Went there for a valentine's dinner. Had a very good menu. They had a singer named Mike quintelliani, who wasn't all in all it was a great night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
K A
Let's talk about the fettuccine Alfredo. The sauce was barely there, also cooked on too high of a heat since you can see small curdles. It honestly lacked flavor, I'm disappointed đ
Food: 3
Jessica Rascati
Do not book an event here. I hosted my baby shower at this location on 02/08/26 and it was a complete nightmare. This was supposed to be a day about me celebrating with friends and family, but instead, I spent the entire time stressed out, angry, and managing the staffâs incompetence.
The negligence was staggering. We had a strict two-hour reservation starting at 2:00 PM. Despite the restaurant being virtually empty, the server completely ignored us for a full hour. She didnât even take our order until 3:00 PM, leaving us with only an hour to eat and celebrate. It felt like she either couldnât understand English or simply refused to listen to a word I said.
I was the host. I selected the package. I called and set everything up. Yet, she ignored my direct instructions and took orders from other guests instead, resulting in pizzas with toppings I specifically told her not to include. When the food runner brought the wrong order, instead of apologizing, she gave me an attitude and said, 'I didn't put the order in.' I donât care who put it inâyou work there, fix it!
The service was lazy and stingy. One plate of bread each table for a whole group? Empty drink pitchers for twenty minutes? I walked out of my own baby shower feeling defeated and upset because the staff couldnât do the bare minimum. You ruined a special day I can never get back!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Christopher Rascati
We hosted a baby shower at Tolliâs in East Haven and unfortunately the experience was really disappointing.
When we arrived around 2 PM, the restaurant was nearly empty, yet there was no host or staff at the entrance to guide guests coming in and out, which immediately made things confusing. Our server seemed unsure of what was going on from the start. We didnât even begin placing our food order until around 3 PM, despite the event starting an hour earlier.
We clearly told the server which pizzas we wanted, but one of them still came out wrong. Between the delays, lack of organization, and overall inattentiveness â especially considering how empty the restaurant was â it put a damper on what was supposed to be a special celebration.
We understand restaurants get busy, but in this case that wasnât the issue. Basic coordination and communication would have made a huge difference. We hope management takes this feedback seriously so future guests have a better experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Robert Acquarulo
One of my top 5 places for Apizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jean Edwards-Chieppo
Got Guisepinas meatballs and a pizza. The meatballs are absolutely delicious! The pizza was perfect! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sheri Z
Pasta dishes are excellent!! That was the best pizza I have ever had. Thank you Tolliâs youâre the best!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nancy Golia
We love it pizza great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nutella Apizza
Katie George
Have been coming to Tolliâs for 30 years. Every time That I am here the staff is friendly and inviting. The food is consistently excellent. The pizza rivals and New Haven pizza. If you not on the mood for pizza there are many choices on the menu.
waitstaff were very inappropriate to a friend of mine, unprofessional and rude
Mike Smith
Went in recently and was treated very poorly by a woman named Karina. Not sure how you keep an employee who is so rude to customers.
Edit: not sure why the owner is pretending like they do not know who their daughter is, but nice try! Try being better people and running a better business.
Service: 1
U6215XScarlaj
Family that owns this place is awful. Absolutely terrible people. And they run their business as such. Poor customer service, cold and nasty food.
MMS hinman
I was so disappointed I ordered a Chicken cutlet sub for takeout and it was so mushy. I couldnât even eat it. The bread was just a mushy mess.
Food: 1
JRA
Great New Haven style pizza without the lines! Delicious food and a wonderful staff! Now my familyâs âgo toâ pizza restaurant!
Love there Happ hour menu đ
Went there for a valentine's dinner. Had a very good menu. They had a singer named Mike quintelliani, who wasn't all in all it was a great night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Let's talk about the fettuccine Alfredo. The sauce was barely there, also cooked on too high of a heat since you can see small curdles. It honestly lacked flavor, I'm disappointed đ
Food: 3
Do not book an event here. I hosted my baby shower at this location on 02/08/26 and it was a complete nightmare. This was supposed to be a day about me celebrating with friends and family, but instead, I spent the entire time stressed out, angry, and managing the staffâs incompetence.
The negligence was staggering. We had a strict two-hour reservation starting at 2:00 PM. Despite the restaurant being virtually empty, the server completely ignored us for a full hour. She didnât even take our order until 3:00 PM, leaving us with only an hour to eat and celebrate. It felt like she either couldnât understand English or simply refused to listen to a word I said.
I was the host. I selected the package. I called and set everything up. Yet, she ignored my direct instructions and took orders from other guests instead, resulting in pizzas with toppings I specifically told her not to include. When the food runner brought the wrong order, instead of apologizing, she gave me an attitude and said, 'I didn't put the order in.' I donât care who put it inâyou work there, fix it!
The service was lazy and stingy. One plate of bread each table for a whole group? Empty drink pitchers for twenty minutes? I walked out of my own baby shower feeling defeated and upset because the staff couldnât do the bare minimum. You ruined a special day I can never get back!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
We hosted a baby shower at Tolliâs in East Haven and unfortunately the experience was really disappointing.
When we arrived around 2 PM, the restaurant was nearly empty, yet there was no host or staff at the entrance to guide guests coming in and out, which immediately made things confusing. Our server seemed unsure of what was going on from the start. We didnât even begin placing our food order until around 3 PM, despite the event starting an hour earlier.
We clearly told the server which pizzas we wanted, but one of them still came out wrong. Between the delays, lack of organization, and overall inattentiveness â especially considering how empty the restaurant was â it put a damper on what was supposed to be a special celebration.
We understand restaurants get busy, but in this case that wasnât the issue. Basic coordination and communication would have made a huge difference. We hope management takes this feedback seriously so future guests have a better experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
One of my top 5 places for Apizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got Guisepinas meatballs and a pizza. The meatballs are absolutely delicious! The pizza was perfect! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pasta dishes are excellent!!
That was the best pizza I have ever had.
Thank you Tolliâs youâre the best!
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love it pizza great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nutella Apizza
Have been coming to Tolliâs for 30 years. Every time
That I am here the staff is friendly and inviting. The food is consistently excellent. The pizza rivals and New Haven pizza. If you not on the mood for pizza there are many choices on the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
waitstaff were very inappropriate to a friend of mine, unprofessional and rude
Went in recently and was treated very poorly by a woman named Karina. Not sure how you keep an employee who is so rude to customers.
Edit: not sure why the owner is pretending like they do not know who their daughter is, but nice try! Try being better people and running a better business.
Service: 1
Family that owns this place is awful. Absolutely terrible people. And they run their business as such. Poor customer service, cold and nasty food.
I was so disappointed I ordered a Chicken cutlet sub for takeout and it was so mushy. I couldnât even eat it. The bread was just a mushy mess.
Food: 1
Great New Haven style pizza without the lines! Delicious food and a wonderful staff! Now my familyâs âgo toâ pizza restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...