Sugar Bakery

424 Main St, East Haven
(203) 469-0815

Recent Reviews

Sort by
shayna white

The staff at the front are obnoxious! If you don’t like customers and hate your job then you shouldn’t be answering the phone or working at the front of any establishment. You will NEVER receive my business again.

joanne kahl

I walked in to this place for the first time. It looked just as good as the reviews. All I wanted was some fresh macarons. I was so excited to hear them say “yes, we have them“. Until I saw them. I usually just buy a box of frozen macarons at Stop & Shop (right down the street from this bakery) on Saturday’s. In fact, these same exact macarons for $6 a box and a box contains 12. Instead, I was sold the same plastic tray the frozen ones come in, cut in half, with only 6 macarons for $7. I know this as I brought it home and laid it next to my box of frozen ones just to be sure. This isn’t a great business practice and the fact they are reselling frozen baked items and advertising them as not only their own, but freshly baked is very disappointing. I will not be returning to this bakery, not even for a cupcake that I’ve heard are to die for. Tbh, coming from the freezer versus the display case at the bakery, the ones directly from Stop & Shop are actually much fresher.

Mark Douglas

This is our 2nd year that we @ (The workplace) have ordered over 150 cupcakes for our events!! The whole staff Love there cupcakes 🧁 😍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcakes

Ashley K

Never disappoints. I come atleast every 2wks and get my favorite starter pack . 1. Black bottom, Oreo explosion, simply chocolate,

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Asssorted Cupcakes, Chocolate Lover's Dozen

GiGi RF

This bakery is wonderful, they have one of the Best cupcakes I ever had. They are truly the Icing on a cake so delicious, so moist. Not too sweet, just right.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kishan Kandirelli

I ordered a gender reveal-themed cake from this bakery, and I absolutely loved it! The cake was not only delicious but also beautifully designed with a perfect color theme that matched the occasion. It exceeded my expectations, and I would highly recommend SugarBakery for any special event!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookie, Lemon Drop Cupcake, Cupcakes, Cakes, Unicorn Cake, Macarons, Wedding Cake Cupcake

Miriam Rivera-Farrar

I love this place! There are 2 sides, a little shop where you can buy all sorts of little trinkets, cute kid friendly items, all sorts of candies, chocolate, etc. it looks so pretty and lit up, it's almost exciting when you first walk in. Then the best part, the bakery side!!! My absolute favorite cupcake is the Toasted Almond by far, but honestly, you can't go wrong with any that you choose! They are delicious! And then they're macaroons!!!! Mmmmm....also so yummy!! I will say this, they are on the expensive side. Like a little over $3 a cupcake. So you will spend a wee bit for some good sweets. A nice treat once in a while & personally, worth stopping in every time I'm in that area, since I live an hour away. Thank you!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pistachio Midnight Snack Cherry Dip Party, Macarons, Asssorted Cupcakes, Toasted Almond Cupcake

Cindy Stanton

This place was amazing, Thank you to Denise who placed our order and made sure it was ready for pick up. The cupcakes were out of this world and I got rave reviews for the macarons. We will definitely be returning here!!! Thanks again Cindy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Milo Blanchard

Best cupcakes on the planet

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wanda Moore Alston

Blueberry Pomegranate cupcake soooo good...like so many of the other flavors but new for me!! Thank you Sugar Bakery ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

margaret casanas

I've tried many. These are the greatest!

Eric Santillan

You can tell why they are award winning

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex DeMartino

Such a let down. With all the hype about these cupcakes we were sadly very disappointed. We tried their German chocolate, the s'mores, cherry, almond, coconut and double chocolate versions in a six pack. All of them were cold, lifeless and very frosting heavy. Nothing really stood out between them except for the so fake cherry flavor, otherwise they were just run of the mill cupcakes.

Food: 2

Mazie B

The cupcakes are out of this world! The confetti dip and toasted almond are my favorites! Definitely worth a try.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

K Lap

My sister-in-law grabbed an assortment of cupcakes from here for our family's Christmas celebration. These things were great and enjoyed by all.
I don't recall the name of the little chunk of delight I had, but I can assure you that it was very good and was very similar to a Hostess cupcake decorated with a Christmas wreath. It was a chocolate cupcake, with a vanilla buttercream core, dipped in chocolate ganache.
Another note-worthy cupcake was something I believe was called Buddy's Breakfast, which was a bit of a tribute to the movie Elf. I will post a pic of it. It is made to look like it has spaghetti on it, among other items of peculiarity...

Loading...