Painted Pony Restaurant

74 Main St S, Bethlehem
(203) 266-5771

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Classic Pasta Dishes
Braised Shirt Ribs
Braised Short Ribs
Jala Mango Burger
Chicken Wings
Fish and Chips
Mashed Potato
Bistro Burger

Beginnings
Everything Spiced Ahi Tuna
Seared and chilled, thin sliced, chili aioli, avocado, and shaved scallion.
Jalapeño Popper Dip
Cream cheese, cheddar and mozzarella, roasted hot peppers, bacon, green onion, and warm bavarian pretzels.
Wings
Always at the pony. Bone-in or tenders choose - classic buffalo, hot honey, bbq or jala-mango served with bleu cheese, ranch or honey mustard.
Breaded Mozzarella
Hand cut and fried wedges, house marinara, and crispy parsley.
Cheese Curds Poutine
Breaded wisconsin curds, demi-glace, shredded short ribs, and beer cheese drizzle.
Classic Shrimp Cocktail
Poached white shrimp, classic cocktail sauce or coconut curry dipping sauce.
Fried Calamari and Olives
Lightly fried, crispy capers, house cured olives, and lemon.
Littleneck Clams
Drawn butter or beer broth, fresh lemon, crostini.
Pork Belly and Pickles Board
Sweet and spicy chili glazed pork belly slabs, house made pickled onions and cucumbers, and cinnamon chipotle chips.

Salads
Cobb
Avocado, hard boiled egg, bleu cheese, pork belly lardons, tomatoes, and chopped greens.
Garden
Greek
Local feta, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion, kalamata olives, and chopped romaine.
Harvest
Sweetened cranberries, glazed pecans, bosc pears, gorgonzola cheese, and harvest greens.
Build Your Own
Red sauce or fig jam, mozzarella or cheddar 9.
Fig, Onions, Pork Belly and Gorgonzola
Mission fig jam, caramelized onions, and pork belly lardons.
Kalamata, Feta and Spinach
Alfredo, tomato, lemon peel, and red onion.
Roasted Tomato and Artichoke
Garlic oil, mozzarella blend, and basil pesto.
Short Ribs, Green Onions and Asiago
Braised and shredded short ribs, tomato, and beer cheese drizzle.

Hands
Bistro Burger
8 ounces choice blend, caramelized onions, gorgonzola cheese, fig jam, and brioche bun.
Burger
8 ounces house choice blend, pickled onions, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, brioche bun bacon, caramelized onions, and avocado.
Chicken and Waffles
Buttermilk fried chicken breast, roasted jalapeno jam, heirloom tomato salata, cheddar cheese and green onion belgian waffle, and smoked chili aioli.
Chicken Avocado
Marinated and grilled breast, smoked bacon, tomatoes, avocado, lemon ailoi.
Chicken Parm
Hand breaded chicken breast, melted mozzarella, house tomato sauce, and tuscan roll.
Eggplant Parm
Hand breaded eggplant, melted mozzarella, house tomato sauce, and tuscan roll.
Jala-mango Burger
8 ounces choice blend, cheddar cheese, jala-mango glazed onion rings, pork belly, and brioche bun.
Pork Belly
Hot honey, pickles, house slaw, smashed curds, cajun crema, and brioche bun.
Steak and Cheese
Cheddar, caramelized onions, shaven prime rib, and bourbon demi-glace for dipping.

Fresh Pasta
Bolognese
Traditional slow-cooked beef, pork and tomatoes, parmesan cheese, and fresh herbs.
Classic Pasta Dishes
Choose pasta, choose sauce: marinara 14 | alfredo, pesto, vodka sauce 15 add meatballs 5 add chicken 5 add shrimp 7.
Pasta E Carbonara
Creamy alfredo, bacon, peas, and parmesan.
Pasta Putanesca
Classic tomato and caper sauce, mixed olives, garlic, roasted peppers, and artichoke hearts.
Seafood Arribiata
Calamari, shrimp, scallops, clams, spicy garlic and tomato sauce, toasted fennel, and parmesan cheese.
White Clam Sauce
Fresh littlenecks, garlic, white wine broth, virgin oil, and parsley.
Wild Mushroom Ravioli and Short Ribs
Porcini mushrooms, shredded braised short ribs, veal demi-glace, light cream, parmesan cheese, and fresh herbs.

Mains
Mac and Cheese
Cheddar gouda blend, shell pasta add short ribs 8, add pork belly 6.
Rosemary Chicken
Parmesan crusted chicken breast, herbed compound butter, shaved brussels, and cauliflower risotto.
Fish and Chips
Golden ale battered haddock, potatoes, tarter sauce, and house slaw.
Norwegian Salmon Fillet
Brown sugar and sea salt glaze, sauteed spinach, and cauliflower risotto.
Pan Seared Scallops
Pan seared, cracked pepper, white wine, butter and lemon sauce, crispy brussels sprouts, and pork belly.
Tuna Livernese
Black and blue seared tuna, peppercorn crust, garlic, tomato, capers, olives, and tagliatelle pasta.

Steaks and Chop
Braised Short Ribs
10 ounces, and veal demi-glace.
Steak Tips
Bourbon and brown sugar marinated, pan seared, caramelized onions, mushrooms, and peppers.
Delmonico
14 ounces off-the-bone ribeye, and garlic butter.
New York Strip
12 ounces boneless striploin, and gorgonzola butter.
Pork Rib Chop
Duroc pork, brown sugar, and sea salt, and poached pear chutney.
Tenderloin Medallions
Sauteed mushrooms, and whiskey demi-glace.

Pony Classics
Chicken Alexander
Breaded chicken breast, white wine, mushrooms, and mozzarella.
Chicken Caruso
Breaded chicken breast, shrimp, broccoli, and burgh sauce.
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded chicken breast fillets, mozzarella, tomato sauce, and capellini.
New England Baked Cod
Cracker crumbs, white wine and butter roasted cod, choose two sides.

Sides
House Fries
Avgolemeno Soup
Mashed Pots
Cauliflower Risotto
House Slaw
Onion Rings
Roasted Carrots
Roasted Potatoes
Soup Otd
Spinach
Sweet Tots
Tossed Salad

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+36 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+35 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

No joke, my boyfriend keeps talking about how this was the most tender chicken he's ever had. He could've eaten it with a spork was so tender.

And I know everybody loves prime rib, and their location is the best location but, no joke, this is the best prime rib I've ever had the rub flavors ran deep and the entire 14 ounces was cooked to perfection. And the bartender was just such a beautiful soul. I would go back just for them and their mixology

Love...
January 2026
We got the fig jam flat bread and the southern fried chicken sandwich and they were absolutely delicious! Service was fast and great. Restaurant itself if very clean and appealing to look at. Fair pricing as well.
November 2025
Had a 70th birthday celebration including 16 family members and friends. The waitress, Helen, was quite attentive to our needs with timely service. The space was perfect and food excellent.
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Little Town Deli - 22 East St
Deli
Nick's Country Kitchen - 3G Flanders Rd
American, Pizza
Big Daddy's Pizza and Deli Woodbury - 1633 Main St N
Pizza, Italian, American

Painted Pony Restaurant

74 Main St S, Bethlehem, CT 06751
(203) 266-5771