Our waitress was so sweet. The first thing I noticed about this restaurant was how lively it was. This is clearly a popular spot for a reason. They brought out warm fresh bread. We had to restrain ourselves from filling up on bread so we could eat our main dish and not was it hard. I ordered a nice white wine and the scallop fettuccine. It was delicious. This place stands out because of its great service and lively atmosphere.
Janet W.
What an amazing culinary experience with our server, Jen. I made reservations in advance per the previous Yelpers. We found street parking on Ninth street. There is a happy hour at the bar from 5-6 pm with half off appetizers and $2 off draft beers. So I opted out of a table in the back and sat at one of the three high top tables by the bar. My husband and I tried the mozarella sticks with marina sauce, made in house and a winner! We also got the mussels in a delicious wine sauce which they gave us an extra basket of bread for dipping. My husband ordeted a local Yampa valley beer (red ale) on draft which he liked. I ended up getting the garlic shrimp appetizer and small Caeser salad for my dinner, but was so full I could only eat the garlic shrimp which came in a fabulous wine sauce that I ended up enjoying like a soup after my shrimp was gone. Both the mussels and garlic shrimp came with a large, crusty bread that was delicious for dipping. My husband got a small Front Range pizza which he could only finish half. Needless to say, we had no room for dessert, but all those sauces for dipping were too good to resist! Jen was the best server, helpful and engaging and warm. She should get an award for friendly servers! Come here for a fabulous meal that you will remember fondly!
Lydia Calkins
I would like to preface by saying that I am not a huge fan of Italian food. But this restaurant? Amazing. The service was great, the food was fantastic, the drinks were lovely. I am very happy to have gotten to try this place out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ritz Butler
The service and food were excellent! I will be back next season for sure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bison Lasagna
Lynne Clouser
Mazzola’s is absolutely delicious. I highly recommend the mussels appetizer as well as any of their pizzas and pastas. Their wine menu is also extensive and everything that I have tried has been excellent. I cannot say enough good things about the staff. They are knowledgeable and polite and timely! I will go back anytime I am in Steamboat and so should you.
First off the service was amazing all around. Our waitress Nikki was great and their hostess made sure we had a table quick even without a reservation. The food was amazing we ordered the cheesy bread as an app then the marinara spaghetti and bison lasagna. Both were AMAZING but we highly recommend the lasagna! Overall a great experience!
Jessica M.
Came for dinner while on vacation and it was very busy. Servers and manager seemed a little frazzled but they were friendly. Things took a little while bc of how busy it was, but it was worth the wait. We had crab dip app- good but lacked actual crab, shrimp scampi was great and full of shrimp, chicken piccata was devoured and chicken Parmesan was also very good. I will say, it was so uncomfortably warm in there. Be sure to wear layers you can take off! Overall, a great dinner and we will be back!
Dew Maur
Went on a Thursday night w/o a reservation. Normally that would be a huge mistake, making a reservation is a must. But we were lucky, there was space at the bar and with shuffling of some people there we were able to be seated. Food was fantastic, two buffalo lasagnas and one chicken piccata were received, but not finished, the portions are quite nice and large. Finished the meal with a nice cognac in a huge smile. I have one suggestion, put some port wine in the bar stock :)
The best chicken parm I have ever tried and I try it everywhere I can. All of our family’s food was excellent and great service too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathleen N.
We were scrambling looking for dinner locations and stumbled across Mazzola. They have an open bar area with a full service for those who was not able to get a reservation like we did. We walked in around 6pm and lucky for us, there was no one at the bar as well as the 3 small tables near the bar. The bartender was very helpful and knowledgeable, he answered all our questions and helped us decide what to get. He is the one who will serve as the server if you're seating in this area. We ended up getting a chicken Caesar salad and a custom made pizza with pepperoni, jalapeño, and pineapple (this is our go to and wanted to compare our usual toppings to a new restaurant). The salad was very good and the chicken we added in to the salad was very large! We ended up getting a medium pizza and for 2 people we still had some slices leftover to take home! The pizza was very good! The pizza style is on the thinner side which we were okay with just an FYI if you were looking for something else. I will definitely be coming back!
Quaint place in the lower level off the street. Excellent service and food quality. Our party of 6 adults enjoyed it very much.
Tim Fish
Had a great meal here the other night and our waitress Spencer was fantastic! She gave us several great reccomendations for town and did an amazing job making us feel at home.
What a great night at Mazzola's! Our waitress was excellent and the food delicious. Great energy in the place too! After dinner we walked around town and came back to Mazzola's for a drink. Guess we couldn't get enough! We'll be back on our next trip to Steamboat. And will recommend your place to others! 5 stars across the board!
Lauren Coe
Excellent food, fast service, & friendly staff. Would definitely recommend and go
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Piccata
CindyO
Absolutely spectacular! The food is delicious and creative and the service is wonderful. Our server was Sheila and she was delightful. She was very attentive and had great recommendations. We love this place - it's a true gem!
Our waitress was so sweet. The first thing I noticed about this restaurant was how lively it was. This is clearly a popular spot for a reason. They brought out warm fresh bread. We had to restrain ourselves from filling up on bread so we could eat our main dish and not was it hard. I ordered a nice white wine and the scallop fettuccine. It was delicious. This place stands out because of its great service and lively atmosphere.
What an amazing culinary experience with our server, Jen. I made reservations in advance per the previous Yelpers. We found street parking on Ninth street. There is a happy hour at the bar from 5-6 pm with half off appetizers and $2 off draft beers. So I opted out of a table in the back and sat at one of the three high top tables by the bar. My husband and I tried the mozarella sticks with marina sauce, made in house and a winner! We also got the mussels in a delicious wine sauce which they gave us an extra basket of bread for dipping. My husband ordeted a local Yampa valley beer (red ale) on draft which he liked. I ended up getting the garlic shrimp appetizer and small Caeser salad for my dinner, but was so full I could only eat the garlic shrimp which came in a fabulous wine sauce that I ended up enjoying like a soup after my shrimp was gone. Both the mussels and garlic shrimp came with a large, crusty bread that was delicious for dipping. My husband got a small Front Range pizza which he could only finish half. Needless to say, we had no room for dessert, but all those sauces for dipping were too good to resist! Jen was the best server, helpful and engaging and warm. She should get an award for friendly servers! Come here for a fabulous meal that you will remember fondly!
I would like to preface by saying that I am not a huge fan of Italian food. But this restaurant? Amazing. The service was great, the food was fantastic, the drinks were lovely. I am very happy to have gotten to try this place out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The service and food were excellent! I will be back next season for sure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bison Lasagna
Mazzola’s is absolutely delicious. I highly recommend the mussels appetizer as well as any of their pizzas and pastas. Their wine menu is also extensive and everything that I have tried has been excellent. I cannot say enough good things about the staff. They are knowledgeable and polite and timely! I will go back anytime I am in Steamboat and so should you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bison Lasagna, Tiramisù, Calamari, Pesto, Chicken Piccata
First off the service was amazing all around. Our waitress Nikki was great and their hostess made sure we had a table quick even without a reservation. The food was amazing we ordered the cheesy bread as an app then the marinara spaghetti and bison lasagna. Both were AMAZING but we highly recommend the lasagna! Overall a great experience!
Came for dinner while on vacation and it was very busy. Servers and manager seemed a little frazzled but they were friendly. Things took a little while bc of how busy it was, but it was worth the wait. We had crab dip app- good but lacked actual crab, shrimp scampi was great and full of shrimp, chicken piccata was devoured and chicken Parmesan was also very good. I will say, it was so uncomfortably warm in there. Be sure to wear layers you can take off! Overall, a great dinner and we will be back!
Went on a Thursday night w/o a reservation. Normally that would be a huge mistake, making a reservation is a must. But we were lucky, there was space at the bar and with shuffling of some people there we were able to be seated. Food was fantastic, two buffalo lasagnas and one chicken piccata were received, but not finished, the portions are quite nice and large. Finished the meal with a nice cognac in a huge smile. I have one suggestion, put some port wine in the bar stock :)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bison Lasagna, Chicken Piccata
The best chicken parm I have ever tried and I try it everywhere I can. All of our family’s food was excellent and great service too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were scrambling looking for dinner locations and stumbled across Mazzola. They have an open bar area with a full service for those who was not able to get a reservation like we did. We walked in around 6pm and lucky for us, there was no one at the bar as well as the 3 small tables near the bar. The bartender was very helpful and knowledgeable, he answered all our questions and helped us decide what to get. He is the one who will serve as the server if you're seating in this area. We ended up getting a chicken Caesar salad and a custom made pizza with pepperoni, jalapeño, and pineapple (this is our go to and wanted to compare our usual toppings to a new restaurant). The salad was very good and the chicken we added in to the salad was very large! We ended up getting a medium pizza and for 2 people we still had some slices leftover to take home! The pizza was very good! The pizza style is on the thinner side which we were okay with just an FYI if you were looking for something else. I will definitely be coming back!
Restaurantji Recommends
Quaint place in the lower level off the street. Excellent service and food quality. Our party of 6 adults enjoyed it very much.
Had a great meal here the other night and our waitress Spencer was fantastic! She gave us several great reccomendations for town and did an amazing job making us feel at home.
What a great night at Mazzola's! Our waitress was excellent and the food delicious. Great energy in the place too! After dinner we walked around town and came back to Mazzola's for a drink. Guess we couldn't get enough! We'll be back on our next trip to Steamboat. And will recommend your place to others! 5 stars across the board!
Excellent food, fast service, & friendly staff. Would definitely recommend and go
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Piccata
Absolutely spectacular! The food is delicious and creative and the service is wonderful. Our server was Sheila and she was delightful. She was very attentive and had great recommendations. We love this place - it's a true gem!