Sugar Bakery

424 Main St, East Haven
(203) 469-0815

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Pistachio Midnight Snack Cherry Dip Party
Game of Thrones Themed Cupcakes Variety
Ultimate Brownie Sundae Cupcake
Birthday Cake French Macaron
Buddy's Breakfast Cupcake
Chocolate Lover's Dozen
Toasted Almond Cupcake
Cannoli Birthday Cake
Cupcakes Key Lime Pie
Reese's Riot Cupcake

Menu

Gift and Party Packs!
Best Sellers Party Pack
Includes: Cannoli, Oreo Explosion, Reese's Riot, Boston Cream, Simply Vanilla, Chocolate Fudge, Strawberry Cheesecake, Toasted Almond, Cookie Dough, Lemon Drop, Mostess and Red Velvet
Chocolate Lover's Dozen Party Pack
For the chocolate-loving crowd! 3 each of the following: Ultimate Brownie Sundae, Chocolate Fudge, Oreo Explosion and Mostess
'Sending Hugs and Cupcakes' Gift Pack
Is there anything better than hugs AND cupcakes?! This special gift pack features one dozen fun, bright and delicious cupcakes and is sure to brighten the day. Gift packaged with a colorful ‘Sending Hugs and Cupcakes' wrap. Flavors include: 2 Confetti Dip, 2 Rainbow Party Time, 2 Chocolate Party Time, 2 Cookie Dough, 2 Oreo Explosion and 2 Vanilla with Chocolate Buttercream
'Happy Birthday' Cupcake Gift Pack
How do you make a birthday sweeter? With cupcakes, of course! This special birthday pack features one dozen cupcakes packaged in our festive birthday wrap. Flavors include: 2 Confetti Dip, 2 Rainbow Party Time, 2 Chocolate Party Time, 2 Cookie Dough, 2 Oreo Explosion and 2 Vanilla with Chocolate Buttercream
'Happy Birthday' Cupcakes and Dragon Stuffy Pack
Our ‘Happy Birthday' Cupcake Gift Pack features one dozen fun & delicious cupcakes gift packaged in our festive birthday wrap & topped with a dragon stuffy and bow. Flavors: 2 Confetti Dip, 2 Rainbow Party Time, 2 Chocolate Party Time, 2 Cookie Dough, 2 Oreo Explosion, 2 Vanilla/Chocolate with sprinkles. Sending this as a gift? Please specify a short message for card.
'Happy Birthday' Cupcakes and Kitten Stuffy Pack
Our ‘Happy Birthday' Cupcake Gift Pack features one dozen fun & delicious cupcakes gift packaged in our festive birthday wrap & is topped with a kitten stuffy and bow. Flavors: 2 Confetti Dip, 2 Rainbow Party Time, 2 Chocolate Party Time, 2 Cookie Dough, 2 Oreo Explosion, 2 Vanilla/Chocolate with confetti sprinkles. Sending this as a gift? Please specify a short message for card.
'Happy Birthday' Cupcakes and Bear Stuffy Pack
Our ‘Happy Birthday' Cupcake Gift Pack features one dozen fun, bright & delicious cupcakes gift packaged in our festive birthday wrap & is topped with an adorable kitten stuffy and bow. Flavors: 2 Confetti Dip, 2 Rainbow Party Time, 2 Chocolate Party Time, 2 Cookie Dough, 2 Oreo Explosion, 2 Vanilla/Chocolate with sprinkles. Sending this as a gift? Please specify a short message for card.
Sending Hugs, Cupcakes and Kitten Stuffy Pack
Send them hugs, cupcakes and a stuffy to brighten their day! Features one dozen fun, delicious cupcakes & is sure to brighten the day. Gift packaged with a colorful ‘Sending Hugs and Cupcakes' wrap, a kitten stuffy & a bow. Flavors: 2 Confetti Dip, 2 Rainbow Party Time, 2 Chocolate Party Time, 2 Cookie Dough, 2 Oreo Explosion, 2 Vanilla/Chocolate with sprinkles. Sending this as a gift? Please specify a short message for card.
Sending Hugs, Cupcakes and Dragon Stuffy Pack
Send them hugs, cupcakes and a stuffy to brighten their day! Features one dozen fun, delicious cupcakes gift packaged with a colorful ‘Sending Hugs and Cupcakes' wrap, a dragon stuffy & a bow. Flavors: 2 Confetti Dip, 2 Rainbow Party Time, 2 Chocolate Party Time, 2 Cookie Dough, 2 Oreo Explosion, 2 Vanilla/Chocolate with sprinkles. Sending this as a gift? Please specify a short message for card.
Sending Hugs, Cupcakes and Bear Stuffy Pack
Send them hugs, cupcakes and a stuffy to brighten their day! Features one dozen fun, delicious cupcakes gift packaged with a colorful ‘Sending Hugs and Cupcakes' wrap, a bear stuffy & a bow. Flavors: 2 Confetti Dip, 2 Rainbow Party Time, 2 Chocolate Party Time, 2 Cookie Dough, 2 Oreo Explosion, 2 Vanilla/Chocolate with sprinkles. Sending this as a gift? Please specify a short message for card.

Cupcakes
Confetti Dip Cupcake
Confetti cupcake, confetti buttercream, confetti dip-top shell.
Ultimate Brownie Sundae Cupcake
Brownie cupcake, edible chocolate chip cookie dough, vanilla buttercream, chocolate ganache drizzle.
Cannoli Cupcake
Our signature cupcake! Vanilla cupcake, chocolate chip cannoli cream filling, vanilla buttercream, mini morsels.
Reese's Riot Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake, peanut butter cream and reese's peanut butter cup filling, chocolate buttercream.
Strawberry Cheesecake Cupcake
Strawberry cupcake, cream cheese frosting.
Oreo Explosion Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake, vanilla mousse filling with crushed Oreo's, vanilla buttercream.
24 Karat Cake Cupcake
Carrot cake with crushed pineapple, raisins, and coconut, cream cheese frosting.
Black Bottom Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake, chocolate chip cheesecake center, cream cheese and chocolate fudge swirled frosting.
Red Velvet Cupcake
Traditional red velvet cupcake, cream cheese frosting.
Cookie Dough Cupcake
Chocolate chip cupcake, cookie dough buttercream, edible chocolate chip cookie dough.
Boston Cream Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake, Bavarian cream filling, chocolate ganache.
Toasted Almond Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake, almond buttercream, rolled in butter crunch with toasted coconut.
Simply Vanilla Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake, vanilla buttercream.
Chocolate Fudge Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake, chocolate fudge frosting, rainbow sprinkles.
Coconut Dream Cupcake
Coconut cupcake, cream cheese frosting, toasted coconut.
Mostess Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake, vanilla buttercream core, dipped in chocolate ganache, icing curl.
Simply Chocolate Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake, chocolate buttercream.
The German Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake, coconut, caramel, and pecan filling, chocolate ganache, toasted coconut.
Lemon Drop Cupcake
Lemon cupcake, lemon buttercream, sprinkles.
Vegan/Dairy Free* Party Time Cupcake
Confetti cupcake, vanilla frosting, rolled in rainbow sprinkles. *All ingredients are vegan/dairy free.
Campfire S'mores Cupcake
Graham cupcake, fudge filled, marshmallow fluff buttercream, chocolate dip-top shell, graham cracker crumbs
Pistachio Cheesecake Cupcake
Pistachio cupcake, cream cheese frosting, pistachios
Cherry Dip Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake, vanilla buttercream, cherry dip-top shell
Blueberry Stuffed French Toast Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake, blueberry pie filling, maple buttercream, French toast bite
Pumpkin Cheesecake Cupcake
Pumpkin cupcake, cinnamon cream cheese frosting
Black Forest Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake, cherry pie filling, fresh whipped cream frosting, chocolate curls
Gluten Free* Cherry Dip Cupcake
Gluten free vanilla cupcake, vanilla buttercream, cherry dip top shell, sprinkles (*Made with all gluten free ingredients. Facility is not gluten free.)
Gluten Free Cannoli Cupcake
Gluten free* vanilla cupcake, chocolate chip cannoli cream, chocolate curls. (*Made with all gluten free ingredients. Facility is not gluten free.)
Vegan/Dairy Free Party Time Cupcake
Vegan* confetti cupcake, vegan vanilla buttercream, rolled in rainbow sprinkles. (*Made with all dairy free/vegan ingredients. Facility is not vegan/dairy free.)
Apple Pie Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake, apple pie filling, fresh whipped cream frosting, cinnamon sugar
Halloween Party Time Cupcake
Confetti cupcake, vanilla buttercream, sprinkles, decorative spider ring
Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake dipped in chocolate ganache, raspberry buttercream, chocolate truffle, chocolate ganache drizzle
Peanut Butter Dream Cupcake
Peanut butter cupcake dipped in white chocolate, peanut butter buttercream, white chocolate curls
Gluten Free* Chocolate Chip Cheesecake Cupcake
Gluten free chocolate cupcake, cream cheese frosting, chocolate chips. *Made with gluten free ingredients. Facility is not gluten free.
Vegan/Dairy Free* Vanilla Oreo Dirt Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake, Oreo frosting, Oreo crumbs, decorative spider ring. *Made with all dairy free and vegan ingredients. Facility is not vegan or dairy free.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+88 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+87 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We ordered cupcakes from our wedding from here and they were INCREDIBLE. The flavors were out of this world - Hostess Cupcake, Oreo explosion, 24Karat to name a few. - and they also had a good gluten free option for our GF guests. I loved the seasonal flavor options. Everything was so delicious and Brenda and her staff were a pleasure to work with. It was one of the highlights of my wedding planning and day. We got lots of compliments from guests. Thank you Sugar Bakery, can't...
October 2025
I ordered a birthday cake, and was delighted by the customer service (thank you, Denise!). We were thrilled with the result-the cake was fabulous! When we picked up the cake, we were tempted by the other treats in the bakery and bought several amazing decorated cookies and a cupcake. This will be my go-to bakery! A true gem.
September 2025
First time at Sugar Bakery today, and was so impressed with the whole experience. The cupcakes were outstanding...moist with just the right amount of sweetness. The staff working there were extremely friendly and helpful. The place was immaculate. Will most definitely be back and highly recommend!
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Chicken Roast asados y algo más… - 430 Main St
Tolli's Apizza & Restaurant - 410 Main St
Pizza, Italian, American, Vegetarian
Sabor Latino Deli - 405 Main St
Mexican, Spanish, Latin American

Sugar Bakery

424 Main St, East Haven, CT 06512
(203) 469-0815