Get the white pizza. Incredible. Regular pie very good, but not as good as New Haven location, not sure why. Friendly service, big dining room. Be careful to check the label on your parking spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sergio CT
Is my second horrible experience with this place, first in Stamford with a 2 year old waiting two hours to eat and then messing up the order and now in Fairfield, I thought in giving it another chance this time to go, the pizza with shrimp was drenched in butter through the pizza box and so saggy it had to be eaten with a spoon. Ended up in the garbage the whole thing. Never again
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Matthew Santiago
Always wanted to try Sally’s pizza heard good things. As soon as I got to the restaurant I notice it’s was empty but I see the guys in the back making the pizza, everything smelled great. BUT like I said the restaurant was empty and after waiting so long to be seated I decided not to wait any longer and left.
Service: 1
M K
The satellite locations of these iconic New Haven pizza places that sell out to larger ownership groups never seem to be able to replicate the original.
This isn't bad pizza, but it isn't *Sally's.* You are most certainly paying a premium for the name - but that is all it is, a name. There are other places in Fairfield that have equivalent pizza for less money.
If you want Sally's, take a ride to New Haven. And if you're going to take that ride, maybe hit one of the places that isn't focused on expansion and is just making excellent pizza.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Claudine R.
I’m addicted to Sally’s Calabrian stinger pizza and decided to come here instead of going to Stamford because of the difficulty in finding parking. This place delivered! We also tried another pie with mushrooms and onions, and that was great too! Service was friendly, and the atmosphere was a good dinner spot on a Monday night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
K M
I have to give such a low rating because this place is a rip off and insult to real traditional new haven style pizza especially with the “Sally’s” name serving a SMALL SIZE PIE and calling it a large!
The first picture is 2025 the second is 2023 both fairfield location.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Megan Kirven
I get why Connecticut is famous for Pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Hellauer
I brought my pals here and they loved it, great job Sally’s
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nancy Terrill
We can’t rave enough about the fresh tomato pie! It was sublime! Major summertime treat
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roy Cohen
Ordered pizza for 5:20-5:30. Got there at 5:15 and the Puzza was already sitting on the counter. Opened it in the car and realized it was cool and very overcooked ( I like my pizza crispy) I called when I got home to complain but went straight to voicemail and never got a return call. NEVER again will I go to the Sally’s Fairfield location Absolutely awful Threw the Pizza away before I realized I should have take a picture. NEVER GOT A RETURN PHONE CALL!!! Even though I left a detailed message. I guess they do not CARE
I love the crust on this pizza. It’s addicting! You have to try Sally’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard W
Delicious classic New Haven-style coal-fired pizza with a thin, charred, crispy, chewy crust. Wine selection is surprisingly great for a pizza joint. Sally’s is known for their tomato sauce so I recommend something like the Firebird over the clam pizza. In my opinion, Frank Pepe’s makes a better, lighter, more aromatic clam pizza, but the red sauce pizzas are better at Sally’s.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Red (Red06794)
Not the same as Sally's in New Haven. The pizza was only so so and very oily. Also they seem to be shrinking the size of the pizza so that a large is now about the size of a medium and the pizza's are no longer square. Restaurant was very warm and bathrooms were not maintained well (no hand soap, paper towels). Overall, not the best experience.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Hope Weisser
Visiting from out of town, tried several different pies. The pizza was great, service was great. Recommend you visit and try the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chunky Guac
Not a bad pie but as a New Haven native I was definitely expecting better. It had that nice New Haven style char around the crust, however, the cheese + sauce was pretty mushy and oily , leading to a very floppy slice (apart from the crust).
The service was also very slow , we sat there and ordered only 1 pie and it took an hour to come out (it was not busy). The server was very nice and apologetic about it - we don’t blame them - I just wish the food didn’t take so long!
Get the white pizza. Incredible. Regular pie very good, but not as good as New Haven location, not sure why. Friendly service, big dining room. Be careful to check the label on your parking spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Is my second horrible experience with this place, first in Stamford with a 2 year old waiting two hours to eat and then messing up the order and now in Fairfield, I thought in giving it another chance this time to go, the pizza with shrimp was drenched in butter through the pizza box and so saggy it had to be eaten with a spoon. Ended up in the garbage the whole thing.
Never again
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Always wanted to try Sally’s pizza heard good things. As soon as I got to the restaurant I notice it’s was empty but I see the guys in the back making the pizza, everything smelled great. BUT like I said the restaurant was empty and after waiting so long to be seated I decided not to wait any longer and left.
Service: 1
The satellite locations of these iconic New Haven pizza places that sell out to larger ownership groups never seem to be able to replicate the original.
This isn't bad pizza, but it isn't *Sally's.* You are most certainly paying a premium for the name - but that is all it is, a name. There are other places in Fairfield that have equivalent pizza for less money.
If you want Sally's, take a ride to New Haven. And if you're going to take that ride, maybe hit one of the places that isn't focused on expansion and is just making excellent pizza.
Food: 3
Service: 4
I’m addicted to Sally’s Calabrian stinger pizza and decided to come here instead of going to Stamford because of the difficulty in finding parking. This place delivered! We also tried another pie with mushrooms and onions, and that was great too! Service was friendly, and the atmosphere was a good dinner spot on a Monday night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have to give such a low rating because this place is a rip off and insult to real traditional new haven style pizza especially with the “Sally’s” name serving a SMALL SIZE PIE and calling it a large!
The first picture is 2025 the second is 2023 both fairfield location.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I get why Connecticut is famous for Pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I brought my pals here and they loved it, great job Sally’s
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We can’t rave enough about the fresh tomato pie! It was sublime! Major summertime treat
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered pizza for 5:20-5:30. Got there at 5:15 and the Puzza was already sitting on the counter.
Opened it in the car and realized it was cool and very overcooked ( I like my pizza crispy)
I called when I got home to complain but went straight to voicemail and never got a return call.
NEVER again will I go to the Sally’s Fairfield location
Absolutely awful
Threw the Pizza away before I realized I should have take a picture.
NEVER GOT A RETURN PHONE CALL!!! Even though I left a detailed message. I guess they do not CARE
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
I love the crust on this pizza. It’s addicting! You have to try Sally’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious classic New Haven-style coal-fired pizza with a thin, charred, crispy, chewy crust. Wine selection is surprisingly great for a pizza joint. Sally’s is known for their tomato sauce so I recommend something like the Firebird over the clam pizza. In my opinion, Frank Pepe’s makes a better, lighter, more aromatic clam pizza, but the red sauce pizzas are better at Sally’s.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not the same as Sally's in New Haven. The pizza was only so so and very oily. Also they seem to be shrinking the size of the pizza so that a large is now about the size of a medium and the pizza's are no longer square. Restaurant was very warm and bathrooms were not maintained well (no hand soap, paper towels). Overall, not the best experience.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Visiting from out of town, tried several different pies. The pizza was great, service was great. Recommend you visit and try the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not a bad pie but as a New Haven native I was definitely expecting better. It had that nice New Haven style char around the crust, however, the cheese + sauce was pretty mushy and oily , leading to a very floppy slice (apart from the crust).
The service was also very slow , we sat there and ordered only 1 pie and it took an hour to come out (it was not busy). The server was very nice and apologetic about it - we don’t blame them - I just wish the food didn’t take so long!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Loading...