Margaritas Mexican Restaurant

12 Water St, Mystic
(860) 536-4589

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Guajillo Shrimp Salad
Loaded Skillet Nachos
Mucho Sabor Fajitas
Grilled Baja Tacos
Roasted Vegetables
Steak Chimichanga
Margarita Flight
Supreme Burrito
Chicken Fajitas
Chips and Salsa

Menu

Featured items
Chicken Baby Chimis
Fried Ice Cream
Sweet vanilla ice cream with a salty crushed pretzel shell, covered in chocolate sauce or honey - both, if you're feeling loco!
Queso
Our distinctive Mexican, melted cheese dip.
Lava Cake
Chocolate cake with a molten chocolate center, topped with white chocolate shavings.
Quesadilla Extravaganza
Juan's Handheld Burrito
Street Corn
Just like from the streets of Mexico. Served on or off the cobb, topped with chipotle aioli and queso fresco.
Enchiladas Muchachas
Big Combo! Featuring one beef enchilada and one chicken enchilada bathed in a special sauce, covered in melted cheese, green onions and sour cream. Served with Mexican rice and beans.
Chicken Chimichanga
Steak Fajitas
Char-grilled prime steak marinated and served medium rare.

Appetizers
Street Corn
Just like from the streets of Mexico. Served on or off the cobb, topped with chipotle aioli and queso fresco.
Chicken Baby Chimis
Lightly fried mini chimichangas filled with chicken and cheese. Served with guacamole and sour cream. Yeah, they're awesome.
Queso
Our distinctive Mexican, melted cheese dip.
Loaded Skillet Nachos
You ready for this? House-fried chips over a bed of refried beans, double layered with chicken or beef, smothered with queso, jack and cheddar cheeses, served with jalapeños, guacamole, salsa fresca, and sour cream.
Guacamole
Made fresh to order.
Charred Jerk Wings
Deep fried and hand-tossed in a deliciously spicy jerk sauce. Finished on the grill.
Fried Pickles
House made in a cherry pepper brine. Served with Three Pepper Sauce for dipping.
Juan's Tenders
Chipotle BBQ, buffalo or spicy coconut sauce.
Hector's Quesadilla
Grill a flour tortilla filled with cheese and mild red and green chiles, add a little sour cream and a touch of guacamole and you have a "case-uh-dee-yuh."
Jalapeno Baby Chimis
Jalapeno and cream cheese filled mini chimichangas. Served with cucumber ranch dressing.
Mayan Shrimp
Lightly fried shrimp, tossed in chipotle aioli with fire roasted corn salsa, pickled onions, three pepper sauce, and avocado.
Juan's Wings
Chipotle BBQ, buffalo or spicy coconut sauce.

Fajitas
Steak Fajitas
Char-grilled prime steak marinated and served medium rare.
Chicken Fajitas
Half pound of juicy marinated and grilled chicken breast.
Original Combo Fajita
Classic chicken and steak for when you can't decide.
Guadalajara Steak Fajita
Spicy. Delicious cracked pepper steak.
Island Jerk Chicken Fajita
Overflowing with all the fixin's. Seared with our Caribbean spice blend.
Shrimp Fajitas
Juicy large shrimp sautéed in our special salsa butter.

Tacos
Flour Tortilla Taco
Hard Shell Taco
Original Fish Tacos
Tortilla-encrusted fish, roasted corn salsa, shredded red cabbage and chipotle aioli on soft corn tortillas.
Grilled Baja Tacos
Perfectly grilled mahi dusted with a special blend of spices. Served in grilled flour tortillas with red cabbage, three pepper sauce, salsa fresca, and avocado.
Tacos Del Mar
Baja style, beer-battered fish, scallions, orange slaw, three pepper sauce and avocado, on soft corn tortillas.
Grilled Shrimp Lettuce Tacos
Plump seasoned shrimp grilled to perfection and served on lettuce leaves with corn salsa, chipotle aioli drizzle and three pepper sauce, topped with pickled onions and avocado.
White Corn Tortilla Taco
Taco Gigante
Our 2 pound taco featuring a foot-long shell filled with seasoned chicken, ground beef, bacon, refried beans, Mexican rice, cheese, lettuce, salsa Fresca, queso, and our Picante, Hacienda and Crema sauces topped with pickled jalapenos!!

Salads
Taco Salad
This is big! Crisp tortilla bowl filled with shredded lettuce, cheese, corn salsa, salsa fresca, enchilada sauce and your choice of ground beef or chicken. Topped with guacamole and sour cream.
Chicken Fajita Salad
Half Fajita, half salad, 100% beautiful. Grilled chicken atop a bed of lettuce with beans, seared onions and peppers, salsa fresca, cheese and guacamole.
Coconut Shrimp Salad
Lightly fried shrimp tossed in spicy coconut sauce. Served over chopped lettuce, cucumbers, salsa fresca, roasted corn salsa and queso fresco. Comes with our house tequila lime vinaigrette dressing.

Vegetarian
Enchiladas Banderas
Three enchiladas filled with cheese, guacamole, refritos and salsa fresca, baked in red, white and green sauces. Served with Mexican rice and beans.
Burrito Vegetariano
A flour tortilla stuffed with beans, rice and sautéed vegetables. Baked in our enchilada sauce and cheese, and topped with lettuce, salsa fresca and sour cream.
Roasted Vegetable Zarape
Sauteed spinach, fire-roasted corn, onions, mushrooms and peppers baked on a skillet with our signature salsa butter and cheese. Served with sour cream and flour tortillas.

Enchiladas
Mexican Flag
3 cheese enchiladas stuffed with cheese, steak, ground beef and chicken. Baked in red, white and green sauce topped with salsa Fresca and green onions served with Mexican rice and beans.
Enchiladas Muchachas
Big Combo! Featuring one beef enchilada and one chicken enchilada bathed in a special sauce, covered in melted cheese, green onions and sour cream. Served with Mexican rice and beans.
Skillet Baked Enchiladas
One steak enchilada, one chicken enchilada and one stuffed with salsa fresca. Skillet baked with our house tomatillo sauce. Served with Mexican rice and beans.
Enchiladas Frescas
Two of our sauced and baked enchiladas stuffed with our fresh tomato salsa and sautéed mushrooms. Served with Mexican rice and beans. Topped with sour cream.

Burritos
Burritos Supreme
Large fl our tortilla stuffed with refritos and your choice of juicy beef or chicken. Baked in our sauce and cheese. Topped with sour cream.
Juan's Handheld Burrito
Chicken or Ground Beef, queso, Mexican rice, beans, crema, guacamole and salsa fresca.
Tio's Super Burrito
A real belt buster. Super chunks of sirloin and refritos stuffed in a giant flour tortilla. Baked with lots of sauce and lettuce and salsa fresca piled on top. Served with guacamole and sour cream.

Los Favoritos
Chicken Chimichanga
Legendary favorite! (Cheemee-chong-uh). Sounds funny- looks good, tastes great. Shredded chicken and cheese, rolled into a flour tortilla, lightly fried, then baked in our red chile sauce and cheese. Served with Mexican rice and beans, guacamole and sour cream.
Quesadilla Extravaganza
Seasoned chicken, ground beef or sautéed spinach in a flour tortilla grilled with salsa fresca, mild chiles and cheese. Served with guacamole and sour cream.
Margaritas Famous Taster
Try a little of everything! A beef taco, chicken burrito and beef enchilada. Served with Mexican rice and beans.
Mexican Smashed Burger
Two smashed quarter-pound patties cooked with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, house made pickles & our homemade zesty smash sauce. Served with fries.
Steak Chimichanga
Seasoned sirloin and refried beans rolled in a flour tortilla. Lightly fried, baked in queso and topped with salsa fresca. Served with Mexican rice.
Carne Asada
12 Ounce Grilled seasoned steak topped with hacienda sauce and salsa fresca. Served with Mexican Rice and beans.
Americano Burger
A juicy half-pound burger with lettuce, tomato, and American cheese. Served with fries.

Sides
Bag of Chips
Queso
Pint of Salsa
Side of Guacamole
Rice & Beans
Mexican Rice
Single Taco Del Mar
Single Grilled Baja Taco
Fries
Beans
Single Shrimp Taco
Side Salad

Kids
Glad-To-See-Ya Quesadilla
Kid's Taco
Hard corn, soft white corn or flour tortilla with chicken or ground beef and lettuce, cheese and tomato.Add a second taco for $1
Neato Burrito
Chicken, ground beef or beans smothered in mild red chili sauce and cheese.
Kickin' Chicken Fingers
Breaded chicken lightly fried.
Kid's Burger
Kid's Steak Fajita
Grilled steak with a choice of soft corn or flour tortillas. Served with lettuce, cheese and sour cream.
Kid's Chicken Fajita
Grilled chicken with a choice of soft corn or flour tortillas. Served with lettuce, cheese and sour cream.
Gnarly Nachos
Gooey melted cheese over chips.
Kid's Chicken Sandwich
Kid's Cheeseburger

Dessert
Super Grande
Churros + our famous Fried Ice Cream + vanilla ice cream. Topped with chocolate sauce. What more could you want?
Churros
Warm churro sticks tossed in cinnamon and sugar. Served with vanilla ice cream and chocolate.
Lava Cake
Chocolate cake with a molten chocolate center, topped with white chocolate shavings.
Fried Ice Cream
Sweet vanilla ice cream with a salty crushed pretzel shell, covered in chocolate sauce or honey - both, if you're feeling loco!

Squeeze
Squeeze

Family Dinner
Tacos
Chicken, beef, or steak tacos, served with your choice ofhard shell corn tortillas, soft corn tortillas, or soft flourtortillas. Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese. Hacienda,crema, and picante sauce on the side. Served with Mexicanrice and refried beans and includes a big bowl of chips and salsa.
Fajitas
Comes with all the fajita fixin's and your choice of corn or flour tortillas. Served with Mexican rice, refried beans, and includes a big bowl of chips, salsa, and guacamole.
Combo Fajitas
Comes with all the fajita fixin's and your choice of corn or flour tortillas. Served with Mexican rice, refried beans, and includes a big bowl of chips, salsa, and guacamole.
Enchiladas
Cheese enchiladas with your choice of chicken, beef, orsalsa fresca. Served with Mexican rice, refried beans,and sour cream. Includes a big bowl of chips, and salsa.

Take & Bake
Quesadilla Extravaganza
Chicken Baby Chimis
Juan's Handheld Burrito
Enchiladas Muchachas
Glad-To-See-Ya Quesadilla
Enchiladas Rancheras
Jalapeno Baby Chimis
Skillet Baked Enchiladas
Chicken Chimichanga
Burrito Supreme
Neato Burrito

Beverages
Mexican Coke
Jarritos Pineapple
Jarritos Mandarin
Bottled Water
Jarritos Grapefruit

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
+80 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+79 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This place is a bit of a tourist trap. Food was mediocre and lacked authenticity. The salsa was straight from the jar and tasted of vinegar. The enchiladas were a bit bland. Not sure what kind of rice we were served but it was not prepared the traditionally Mexican way. Service was ok. Atmosphere was warm and inviting. Multilevel restaurant offers many unique dining experiences. It’s too bad the food isn’t better, this place has the potential to be a real gem.
September 2024
We drove from Canada to CT and one thing on our list was to have dinner at Margaritas. It was after 5 long years and customer service, food and ambience was great as olden days.

Our server Jennifer made our day and we felt so nostalgic. Her suggestion in terms food and drink was so good. I had gone to eat Jalapeno Chimes and ended up having Roasted Vegetable Zarape.
August 2024
Service was excellent!! We dined upstairs in the lounge area (cuz we're adults) and a family with small children came upstairs and sat right next to us, was obnoxious to say the least but in the MOST professional way, our waitress politely moved them to a different table so we decided to stay for another round of margaritas -- which were GREAT! waitress had good recommendations among her impeccable service. Food was decent, we only had the skillet nachos, but was definitely...
July 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Mystic River Chocolate Cafe - 12 Water St
Coffee & Tea, Chocolatiers & Shops, Beer Bar
Friar Tuck's Tavern - 12 Water St
Irish, British, American, Sports Bar, Vegetarian
Oyster Club - 13 Water St
Fine Dining, American, Seafood, New American, Pet Friendly

Margaritas Mexican Restaurant

12 Water St, Mystic, CT 06355
(860) 536-4589