Met a friend for a beer and dinner,
30 minutes later we asked the bartender a follow up to our order. Now mind you, everyone else in the restaurant had their meals. She came back and said they are working on it. So we asked, we getting it in 2 minutes? She said No She proceeded to say they are just working on it, which means she either forgot to put the order in, or they missed it. She comped us the drinks, but whipdeedoo I went for a meal, not free drinks
First and last experience, terrible Won’t go back
Ron B
Amelia La Bella
So great and friendly! Had family size meals for Christmas the chicken Marsala was amazing! Had lunch there today and it was just as great for a chicken wrap!
Anthony LoVerde
My absolute favorite place in Cromwell. Great food always fresh and hot and friendly staff. Great atmosphere tv’s music great food and drinks. Definitely recommend and my go to place.
Genesis
Fantastic food and staff
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Holly Salmon
Slow and ignored customers for 20 minutes. Complaining with the 3 other people here that have also been waiting.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
AC Twach
Service was great and food is yummy!
Marc LaValle
Best steak dinner!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rodrigo Ferrer
I’ve had Nostalgia pizza twice now, both times take out. It’s good, tasty, fresh, quality pizza. I got the wings too and they were prime. The did three large pies and a dozen wings in under 30 minutes. That’s nice on an NFL Sunday! My only suggestion, I wish they were on Slice or Toast or any type app that I could at least put my order in electronically. Even if it’s just for pick up. I know it’s called Nostalgia, but I never miss the slight inconvenience of the calling in to place your order. Who doesn’t like ordering you food and paying in a few clicks? Aside from that very slight criticism, excellent restaurant! I’ll be trying full entrees next.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janey Richards
We are always looking for a local establishment and this one was excellent. Great food, good prices, extensive menu, good service, and clean. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ernie B
I am just wow. Food quality excellent. I ordered a burger and I have had a lot of good burgers, but the taste of this one? Oh my. Char grilled. Fresh ingredients. Good sized patty. Fresh and tasty. The taste is exceptional. This crew knows what they are doing.
Service and food were great but it was so noisy that we could not enjoy our time.
damon ferrara
Great food, and people
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cindy S
Delicious food, generous portions. Atmosphere just plain and alittle dark. Definitely going back to try more food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jasmine Peck
I went a few months back with my partner for a date. I got the eggplant Parm over penne pasta, HUGEEEE portion! I wanted to write this because I just recently went out to a fancy Italian restaurant and got their eggplant Parm over spaghetti and LET ME TELL YOU!!! Nostalgia's was sooooooo much better! The eggplant was delicious and the portion was insane, I have two more meals out of it. I will definitely be back for more!
Nate Gamer
Wonderful pizza. Neapolitan. Crispy on the end and the middle. A nice consistency throughout.
The margarita pizza really allows you to taste the depth of the pizza sauce.
The prices are fair and honesty in the menu is appreciated.
Met a friend for a beer and dinner, 30 minutes later we asked the bartender a follow up to our order. Now mind you, everyone else in the restaurant had their meals. She came back and said they are working on it. So we asked, we getting it in 2 minutes? She said No She proceeded to say they are just working on it, which means she either forgot to put the order in, or they missed it. She comped us the drinks, but whipdeedoo I went for a meal, not free drinks First and last experience, terrible Won’t go back Ron B
So great and friendly! Had family size meals for Christmas the chicken Marsala was amazing! Had lunch there today and it was just as great for a chicken wrap!
My absolute favorite place in Cromwell. Great food always fresh and hot and friendly staff. Great atmosphere tv’s music great food and drinks. Definitely recommend and my go to place.
Fantastic food and staff
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Slow and ignored customers for 20 minutes. Complaining with the 3 other people here that have also been waiting.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Service was great and food is yummy!
Best steak dinner!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve had Nostalgia pizza twice now, both times take out. It’s good, tasty, fresh, quality pizza. I got the wings too and they were prime. The did three large pies and a dozen wings in under 30 minutes. That’s nice on an NFL Sunday! My only suggestion, I wish they were on Slice or Toast or any type app that I could at least put my order in electronically. Even if it’s just for pick up. I know it’s called Nostalgia, but I never miss the slight inconvenience of the calling in to place your order. Who doesn’t like ordering you food and paying in a few clicks? Aside from that very slight criticism, excellent restaurant! I’ll be trying full entrees next.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We are always looking for a local establishment and this one was excellent. Great food, good prices, extensive menu, good service, and clean. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am just wow. Food quality excellent. I ordered a burger and I have had a lot of good burgers, but the taste of this one? Oh my. Char grilled. Fresh ingredients. Good sized patty. Fresh and tasty. The taste is exceptional. This crew knows what they are doing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Service and food were great but it was so noisy that we could not enjoy our time.
Great food, and people
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious food, generous portions. Atmosphere just plain and alittle dark. Definitely going back to try more food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went a few months back with my partner for a date. I got the eggplant Parm over penne pasta, HUGEEEE portion! I wanted to write this because I just recently went out to a fancy Italian restaurant and got their eggplant Parm over spaghetti and LET ME TELL YOU!!! Nostalgia's was sooooooo much better! The eggplant was delicious and the portion was insane, I have two more meals out of it. I will definitely be back for more!
Wonderful pizza.
Neapolitan. Crispy on the end and the middle.
A nice consistency throughout.
The margarita pizza really allows you to taste the depth of the pizza sauce.
The prices are fair and honesty in the menu is appreciated.
Kudos.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...