Fat Tony's Deli & Pizzeria

I have just spent $24 for a grandmas pie that was soooo tiny. In New York your grandmas pie is double that size. I felt I was taken advantage of.

We all had different slices of pizza and they were all fantastic. We tried the cheesecake too which was great! They even had cream soda which I have not had in years!

Placed an order with Fat Tony’s in bethel for my husband’s birthday party. I worked with Tony in deciding what to order and on his recommendations I went with 2 sandwich platters with a variety of sandwiches…..all delicious. Also an order of chicken nuggets for the kids. Everyone enjoyed the sandwiches and most tried more than one. Tony was a pleasure to work with and we will definitely be back. Highly recommend

One of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had. We ordered Dat Sticky Chicky sandwich on sourdough. Phenomenal. Also had the Carbivore sandwich…increíble! The mozz bites were so yummy and the jalapeño poppers were tasty and crispy and we got it delivered! Highly recommend this place!

Great place to get pizza by the slice. They have a lot of options on the menu and always have slices that are ready. The pizzas are great tasting and the dessert options are great as well. Some excellent vegetarian options as well if you dont eat meat.
Service was fast if you wanted to get something quickly for lunch. And they always give you heated slices.

I have ordered a couple of sandwiches from here and they are always excellent. Recently got an order of the Shamrock Eggrolls, WOW! Awesome!

Keep up the good work. One of the best delis around.

Always order the grilled chicken sandwich on a roll and recently had a bacon egg and cheese sandwich with avocado it was amazing 🙌🏽

Really really worth it and better prices than others in the area!

Not good very bland not for me

One of the worst chicken Parmesan sandwiches I’ve ever had

Food was trash and overpriced chicken Parm had no chicken pizza was bland like cardboard

Placed an order. Received texts about status. Final text was about Diogene delivered it. No pizza. No images on cameras. Of course it’s now closed so no way to call.

Great place! Not from the area, needed lunch...chicken parm and nuggets. Juicy tender, good coating on the chicken and a nice slice to go. Nice little sit down area. Friendly people. Will definitely seek this place out when in the area again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

my wife goes in about 2 or 3 times a week to get bacon egg on rolls I had. fat tony s is the place to eat

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The rudest vendor I have ever dealt with. Do not hire him for events. Needs help for anger issues

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1