šļøJuly 18, 2025-
*WRITTEN REVIEW
Big Alās Reel Reviews EP.139
š Mystic Pizza šš¾
Downtown Mystic, CT
They made a movie about it in ā88.
But today, I walked in as the food critic theyāve really been waiting on. š¬š
Right in the heart of downtown Mystic, this spot is legendary. It was packed inside, full of energy, and the decor was absolutely beautiful. The vibe? Movie-worthy. The crowd? Out in full force.
I was greeted by a great staffāSophia was my server and super polite. Max, the manager, came out and introduced himself. Later, Graysonāanother team member and B.A.R.R.fanācame over and showed love. That part was dope. šš¾
But you know meā¦ Iām not here to review the movie.
Iām here to review the meal.
š½ļø Hereās what I ordered:
1. Bourbon Molasses Wings š ā $15.00
The wings were dry, lacking flavor, and honestly? They felt cheap in qualityāthe kind youād expect from a freezer bag, not a spot with a name this iconic. The bourbon molasses sauce didnāt bring the flavor I was hoping for, and while the blue cheese dressing on the side was fireā¦ it couldnāt save the dish.
ā Verdict: Thumbs Down šš¾
2. Small Plain Cheese Pizza š ā $14.00
Overloaded with cheese, under-seasoned, and very little flavor. Looked like a basic pie, but didnāt deliver anything beyond the name.
ā Verdict: Thumbs Down šš¾
3. Chicken Parm with Garlic Bread š ā $22.00
The portion size was huge, but the execution missed. The noodles were waterlogged and mushyādefinitely not al dente. The chicken was drowning in cheese, and not in a good way. I was literally choking on the mozzarella. The garlic bread? Actually pretty goodābut it couldnāt save the dish.
ā Verdict: Thumbs Down šš¾
š£ļø Final Thoughts:
The service? Wonderful.
The atmosphere? Beautiful.
The food? Missed on all fronts.
Now listenāI totally understand if folks feel connected to this place because of the movie. For some, itās not about the flavorāitās about the feeling. The memories. And if thatās what brings you joy when you walk into Mystic Pizza, I get it. I truly do.
But Iām here to rate the food. And on that frontā¦ it just didnāt deliver.
And let me say this for the recordāfor anyone out there saying, āBig Alās bad reviews hurt businessesāā¦ letās be real. Mystic Pizza isnāt going anywhere. Itās a nationally known tourist magnet. This review wonāt stop the crowds from showing up. But I will always give it to you straight.
This oneās a pass.šš¾
āš¾ā¤ļø āBig Al Mayo
Always keeping it real to reel.
See you on the Rebound. Peaceāš¾out
Christian Alvarez
The pizza here reminds me of what Pizza Hutās pizza used to be like from the 90s. This is not a bad thing, it is still quite delicious and the taste certainly brings back some nostalgia!
Chester Copperpot
Had their Italian grinder. Absolute garbage. They use tasteless government provolone cheese. Garbage bread that youād buy at Stop and Shop and it came with only 2 meatsā¦ salami (which is fine) and boiled ham. (Wrong) I cannot believe that sandwich came out of a New England state. Embarrassing. Youāre better off buying a Subway Italianā¦.. seriously .
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Larry Gross
Since we were nearby in RI, I wanted to take a quick trip to Mystic. Mystic Connecticut is a quaint little seaside town rich with history. Mystic Pizza has a history of its own. We're here in off-season, which, if anything, doesn't make parking a hassle. But it is cooler in late November. There are two entrances, one fir pick up and the other for the dining area. The interior borrows heavily from the movie, including a monitor running the 1988 movie of the same name.
We arrived in time for an early lunch. We kept it simple, splitting a bowl of New England clam chowder and a small pepperoni and garlic pizza. I also chose a local brew, RoadsMary, to wash it down.
Everything came out in a reasonable time. The clam chowder was good, but on the peppery side. The pizza is thin crust style with a good overall flavor and a nice crunch of the crust. But a slice a heaven, maybe not.
Service was first rate. Our food and beverage choices were very good but nothing stellar. Still, it's worth a try. Enjoy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Michael Van Domelen
We visited on 9/24 during our trip to Mystic. Juan was our server. He did a great job taking care of us! We ordered a small House Special Pizza. It was so delicious!! The history of the movie and those who have visited made it much more than a place to grab a bite to eat. Now I will have to watch the movie!! Thanks for making our day in Mystic all the more memorable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Francisco Pena
Probably the best pizza in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven Blondin
I just grabbed a small plain cheese and enjoyed it a lot. Excellent cheese, flavorful sauce, and great crust. Only my second time, but they are definitely in the rotation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Special Pizza
Katie Wolfe
Being from out of state, I was told to go to Mystic Pizza and this place did not disappoint!!! It was like eating at home and the atmosphere was so good. The service was so attentive and the pizza. The pizza was unbelievable! No words! Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Izzo
Canāt go to Mystic without going to Mystic Pizza. Full disclosure, I have never seen the movie. There is lots of nostalgia and movie memorabilia around the restaurant. There is a tv with the movie playing in the main dining area. Frank Sinatra and other similar music is playing overhead. There is the main dining room, bar area, upstairs outdoor seating, and a few small tables on the sidewalk. The upstairs seating opens at 12.
I really enjoyed the food. We started with fried meatballs. Very crispy on the outside with a great sauce. Very flavorful and a nice mix in the meat. The pizza was also very good. It came out hot so we had to take a quick pause. Really good sauce and cheese. The cheese was very gooey and had a nice pull. I would definitely come back and would sit outside the next time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Samuel Mag
Great atmosphere, wonderful food, and great people working.
The pizza was fantastic, with a crispy crust and great sauce. We came because of the movie and came back for takeout to take home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tara Marchesani
Pizza is maybe not a slice of heaven but it's at least what they serve in purgatory. It's the pizza you get when you weren't bad in life, but you could have done better. It's ok. Pizza hut style if you're familiar. It's not bad and it will get you by if you're craving pizza. Staff was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Mary Alvarez
Great Pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mystic Pizza Cheese and Meat Lovers, Pickles
Mr Chief
First time at Mystic Pizza. .. Great pizza!! Really cool place.
Parking can be challenging, we used the pay parking lot, walked around village and all the shops finishing at Mystic
šļøJuly 18, 2025- *WRITTEN REVIEW Big Alās Reel Reviews EP.139 š Mystic Pizza šš¾ Downtown Mystic, CT They made a movie about it in ā88. But today, I walked in as the food critic theyāve really been waiting on. š¬š Right in the heart of downtown Mystic, this spot is legendary. It was packed inside, full of energy, and the decor was absolutely beautiful. The vibe? Movie-worthy. The crowd? Out in full force. I was greeted by a great staffāSophia was my server and super polite. Max, the manager, came out and introduced himself. Later, Graysonāanother team member and B.A.R.R.fanācame over and showed love. That part was dope. šš¾ But you know meā¦ Iām not here to review the movie. Iām here to review the meal. š½ļø Hereās what I ordered: 1. Bourbon Molasses Wings š ā $15.00 The wings were dry, lacking flavor, and honestly? They felt cheap in qualityāthe kind youād expect from a freezer bag, not a spot with a name this iconic. The bourbon molasses sauce didnāt bring the flavor I was hoping for, and while the blue cheese dressing on the side was fireā¦ it couldnāt save the dish. ā Verdict: Thumbs Down šš¾ 2. Small Plain Cheese Pizza š ā $14.00 Overloaded with cheese, under-seasoned, and very little flavor. Looked like a basic pie, but didnāt deliver anything beyond the name. ā Verdict: Thumbs Down šš¾ 3. Chicken Parm with Garlic Bread š ā $22.00 The portion size was huge, but the execution missed. The noodles were waterlogged and mushyādefinitely not al dente. The chicken was drowning in cheese, and not in a good way. I was literally choking on the mozzarella. The garlic bread? Actually pretty goodābut it couldnāt save the dish. ā Verdict: Thumbs Down šš¾ š£ļø Final Thoughts: The service? Wonderful. The atmosphere? Beautiful. The food? Missed on all fronts. Now listenāI totally understand if folks feel connected to this place because of the movie. For some, itās not about the flavorāitās about the feeling. The memories. And if thatās what brings you joy when you walk into Mystic Pizza, I get it. I truly do. But Iām here to rate the food. And on that frontā¦ it just didnāt deliver. And let me say this for the recordāfor anyone out there saying, āBig Alās bad reviews hurt businessesāā¦ letās be real. Mystic Pizza isnāt going anywhere. Itās a nationally known tourist magnet. This review wonāt stop the crowds from showing up. But I will always give it to you straight. This oneās a pass.šš¾ āš¾ā¤ļø āBig Al Mayo Always keeping it real to reel. See you on the Rebound. Peaceāš¾out
The pizza here reminds me of what Pizza Hutās pizza used to be like from the 90s. This is not a bad thing, it is still quite delicious and the taste certainly brings back some nostalgia!
Had their Italian grinder. Absolute garbage. They use tasteless government provolone cheese. Garbage bread that youād buy at Stop and Shop and it came with only 2 meatsā¦ salami (which is fine) and boiled ham. (Wrong) I cannot believe that sandwich came out of a New England state. Embarrassing. Youāre better off buying a Subway Italianā¦.. seriously .
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Since we were nearby in RI, I wanted to take a quick trip to Mystic. Mystic Connecticut is a quaint little seaside town rich with history. Mystic Pizza has a history of its own. We're here in off-season, which, if anything, doesn't make parking a hassle. But it is cooler in late November. There are two entrances, one fir pick up and the other for the dining area. The interior borrows heavily from the movie, including a monitor running the 1988 movie of the same name.
We arrived in time for an early lunch. We kept it simple, splitting a bowl of New England clam chowder and a small pepperoni and garlic pizza. I also chose a local brew, RoadsMary, to wash it down.
Everything came out in a reasonable time. The clam chowder was good, but on the peppery side. The pizza is thin crust style with a good overall flavor and a nice crunch of the crust. But a slice a heaven, maybe not.
Service was first rate. Our food and beverage choices were very good but nothing stellar. Still, it's worth a try. Enjoy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
We visited on 9/24 during our trip to Mystic. Juan was our server. He did a great job taking care of us! We ordered a small House Special Pizza. It was so delicious!! The history of the movie and those who have visited made it much more than a place to grab a bite to eat. Now I will have to watch the movie!! Thanks for making our day in Mystic all the more memorable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Probably the best pizza in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just grabbed a small plain cheese and enjoyed it a lot. Excellent cheese, flavorful sauce, and great crust. Only my second time, but they are definitely in the rotation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Special Pizza
Being from out of state, I was told to go to Mystic Pizza and this place did not disappoint!!! It was like eating at home and the atmosphere was so good. The service was so attentive and the pizza. The pizza was unbelievable! No words! Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Canāt go to Mystic without going to Mystic Pizza. Full disclosure, I have never seen the movie. There is lots of nostalgia and movie memorabilia around the restaurant. There is a tv with the movie playing in the main dining area. Frank Sinatra and other similar music is playing overhead. There is the main dining room, bar area, upstairs outdoor seating, and a few small tables on the sidewalk. The upstairs seating opens at 12.
I really enjoyed the food. We started with fried meatballs. Very crispy on the outside with a great sauce. Very flavorful and a nice mix in the meat. The pizza was also very good. It came out hot so we had to take a quick pause. Really good sauce and cheese. The cheese was very gooey and had a nice pull. I would definitely come back and would sit outside the next time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Great atmosphere, wonderful food, and great people working.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We enjoyed the pizza and the experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was fantastic, with a crispy crust and great sauce. We came because of the movie and came back for takeout to take home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Pizza is maybe not a slice of heaven but it's at least what they serve in purgatory. It's the pizza you get when you weren't bad in life, but you could have done better. It's ok. Pizza hut style if you're familiar. It's not bad and it will get you by if you're craving pizza. Staff was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great Pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mystic Pizza Cheese and Meat Lovers, Pickles
First time at Mystic Pizza. .. Great pizza!! Really cool place.
Parking can be challenging, we used the pay parking lot, walked around village and all the shops finishing at Mystic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...