Absolutely the best pizza I have ever had, these guys and girls know their stuff, if you love pizza then go here to meet your pizza soul mate because you will be in heaven with the first bite...!!Kid-friendliness: We brought our grand child there his name is Otto and they gave him a free t shirt ...who does that these days ....?
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Shaun Daskam (piperpilot26)
Otto is set in one of the most quaint, romantic little towns in CT. The pizza is some of the best I've tasted. The sauce, the soft, yet crunchy crust, the atmosphere. This place has it all!If you're looking for date night ideas, definitely make it a point to stop in and grab a pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Michael W.
So you've stopped by Little House to grab a beer but now you're hungry, where should you go? Otto of course! Hands down the best pizza in the area but even better when it's just steps away from great beer and ice cream. I'll warn you now - it is HOT in here. You could wear shorts and a t shirt in the middle of winter and still be comfortable by the oven. But I'm not mad about it, watching them make the pizzas adds to the ambiance and appeal of this small pizza shop. And even though it isn't fancy inside don't let that discourage you - the pizza here is anything but cheap! The dough and crust is amazing. The flavors they pack into each bite of the pie is top tier!! I've never tried a pizza here that I didn't like but pepperoni is definitely my go to. So much flavor! Service is great too, very attentive and everything is ready pretty quick - even on a busy Friday night. They give you large containers of water to serve yourself (you'll need it sitting by the fire lol). They have great local beer on tap, mixed drinks, and wine by the bottle. I literally couldn't ask for anything more. Any time I'm in the area I'm stopping at Otto!
Lissie Brooks
A tiny but wonderful restaurant! The open fire where the pizzas are prepared is a great attraction. Our pizzas were terrific and I loved the spinach salad.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza with Stracciatella
Michael Minicucci
First time but certainly not last. Great artisan pizza, draft beer menu and excellent service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James N.
We returned to OTTO, early winter 2024 . . . [although an early Mentor in my career advised: "If you experience a great restaurant, Never Go Back."] . . . but we returned, and OTTO was even more perfect (if that is possible) than our first experience. It was COLD outside (I mean, really cold, -0 degrees and high winds) and OTTO was crowded with Beautiful Customers, at the bar, at tables . . . kids, old people, new families, rednecks, college professors, police, illegals -- you get the idea: Everyone! . . . everyone whose blood is red and who acknowledges pizza as the Perfect Meal. But the pizza -- OMG I swear the crust was still on fire and bubbling as it arrived at out table (the table of honor -- 'The Crossroads' of the dining area), and the stracciatella (liquidy-creamy Italian mozzarella-like [but better] cheese) and Fresh (they must have a garden out back) basil and tomato was as if from The Garden Of Eden. My wife and I are left-handed. Our OTTO Waitperson was left-handed. Coincidence? I don't think so. Perfection? Yes -- that's it!! We also had the fantastic seasoned and roasted Castelvetrano olives while we waited (briefly, perfect timing) for the pizza. And a Negroni cocktail and Montepulciano d Abruzzo wine. Meanwhile, the acoustic ceiling panels kept the noise decibels to a pleasant level of social enthusiasm . . . and the beautiful customers flowed in and around and out. I love OTTO.
Kim Hecht
Delicious pizza, beer on tap, a bit noisy but they were very busy. Server was excellent and friendly. Lots of takeout orders.....I definitely recommend that you try
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe F.
I've been reluctant to post this because I don't want more people knowing about this great little spot. Pizza is as good as it gets around here (without heading to New Haven). Staff are all very friendly and it's fun to watch the pizzas get made in the months they allow indoor seating (don't understand why they don't allow it in summer?).
Diana McQuade
My husband and I come here every Friday night! The pizza is amazing, the staff is friendly, and they’re always consistent. Thanks for great food and happy small biz Saturday!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza with Stracciatella
Ashley B.
Recommended: Absolutely, for both the pizza and the atmosphere. Overall: A delightful surprise with its inviting ambiance and scrumptious pizza. Snapshot: Food: 5/5 Drink: 4/5 Vibe: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Family-Friendly: 4/5 Highlights: Perfect For: Enjoying high-quality pizza in a picturesque setting Don't Miss: The Margherita pizza, boasting a perfect balance of flavor Bonus Tip: The outdoor garden patio provides a serene dining experience All The Details: Stopping by Otto Pizza after a theater visit in a nearby town turned out to be a wonderful decision. The atmosphere of the place was a fantastic surprise, providing a beautiful outdoor setting that felt like dining in a garden. The tent and seating by a charming brook accentuated the small-town charm of this excellent pizza shop. The pizza itself was slightly thicker than the iconic New Haven style but did not disappoint. The Margherita pizza, in particular, was a standout, reminiscent of Worcester Street's famed offerings - flavorful, delicious, and beautifully balanced. It's definitely something I'd order again. Though the drink selection was small, it was well-curated, with enough choices to suit different preferences. The service was quick and friendly, adding to the overall pleasant experience. While we didn't have our daughter with us, the setting seemed very accommodating for families, with ample space for a stroller. I would wholeheartedly recommend Otto Pizza and am looking forward to returning, not just for the pizza but also for the delightful dining environment.
This was genuinely the best pizza I have ever had (and let me tell ya I've had a lot). Perfection, truly perfection. 10/10. Amazing staff, shout out to Emily and Noah, you guys rock!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Alex H.
Good Neapolitan. Bravo. Need to go back for the basic Margherita but their meat lovers was great. I I
Miriam Almodovar
Love both pizzas. The apples, prosciutto and the cheese delicious. The rotisserie chicken with the mushrooms and rosemary to die for.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Irwin
Hard to give one score as their food is variable. Their meaty pizzas are always 5/5. Their veg ones have gotten more bland to my taste - 4/5 at best. Tried the brisket tonight after hearing good things - 2/5. Was a bit tough, not smoked at all, and cut along the grain not against. Come on gang - BBQ 101. Not getting that here again. And please help out your staff - they’re doing great but look overworked.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Joanna C
The food and atmosphere are amazing. We always enjoy our time at Otto.
Absolutely the best pizza I have ever had, these guys and girls know their stuff, if you love pizza then go here to meet your pizza soul mate because you will be in heaven with the first bite...!!Kid-friendliness: We brought our grand child there his name is Otto and they gave him a free t shirt ...who does that these days ....?
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Otto is set in one of the most quaint, romantic little towns in CT. The pizza is some of the best I've tasted. The sauce, the soft, yet crunchy crust, the atmosphere. This place has it all!If you're looking for date night ideas, definitely make it a point to stop in and grab a pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
So you've stopped by Little House to grab a beer but now you're hungry, where should you go? Otto of course! Hands down the best pizza in the area but even better when it's just steps away from great beer and ice cream. I'll warn you now - it is HOT in here. You could wear shorts and a t shirt in the middle of winter and still be comfortable by the oven. But I'm not mad about it, watching them make the pizzas adds to the ambiance and appeal of this small pizza shop. And even though it isn't fancy inside don't let that discourage you - the pizza here is anything but cheap! The dough and crust is amazing. The flavors they pack into each bite of the pie is top tier!! I've never tried a pizza here that I didn't like but pepperoni is definitely my go to. So much flavor! Service is great too, very attentive and everything is ready pretty quick - even on a busy Friday night. They give you large containers of water to serve yourself (you'll need it sitting by the fire lol). They have great local beer on tap, mixed drinks, and wine by the bottle. I literally couldn't ask for anything more. Any time I'm in the area I'm stopping at Otto!
A tiny but wonderful restaurant! The open fire where the pizzas are prepared is a great attraction. Our pizzas were terrific and I loved the spinach salad.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza with Stracciatella
First time but certainly not last. Great artisan pizza, draft beer menu and excellent service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We returned to OTTO, early winter 2024 . . . [although an early Mentor in my career advised: "If you experience a great restaurant, Never Go Back."] . . . but we returned, and OTTO was even more perfect (if that is possible) than our first experience. It was COLD outside (I mean, really cold, -0 degrees and high winds) and OTTO was crowded with Beautiful Customers, at the bar, at tables . . . kids, old people, new families, rednecks, college professors, police, illegals -- you get the idea: Everyone! . . . everyone whose blood is red and who acknowledges pizza as the Perfect Meal. But the pizza -- OMG I swear the crust was still on fire and bubbling as it arrived at out table (the table of honor -- 'The Crossroads' of the dining area), and the stracciatella (liquidy-creamy Italian mozzarella-like [but better] cheese) and Fresh (they must have a garden out back) basil and tomato was as if from The Garden Of Eden. My wife and I are left-handed. Our OTTO Waitperson was left-handed. Coincidence? I don't think so. Perfection? Yes -- that's it!! We also had the fantastic seasoned and roasted Castelvetrano olives while we waited (briefly, perfect timing) for the pizza. And a Negroni cocktail and Montepulciano d Abruzzo wine. Meanwhile, the acoustic ceiling panels kept the noise decibels to a pleasant level of social enthusiasm . . . and the beautiful customers flowed in and around and out. I love OTTO.
Delicious pizza, beer on tap, a bit noisy but they were very busy. Server was excellent and friendly. Lots of takeout orders.....I definitely recommend that you try
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've been reluctant to post this because I don't want more people knowing about this great little spot. Pizza is as good as it gets around here (without heading to New Haven). Staff are all very friendly and it's fun to watch the pizzas get made in the months they allow indoor seating (don't understand why they don't allow it in summer?).
My husband and I come here every Friday night! The pizza is amazing, the staff is friendly, and they’re always consistent. Thanks for great food and happy small biz Saturday!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza with Stracciatella
Recommended: Absolutely, for both the pizza and the atmosphere. Overall: A delightful surprise with its inviting ambiance and scrumptious pizza. Snapshot: Food: 5/5 Drink: 4/5 Vibe: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Family-Friendly: 4/5 Highlights: Perfect For: Enjoying high-quality pizza in a picturesque setting Don't Miss: The Margherita pizza, boasting a perfect balance of flavor Bonus Tip: The outdoor garden patio provides a serene dining experience All The Details: Stopping by Otto Pizza after a theater visit in a nearby town turned out to be a wonderful decision. The atmosphere of the place was a fantastic surprise, providing a beautiful outdoor setting that felt like dining in a garden. The tent and seating by a charming brook accentuated the small-town charm of this excellent pizza shop. The pizza itself was slightly thicker than the iconic New Haven style but did not disappoint. The Margherita pizza, in particular, was a standout, reminiscent of Worcester Street's famed offerings - flavorful, delicious, and beautifully balanced. It's definitely something I'd order again. Though the drink selection was small, it was well-curated, with enough choices to suit different preferences. The service was quick and friendly, adding to the overall pleasant experience. While we didn't have our daughter with us, the setting seemed very accommodating for families, with ample space for a stroller. I would wholeheartedly recommend Otto Pizza and am looking forward to returning, not just for the pizza but also for the delightful dining environment.
Restaurantji Recommends
This was genuinely the best pizza I have ever had (and let me tell ya I've had a lot). Perfection, truly perfection. 10/10. Amazing staff, shout out to Emily and Noah, you guys rock!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Good Neapolitan. Bravo. Need to go back for the basic Margherita but their meat lovers was great. I I
Love both pizzas. The apples, prosciutto and the cheese delicious. The rotisserie chicken with the mushrooms and rosemary to die for.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hard to give one score as their food is variable. Their meaty pizzas are always 5/5. Their veg ones have gotten more bland to my taste - 4/5 at best. Tried the brisket tonight after hearing good things - 2/5. Was a bit tough, not smoked at all, and cut along the grain not against. Come on gang - BBQ 101. Not getting that here again. And please help out your staff - they’re doing great but look overworked.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
The food and atmosphere are amazing. We always enjoy our time at Otto.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5