If you want pizza, this is the place to go. It is located in a convenience store, so it isn't the kind of place I would necessarily dine in, but for take out, you can't top it. I have had several types of pizza here and everything I have tried has been excellent. I got a meatball parm grinder last time to switch things up, and it was incredible. This is my go to for pizza. I won't even bother with anywhere else in the area. The staff are also friendly and helpful. Easily my favorite place to get food to bring home.
Pu G
Fresh pizza and service is awesome! The sitting area is nice too. Had veggie pizza and it was good, margarita and chicken was good too. Mozzarella sticks were yum too!
Jason Kane
My son’s gold standard for pizza.
Bekah Kilgore
Best pizza I’ve ever had
Josh Scalora
Amazing Pizza located in a large gas station convenience store. Make sure to stop by and get one on the way home.
Ava Miner
Not even close to as good as before. Many changes, not for the better.
Rebecca Harvey
So upset about the changes made within Three Fellas- they were our “go to” pizza place for years prior to the remodel. Conveyor pizza is just not the same as before. A pizza place with no provolone cheese is kinda crazy for those that don’t eat American cheese on grinders. They had the Best garlic bread and took it off the menu. Our office ordered last week and the person ordering made an error, not able to call to fix, you’re stuck with what you’ve got. It’s literally turned into gas station pizza, in my opinion. So very disappointing.
boris karpman
Best pizza in South East
Food: 5
Kariann Moran
Great food great service! Friendly staff. 🖤 10/10 would recommend.
Lenny
We weren’t impressed. $66 for two doughy/chewy crust pizza’s was the deal breaker.
I heard a lot of good things about Three Fellas Pizza before moving in to town, it lives up to the expectation! Definitely recommend and will continue to go to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Ryan Clark
Pizza is always the best , only downside is that they don’t have a working phone number anymore. They’re insistent ordering online through a website is better. They’re losing out on a lot of clientele that way. Other then that best pizza in the area
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Charlie Gotta
Beautiful new building, great pizza, wish they had cold cut grinders...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
MC
Dry, overpriced pizza. The new 3 Fellas is a bad version of Cumberland Farms. Go across the road -BigY has better pizza
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Matt Loiacono
Glad to have some solid pizza in the neighborhood! Got takeout the other day, new location looks clean and modern.
For me the pizza is a solid 8/10, quite good but it does leave a bit to be desired if you're expecting a fully authentic NY slice. Sauce/cheese tastes great, but the dough/crust just isn't quite there.
Nonetheless, will be our go-to pizza spot from now on! Can't beat this, especially for only 5 mins from home for us ?
If you want pizza, this is the place to go. It is located in a convenience store, so it isn't the kind of place I would necessarily dine in, but for take out, you can't top it. I have had several types of pizza here and everything I have tried has been excellent. I got a meatball parm grinder last time to switch things up, and it was incredible. This is my go to for pizza. I won't even bother with anywhere else in the area. The staff are also friendly and helpful. Easily my favorite place to get food to bring home.
Fresh pizza and service is awesome! The sitting area is nice too. Had veggie pizza and it was good, margarita and chicken was good too. Mozzarella sticks were yum too!
My son’s gold standard for pizza.
Best pizza I’ve ever had
Amazing Pizza located in a large gas station convenience store. Make sure to stop by and get one on the way home.
Not even close to as good as before. Many changes, not for the better.
So upset about the changes made within Three Fellas- they were our “go to” pizza place for years prior to the remodel. Conveyor pizza is just not the same as before. A pizza place with no provolone cheese is kinda crazy for those that don’t eat American cheese on grinders. They had the Best garlic bread and took it off the menu. Our office ordered last week and the person ordering made an error, not able to call to fix, you’re stuck with what you’ve got. It’s literally turned into gas station pizza, in my opinion. So very disappointing.
Best pizza in South East
Food: 5
Great food great service! Friendly staff. 🖤 10/10 would recommend.
We weren’t impressed. $66 for two doughy/chewy crust pizza’s was the deal breaker.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I heard a lot of good things about Three Fellas Pizza before moving in to town, it lives up to the expectation! Definitely recommend and will continue to go to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Pizza is always the best , only downside is that they don’t have a working phone number anymore. They’re insistent ordering online through a website is better. They’re losing out on a lot of clientele that way. Other then that best pizza in the area
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Beautiful new building, great pizza, wish they had cold cut grinders...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Dry, overpriced pizza. The new 3 Fellas is a bad version of Cumberland Farms. Go across the road -BigY has better pizza
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Glad to have some solid pizza in the neighborhood! Got takeout the other day, new location looks clean and modern.
For me the pizza is a solid 8/10, quite good but it does leave a bit to be desired if you're expecting a fully authentic NY slice. Sauce/cheese tastes great, but the dough/crust just isn't quite there.
Nonetheless, will be our go-to pizza spot from now on! Can't beat this, especially for only 5 mins from home for us ?
Loading...