Benny J's Pizza

1195 Main St, Branford
(203) 208-2409

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mohamed Hafez

The avocado burger is my favorite. The burgers always taste great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Timothy Samoskevich

Nowadays, as we all know, everything is stupid expensive. So since that is a given, I can only feel that I was not robbed if I receive a product that is worth these exorbitant prices. Benny J's Pizza is such an excellent restaurant that when I get food from there I feel like I Won! The food is absolutely delicious & I've had sandwiches, pizza, calzones, salad & def more! Every single thing I've ordered from Benny J's has been excellent! Never once was my order the least bit shy of perfect. On top of the great quality of the food, Benny J's also gives you portions that end up being TWO big meals! And, somehow, the food is just as good the 2nd time! I highly recommend Benny J's, if you couldn't already tell ?! Worth every penny, every time!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatball Sub, Penne Vodka Pizza, Garlic Bread, Garlic Bread with Cheese, Buffalo Chicken Sub, Clams Casino, Mozzarella Sticks, Cheeseburger Bun, Steak Bomb Sub with Onions Peppers and Mushrooms, Bacon Pizza, Meatball Parmigiana Sub, Chicken Florentine

Eric Bower

Ordered a pie WELL DONE. They delivered it as an oily soupy floppy mess. It wasn’t cooked well done at all, not even close. The attitude of the owner was unacceptable. Basically called us a liar and was very rude. We got our money back and we will never order from there ever again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Victoria Singer

Delicious pizza.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lynda Scanlon

Ordered 2 subs - Benny J combo and Italian combo. Told the girl extra tomatoes. Benny J sub had bacon crumbles and came with 2 in.diameter container of coleslaw. How cheap. Italian combo had NO tomatoes, NO pepperoni, and NO capicola. It was basically a ham sub. The Benny J was tasteless. This sub maker makes POOR subs. Not worth the price and will not return.

Yurem Armijos

Amazing amazing the best food I had in 15 years the best food ever. Very much recommend the avocado pizza if u want an explosive taste in your mouth

Kid-friendliness: Amazing treat the kids with fun and they have a piano

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Penne Vodka Pizza, Cheeseburger Bun, Steak Bomb Sub with Onions Peppers and Mushrooms, Cheeseburger Sub

Michelle Modena

Vegetarian options: Arrived late. Garlic knots package leaking oil but antipasto was great.

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Antipasto Salad

Anthony Aljamal

Beautiful and delicious food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James H

Excellent customer service thank you

Henry Benson

amazing food, fast and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mr. De

Dingy Dining room. When you first walk in, you can help to notice that the room is dark. Mostly because the floor is missing the finish. At some point, the owner ripped up the flooring and left this black adhesive behind. Looks like it's been that way for some time.The waitress was unattentive and seemed put off that I was planning on eating in. I ordered the garlic bread with cheese and linguini with broccoli and garlic. The bread was the best. The side salad was tiny, but worst of all, the garlic was burned, causing the dish to be very bitter and unedible. When I pointed this out to my server, she didn't even acknowledge my concern. Never offered to replace it or deduct it from the bill. Sorry to say, I won't be back.

Bob De

Dingy Dining room. When you first walk in, you can help to notice that the room is dark. Mostly because the floor is missing the finish. At some point, the owner ripped up the flooring and left this black adhesive behind. Looks like it's been that way for some time.The waitress was unattentive and seemed put off that I was planning on eating in. I ordered the garlic bread with cheese and linguini with broccoli and garlic. The bread was the best. The side salad was tiny, but worst of all, the garlic was burned, causing the dish to be very bitter and unedible. When I pointed this out to my server, she didn't even acknowledge my concern. Never offered to replace it or deduct it from the bill. Sorry to say, I won't be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Karrie Ferriouolo

We got their flyer in the mail, and had to try them their prices are great ,we ordered the summer California salad was amazing and eggplant rollatini it was delicious omg we will be trying the pizza next ????????

Lester Allen (Proeman2002)

It doesn't look like much when you walk in but, they know how to cook! The chicken picciatta & marsala were like butter.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Penne Vodka Pizza, Pasta Fagioli

Ricky Gutierrez

Delicious meatball sub. A nice family restaurant

Loading...