRAFT YOUR OWN CAULIFLOWER CRUST PIZZA
Made with real cauliflower, the CAULIPOWER® crust is a crispy, gluten-free, zero trans-fat, delicious option. Available in 10" size. Calories are per slice.
CHICAGO 7 CAULIFLOWER CRUST PIZZA
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, red onions, black olives, green peppers, sliced mushrooms. Made with CAULIPOWER® crust, available in 10" size. Calories are per slice.
MEAT ME CAULIFLOWER CRUST PIZZA
Loaded with Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, andouille sausage, pepperoni, green olive garnish and fresh basil. Made with CAULIPOWER® crust, available in 10" size. Calories are per slice.
DOUBLE DECKERONI CAULIFLOWER CRUST PIZZA
Covered coast-to-coast with a double dose of pepperoni, hot sauce and parsley. Made with CAULIPOWER® crust, available in 10" size. Calories are per slice.
THE CLASSIC CAULIFLOWER CRUST PIZZA
Pepperoni, sliced mushrooms, Italian sausage and roasted garlic. Made with CAULIPOWER® crust, available in 10" size. Calories are per slice.
TUSCAN CHICKEN WITH SPINACH CAULIFLOWER CRUST PIZZA
Lemon garlic sauce, sun-dried tomatoes, applewood-spiced chicken, bruschetta tomatoes and roasted garlic. Topped with fresh spinach tossed in a lemon vinaigrette. Made with CAULIPOWER® crust, available in 10" size. Calories are per slice.
THAI PIE CAULIFLOWER CRUST PIZZA
Our sweet Thai chili sauce with mozzarella, pepper jack & cheddar cheeses, roasted chicken, mushrooms, red peppers and broccoli. Topped with teriyaki sauce and sesame seeds, finished with fresh green onions. Made with CAULIPOWER® crust, available in 10" size. Calories are per slice.
VEGGIE 7 CAULIFLOWER CRUST PIZZA
Red onions, green bell peppers, sliced mushrooms, black olives, artichoke hearts and tomatoes. Made with CAULIPOWER® crust, available in 10" size. Calories are per slice.
SIDES
SIDE OF FRIES
SIDE OF SWEET POTATO FRIES
SIDE OF VEGGIES & DIP
ADDITIONAL SAUCES
UTENSILS
Fork
Knife
Spoon
Salt Packet
Black Pepper Packet
Mustard Packet
Ketchup Packet
Mayo Packet
Napkin
Straw
Photos
+97 photos
+96 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I really enjoyed this Old Chicago. The pizza is always hot, and our waiter is usually very attentive. Sometimes, the music selection is hit or miss, and it sounded like two different stations were battling each other, but with that being said, this place is one of my go-to places in Pueblo.
March 2025
Went to Old Chicago in Pueblo, CO on a date, it was at about 12:30pm. It was great! Atmosphere was good, they have an outdoor patio area for when it's nice out. Weather was perfect to be outside yesterday. The service was amazing, our server's name is Robin. She was on point. Very polite, very prompt.
Overall, everything about Old Chicago was fantastic.
Great for dates, family outings, business, or just catching up with old friends.
Thank you
Jose...
Overall, everything about Old Chicago was fantastic.
Great for dates, family outings, business, or just catching up with old friends.
Thank you
Jose...
February 2025
Italian nachos were pretty good and the cheese stick pizza appetizer was good as well. The fried pickles were very salt and over seasoned. Server was un-knowledgeable on their drink menu, and appeared distracted. Overall, it was a decent experience.
February 2025
You May Also Like
Jimmy John's - 3139 N Elizabeth St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant - 3240 N Elizabeth St
![]()
Italian, Salad, Soup
Red Lobster - 3306 N Elizabeth St
![]()
Seafood, American, Pet Friendly