My favorite place to go in East Haven! You need to go! Everyone is so attentive. Their food is excellent, especially their hot honey pizza. The owners are extremely considerate of your needs and want to make sure your experience is positive. I’m so happy Nicky’s opened in East Haven.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Looney
The pizza from here is actually incrediblly delicious and I havent quite had anything like this before. Although, there is a large amount of grease on the pizza in the form of puddles. You dont need that much olive oil guys.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Michael Angeloni
Been to every pizza joint in East Haven, Nicky’s is hands down the best. Always good pies and they got great drinks if you’re stopping in! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Winston K.
Mane wtf dont ever serve me no damn Lemmon peper wings again my dog at the age of 10 died to due the seasoning on that tomfoolery
Robert Taylor
Ordered online, hot and ready on time! Eating in the parking lot as I type, great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Hernandez
Garbage, don’t waste your time way better pizza places within a half mile radius.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mary P Thompson
Ordered a small Mashed Potato and Bacon pizza, Caesar salad with sardines! No dressing, but salad was still very good. Also enjoyed the fried Mac & Cheese Bites. Everything was delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tara Hall
Great atmosphere..My daughter and I loved it . Food was awesome..Good drink selection and great staff
Dan Faulk
What a great experience we had last night. Visiting the area we were advised of this restaurant and we were not disappointed. Bernie was great in all aspects of customer service and the owner was also very pleasant and cared about our experience. I must admit......their pizza was better than most ...if not....I can't say it lol...compared highly to NY pizza, which is incredible. I thought us New Yorkers had a monopoly over pizza.. I don't think that anymore. Also loved playing pool and pinball there. Just a great overall experience and they put their family history in their pizza story. Don't miss it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony S.
Went to pickup a take out order and have a round of drinks first. The staff was acting like horny school boys for a group of girls at the bar completely ignored us for 15 mins.. I have been her 3 times now and. It a single good experience.
Service great! Owner stopped by our table, very nice touch. Had a small meatball, onion, mushroom pie. The sauce was sweet, crust nicely charred. Could have used a scootch more cheese, but only a comment, not a complaint.Will definitely be back. You should go!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deidre O'Neal
*sigh* My pizza had raw slabs of bacon all over it and the dough was raw and gummy. The toppings were very poorly slapped on the pie and very undercooked. I don't understand how someone could even consider letting this go out the door to a customer. I had to throw it away. Money wasted. Never again.
Food: 1
Rebecca S.
I've ordered via DoorDash a few times and the pizza has always been good. Nice crust and the right amount of toppings. I can't speak to the in person experience, but my order arrived hot and tasted great.
nathaniel gutierrez
Hi I’m coming on here to talk about a reoccurring issue, I live quite close by and often on busy nights like Saturday I find the minimal parking offered leads people to end up parking quite close to our and other people’s houses my only real concern is a lot of the time my mom finds cars partially blocking our driveway if you could please look into suggesting guests to be more mindful of where they park it’d be a huge help besides that I hope y’all continue to have great business!
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
Camille Marquis
Fun bar ,pool table and pinball ,good pizza and sandwiches friendly
My favorite place to go in East Haven! You need to go! Everyone is so attentive. Their food is excellent, especially their hot honey pizza. The owners are extremely considerate of your needs and want to make sure your experience is positive. I’m so happy Nicky’s opened in East Haven.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza from here is actually incrediblly delicious and I havent quite had anything like this before. Although, there is a large amount of grease on the pizza in the form of puddles. You dont need that much olive oil guys.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Been to every pizza joint in East Haven, Nicky’s is hands down the best. Always good pies and they got great drinks if you’re stopping in! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mane wtf dont ever serve me no damn Lemmon peper wings again my dog at the age of 10 died to due the seasoning on that tomfoolery
Ordered online, hot and ready on time! Eating in the parking lot as I type, great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Garbage, don’t waste your time way better pizza places within a half mile radius.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ordered a small Mashed Potato and Bacon pizza, Caesar salad with sardines! No dressing, but salad was still very good. Also enjoyed the fried Mac & Cheese Bites. Everything was delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great atmosphere..My daughter and I loved it . Food was awesome..Good drink selection and great staff
What a great experience we had last night. Visiting the area we were advised of this restaurant and we were not disappointed. Bernie was great in all aspects of customer service and the owner was also very pleasant and cared about our experience. I must admit......their pizza was better than most ...if not....I can't say it lol...compared highly to NY pizza, which is incredible. I thought us New Yorkers had a monopoly over pizza.. I don't think that anymore. Also loved playing pool and pinball there. Just a great overall experience and they put their family history in their pizza story. Don't miss it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went to pickup a take out order and have a round of drinks first. The staff was acting like horny school boys for a group of girls at the bar completely ignored us for 15 mins.. I have been her 3 times now and. It a single good experience.
Restaurantji Recommends
Service great! Owner stopped by our table, very nice touch. Had a small meatball, onion, mushroom pie. The sauce was sweet, crust nicely charred. Could have used a scootch more cheese, but only a comment, not a complaint.Will definitely be back. You should go!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
*sigh* My pizza had raw slabs of bacon all over it and the dough was raw and gummy. The toppings were very poorly slapped on the pie and very undercooked. I don't understand how someone could even consider letting this go out the door to a customer. I had to throw it away. Money wasted. Never again.
Food: 1
I've ordered via DoorDash a few times and the pizza has always been good. Nice crust and the right amount of toppings. I can't speak to the in person experience, but my order arrived hot and tasted great.
Hi I’m coming on here to talk about a reoccurring issue, I live quite close by and often on busy nights like Saturday I find the minimal parking offered leads people to end up parking quite close to our and other people’s houses my only real concern is a lot of the time my mom finds cars partially blocking our driveway if you could please look into suggesting guests to be more mindful of where they park it’d be a huge help besides that I hope y’all continue to have great business!
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
Fun bar ,pool table and pinball ,good pizza and sandwiches friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice