Marcello's Italian Eatery

In Clock Tower Square, 477 Main St, Monroe
(203) 268-7811

Recent Reviews

maddie touri

This has quickly become one of my favorite restaurants to eat at. The food is always INCREDIBLE, and the staff is always very attentive. The drinks are delicious as well. I would recommend Marcellos to anyone!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dominick D

Compliments to the owner Nick! Absolutely love this place. His wait staff is on point as is the food and drink! Waitress was very attentive and the zuppa was out of this world! Espresso martini flight that Nick made himself ten out of ten!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rogers Egbert

8:51 pmCalled to order 2 pizzas and caesar salads...The response was..."Our kitchen closes in 9 minutes, so you have no more time to order."This was one of our places...right around the corner...but no more!We won't go back.

Billy Bob (BillyBob from Connecticut)

Trying to make a reservation for Easter Sunday on the phone I was told that they were all booked up, but I was still able to make one on line. The website refers you to their on-line menu for the day, no buffet mentioned, so I said OK all set. We got there 10 minutes before our reservation time and the line was out the door so we had to wait a total of 30 minutes to be seated. After being seated by a very unfriendly waitress we were told that it was buffet only! Who wants to pay $50 for cold eggs and bacon when I could have a steak for less? Trying to make the best out of an already bad situation we get in the buffet line and there were no plates, most of the food was gone and this nasty fat guy passing out food with his head uncovered starts making more nasty comments. When the plates came there was a butter wrapper stuck to the supposed clean plates and when I questioned it the nasty guy says “please leave” which we gladly did. Never again in this place! On the way out there was an ad for a psychic appearing there with dinner so it might explain the bad vibes in this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

isa isa

Great fresh food, just amazing✌️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The brunch was over priced. The food was just okay. Food displays were too high. I had to go on my tippy toes and still couldn't see what was on the top tier plates. The dessert table was extremely disappointing. I really hate giving bad reviews but think it's an opportunity to improve for future guests. Staff was very nice.

linda colello

Our third time back, this time with friends. As usual, we were not disappointed. Being an Italian girl I know good Italian food and Marcello’s hits the mark every time. The chicken piccata was delicious and the pasta with eggplant was cooked perfectly. And of course none of us could finish the generous portions. I highly recommend the coffee and donuts for dessert, absolute delight.Parking: Easy parking close to restaurant

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Spicy Calamari

EricB

We had an absolutely wonderful time. The food was delicious, and the server was right on the spot. She was prompt and came to the table several times to make sure all was good and if we needed anything. She was polite and fun and brought the food promptly.

RowZee

Met up with some family members for a dinner out. The food was tasty and portions were decent, but the pricing was on the high side. They did have live music which we enjoyed. To their credit, we determined the next day we were charged more for several glasses of wine than what was printed on the menu, but were given a gift certificate for the difference. Not sure we would return for dinner but maybe pizza.

Paulie

The lobster ravioli was very good but the roast pork was dry. The presentation of the food was poor. The Italian calamari was very tasty but the it came out in a bowl. The staff seemed short handed and unorganized.

Nick Timakondu

Went for a date night on a Saturday night for a fantastic experience. The room was set up well, the menu had classic Italian fares with generous portions. I always judge a bar by the old fashion they can make and this was one of the best. After dinner, we had the vanilla gelato and it was delicious with waffle cone bits on top. This is going to becomes one of our regular spots from now on.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Calamari

eaterouter

Food here is good, soups especially. The pasta is done well. The biggest problem is not food related...the seating is the problem! The chairs are so terribly uncomfortable that one may not enjoy the meal because of back pain (in my case, anyway).

Robert c Woehrle

Just great food and great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexandra

Best Italian food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Victor Hernandez

Great food, nice, friendly service, live music, what else can you ask for?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Load More