The Sundae House

499 New Haven Ave, Milford
(203) 783-3982

Recent Reviews

Marie R.

It is probably due to my childhood love of summer and ice cream, but as soon as the weather gets warm, it's time to celebrate. The charming Sundae house in Milford ,Connecticut has a glorious list of tantalizing hard ice cream flavors as well as soft serve.The divine hot fudge is also among the best in this area. The location is easily accessible, and there is plenty of parking. The staff is very efficient at quickly, reducing the usual long line of customers. Theoretically, there is a flavor for every day of the summer. Check out the list in the pictures and enjoy!

Noemi Crespo Rice

Loved our time today at the sundae House! Yummy icecream. Ample parking space. Kids had a blast.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeff Martin

Good ice cream & great selection of flavors. Getting expensive $10/2 people, but give a good portion for a small cup. Unfortunately, a small operation, so only open from spring to Oct 1. Then they always run out of flavors the last week they are open. On Oct 1st they only had soft serve.

Ruhanny Palmero

I had the strawberry sundae in a medium size, and it is huge and delicious. It's definitely the best ice cream shop in town.

Greenbelt Phil

Picked an ice cream spot four our after dinner treat while in town. Good choice, lots of options. Was pretty busy on a Sunday night. Plenty of parking. Could use some tables/chairs to take it to the next level.

Pedro Roman

The only thing that hates this place is my waist line. I may need several gym memberships!!!!!

peter g Lombardozzi

Ice cream great and customer service however very,very disappointed when I took grandkids and was cash only,get with 2023,nobody has cash these days especially with the price of ice cream,shakes,etc I suggest venmo, zelle,credit cards and debit cards you'll get many more customersSo went up the street to Dairy Queen and had a $30 credit card order.

Heather W.

Huge selection of delicious, flavorful hard ice cream and options! Not only soft serve. Cash only :/

Peter Thomas

A little shoo off the beaten path, but plenty of options. Just remember Cash only.

Russell Hudson

Great ice cream with huge portions. There's so many flavors to choose from.

Patty Almeida

I also get the vanilla soft serve cherry sundae..My favorite. Great ice cream.

Dan Champagne

A great local ice cream shop, tons of flavors and options! Carry out only, we usually eat in our car.

Angel B.

Service was quick on this Sunday afternoon. Staff were friendly and efficient. Took our three orders perfectly. I had the brownie boat and it was a lot! Three can eat from it, so be careful!

Susan Kirkwood

Fast, polite service. Generous serving for small sundaes. There was no place to sit so it's either in the car or standing outside. Well worth the stop!

Carlene S.

Great ice cream, love that they offer ice cream sandwiches using Kathy's Cookies (which are addictive). They offer many flavors and specials. Disappointed that they only offer one flavor for frozen yogurt...black raspberry (having withdrawals for their chocolate peanut butter yogurt). The recipe for their lonely black raspberry yogurt has definitely changed and NOT for the better - it's war-head sour). Please note, it's cash only.

Load More