Carmela's on the Extension

139 Main Street Extension, Middletown
(860) 788-7922

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mike S

The food here is fine, but I got turned off by the place because when my partner and I asked to be seated at a booth for breakfast, the request was steadfastly refused, citing their policy that booths were only for 3 or more people. OK, fine. Rules are rules. However, the next couple that came in the door after us got a booth no problem. I know it's probably petty of me to hold it against the place because of that one incident, but that's how it goes sometimes. Can't help how I feel.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Tytiana Washington

I love this place! I go here as a place I like to treat myself to. Service is great, food is great, and it always comes quickly. The portions are perfect as well as the price. I love getting their hot chocolate. I can't say there is anything that I have tried that tastes bad. When I can, I take my friends or family with me. Whoever I take, they always enjoy it too. I definitely recommend. It can get pretty packed, so if you're going with a group, planning might be required, especially for parking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Harvic

Placed a pickup order, got there, no one was there, lights out. Google and uber says they close at 8, we placed the order at around 6. Tried to cancel, Uber charged me the full bill and sent to the restaurant for a cancellation fee. C'mon man.

Rukasu Hebi

This place is amazing. Large portions, great food. Amazing food. I am most definitely going again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anais Paredes

Dennis the menace in the kitchen kills it EVERY SINGLE TIME TRY HIS HASH AND BISCUTS !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Juliet Cavanaugh

Have been here for breakfast many times. The food is a solid 3 to 4 stars. Service is always super friendly and the place is busy with a fun, happy vibe. However, this past weekend we went for breakfast and will not come back and this is the reason why: The owner of the restaurant, who we believe is also the chef, delivered a profanity laden dressing down of one of her employees that most of the restaurant heard. Every vulgar word that you can think of came out of her mouth as she screamed at one at her employee for some transgression(s). And we are people that have no problem with salty language! However, any issue she had with her employee should’ve been dealt with privately, not while screaming from the kitchen for all of the guests to hear. It was verbal abuse and beyond unprofessional. How that employee did not run out of the restaurant in tears I do not know. But if that is how the owner of the restaurant treats her staff, she does not deserve our business.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

daniel riedl

Food was good, service could be better. Not a bad price tag for today’s standard

Paul Letourneau

11/10 must stop. Amazing food, friendly service. Try the strawberry lemonade poppy seed pancakes and the pastrami egg sandwich. The jalapeno popper scrambler special was out of this world!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

CeCe D

This was my first time having food from here and also it definitely will be my last time.. I have ordered a bacon egg and cheese sandwich and I found some weird stuff on my sandwich.. I should have had listen to my daughter when she told me her food wasn't fully cooked... So with that being said I will give up zero Stars.. I no longer trust this restaurant at all!! I would have posted a picture of it but for some reason I don't see where I can post it at.

Master Lord Guru

Sunday brunch with the family. Food was excellent. Are waitress was a young girl who is clearly learning her trade and craft. She unfortunately did not refill my cup of coffee twice after putting it at the end of the table and did not keep looking to see if we needed anything. I did have to wave down one of the older waitresses who understood to look up and look at the tables. The waitress was kind an energetic but not attentive. Being at a table with my partner who also serves at a different restaurant and is a hostess as well as myself who has worked in kitchens, I can only hope that she will improve with time. But overall the experience was wonderful and the food was excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Anthony Calabrese

Good place for breakfast. I haven't tried lunch. Many creative food options.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Hunter Horsman

Great chicken and waffles, and a wide selection of breakfast and lunch options. They gave great pancakes as well, be warned they are big.

A staple breakfast choice in the area in my opinion.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Dan Mcpherson

Today was probably the fifth time we’ve ordered here. I’ve said every time that I wouldn’t order again but I keep giving it a chance. Today was just so bad that I have to write this. Pictured is the $10 “Nutella stuffed” pancake which has nothing but some Nutella drizzled on top. (From a $6.75 plain pancake) We also didn’t get syrup. Also pictured is the $9.50 corned beef hash. As you can see there isn’t even enough to thinly line 3/4 of the container as well as the 3 pieces of bacon for $6 which was just not good. However the hash its self was relatively good. Omelette was super bland and I think I found cheese in 2 bites.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Dennis Done

Great food with great service. Menu has many great options for breakfast.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

540lancem

Mid, mid, mid . I've been there six times and each time i become less impressed. Today. , ordered breakfast platter. Two eggs, sausage, pancakes, home fries, bacon, and coffee. I asked for home fries done overcooked. Home fries came out, they under cooked. Big chunks of potatoes. My son said his were "raw". Bacon there is always low quality and over cooked. Pancakes are never fluffy, always on the small size and compact. I asked three times for a coffee refill and the waitress was just so disingenuous with her work face. Definitely better places to go in the area. I'm done with them. The eggs benedict was lame and the biscuits the same per my son and his partner.

Loading...