My son is a pizza snob!! He'll eat other pizza but he'll let you know that you should have gone to aniellos!!! I'm obsessed w.their pumpkin soup when it's in season<3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christine R.
I kind of stumbled over this restaurant and I'm so glad I did !!! I have been here approx 4 times and every time the meal has been delicious, from the very friendly waitstaff. Every time I have been here we have ordered the hot antipasto which included two baked stuffed shrimp, two stuffed mushrooms, and two clams casino, along with the appetizer came a warm basket of homemade bread with butter. We had the New England Clam chowder and it was perfect I had a veal dish with mushrooms and prosciutto over noodles. Perfect did I say fresh mushrooms my brother had the zuppe di pesce, which he totally enjoyed. He got it without the calamari and another basket of warm bread. If you're looking for delicious Italian food with a very friendly waitstaff this is the place to go. I almost didn't write this review as I don't want to see the place over crowded lol but it's well deserved. We were there last night and will be back again. Very cute place inside
Linda Pixton
Great place. Love the location .Everything so far has been great!
Pattyann Rienzo (Zoe)
I ❤️ Aniello's Pizza! It's the place I go too. I'm always smiling for a good reason. ?The service is outstanding ?? U at Aniello's Pizza Italian Restaurant.Ciao,Pattyann Rienzo
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lasagna
Liz Anderson
Great food and great service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
GARY KANOFF
FOOD. IS. GREAT. 2024I KNEW . FAMILY. FOR. YEAR SPEOPLE. WORK. HERE.VERY. NICE.
Maureen L.
Consistently great food - authentic meals made to order . Great menu selections from appetizers , soups to a large variety of meal choices. Never disappoints !
FM
I asked for white bean and escarole soup, it’s not on the menu but they made it for me. It was sooooooo good! The stuffed bread: chicken parm and spinach and cheese were amazing as well. Great tasting and quality food! Also very very nice staff! This will be my go to when I am in the area, so glad I stopped :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danielle Paoletta
We live very close by so we order to go. I've been eating here for the last 7 years and tonight's food just made me realize this establishment needs to be recognized more widely. I love getting entrees off their updates menus, but tonight I ordered gnocchi alla vodka sauce with burrata (local) which comes with a side salad and their complementary bread. AMAZING. I can't say enough about this dish. But honestly every time I eat the complementary bread it reminds me of my childhood and going to the Italian bakery for fresh bread with my grandfather. My husband LOVES their bacon and onion pizza. I've tried so many dishes I love that I couldn't begin to list here. Two of my favorites are the antipasto and the eggplant rollatini. This is our go to Italian restaurant and I love when my family from out of town comes to enjoy as well! Highly recommend not just for the food but the friendly faces you encounter!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bonnie S.
Wonderful Sisian pizza! Quality food at a fair price ! Convenient location in Trolly Square innEast Haven.
Aniello's is like the Cheers of pizza in East Haven: where everyone knows your name and is glad you came. For take out specifically, you are always greeted warmly by name. After 2-3 visits they definitely make an effort to remember their customers! There's always at least 3-4 people (if not more), getting take out on any given night, we try to avoid going on weekends for that reason. We have tried stuffed breads, grinders and pizzas. All have been very good. Pizza is more NY style than New Haven style (totally fine by us) and they are one of few places who also do a sicilian style thick square pizza, will try it soon but pictures look promising. Since moving to East Shore, Aniello's has become our go to place in the area.
J D
Everything here is good, but the stuff breads are amazing, spinach breads are absolutely delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Williams
Great pizza, love the red pie, little extra sauce, grated cheese!11/23 - Saturday night dinner - Zuppa Di Pesce, excellent. Homemade Gnocchi with meat sauce, also excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth A.
My family and I love Aniello's. The majority of the time we do take out and haven't had a bad meal yet. The staff at the take out window are so friendly and have even helped bring out our food to the car for us. I personally love their chicken francaise and antipasto salad. However, we have tried several other meals such as their gnocchi, chicken parmigiana, salmon and stuffed breads. Everything is always delicious and the portions are generous. We have only dined in a couple of times but the servers were friendly and attentive. A must try if you are in the area!
Ava P.
convenient parking attentive staff good food good location one of the few places to get a Sicilian pie
My son is a pizza snob!! He'll eat other pizza but he'll let you know that you should have gone to aniellos!!! I'm obsessed w.their pumpkin soup when it's in season<3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I kind of stumbled over this restaurant and I'm so glad I did !!! I have been here approx 4 times and every time the meal has been delicious, from the very friendly waitstaff. Every time I have been here we have ordered the hot antipasto which included two baked stuffed shrimp, two stuffed mushrooms, and two clams casino, along with the appetizer came a warm basket of homemade bread with butter. We had the New England Clam chowder and it was perfect I had a veal dish with mushrooms and prosciutto over noodles. Perfect did I say fresh mushrooms my brother had the zuppe di pesce, which he totally enjoyed. He got it without the calamari and another basket of warm bread. If you're looking for delicious Italian food with a very friendly waitstaff this is the place to go. I almost didn't write this review as I don't want to see the place over crowded lol but it's well deserved. We were there last night and will be back again. Very cute place inside
Great place. Love the location .Everything so far has been great!
I ❤️ Aniello's Pizza! It's the place I go too. I'm always smiling for a good reason. ?The service is outstanding ?? U at Aniello's Pizza Italian Restaurant.Ciao,Pattyann Rienzo
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lasagna
Great food and great service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
FOOD. IS. GREAT. 2024I KNEW . FAMILY. FOR. YEAR SPEOPLE. WORK. HERE.VERY. NICE.
Consistently great food - authentic meals made to order . Great menu selections from appetizers , soups to a large variety of meal choices. Never disappoints !
I asked for white bean and escarole soup, it’s not on the menu but they made it for me. It was sooooooo good! The stuffed bread: chicken parm and spinach and cheese were amazing as well. Great tasting and quality food! Also very very nice staff! This will be my go to when I am in the area, so glad I stopped :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We live very close by so we order to go. I've been eating here for the last 7 years and tonight's food just made me realize this establishment needs to be recognized more widely. I love getting entrees off their updates menus, but tonight I ordered gnocchi alla vodka sauce with burrata (local) which comes with a side salad and their complementary bread. AMAZING. I can't say enough about this dish. But honestly every time I eat the complementary bread it reminds me of my childhood and going to the Italian bakery for fresh bread with my grandfather. My husband LOVES their bacon and onion pizza. I've tried so many dishes I love that I couldn't begin to list here. Two of my favorites are the antipasto and the eggplant rollatini. This is our go to Italian restaurant and I love when my family from out of town comes to enjoy as well! Highly recommend not just for the food but the friendly faces you encounter!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful Sisian pizza! Quality food at a fair price ! Convenient location in Trolly Square innEast Haven.
Restaurantji Recommends
Aniello's is like the Cheers of pizza in East Haven: where everyone knows your name and is glad you came. For take out specifically, you are always greeted warmly by name. After 2-3 visits they definitely make an effort to remember their customers! There's always at least 3-4 people (if not more), getting take out on any given night, we try to avoid going on weekends for that reason. We have tried stuffed breads, grinders and pizzas. All have been very good. Pizza is more NY style than New Haven style (totally fine by us) and they are one of few places who also do a sicilian style thick square pizza, will try it soon but pictures look promising. Since moving to East Shore, Aniello's has become our go to place in the area.
Everything here is good, but the stuff breads are amazing, spinach breads are absolutely delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, love the red pie, little extra sauce, grated cheese!11/23 - Saturday night dinner - Zuppa Di Pesce, excellent. Homemade Gnocchi with meat sauce, also excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family and I love Aniello's. The majority of the time we do take out and haven't had a bad meal yet. The staff at the take out window are so friendly and have even helped bring out our food to the car for us. I personally love their chicken francaise and antipasto salad. However, we have tried several other meals such as their gnocchi, chicken parmigiana, salmon and stuffed breads. Everything is always delicious and the portions are generous. We have only dined in a couple of times but the servers were friendly and attentive. A must try if you are in the area!
convenient parking attentive staff good food good location one of the few places to get a Sicilian pie