toast + tonic creative kitchen

I just want to preface this by saying that we’ve been here a few times and it’s a place I look forward to coming to for brunch when visiting Mystic - with that being said, I was highly disappointed today on President’s Day. The food as usual was fantastic. The service, however, makes me never want to return. It looked as though there was one primary server with maybe another to help run food. The primary server (our server) looked extremely overwhelmed because she was literally everywhere - hosting, serving, bussing, taking takeouts, answering the phone, and making the drinks. I would’ve ordered another mimosa; however, the primary server failed to return and only fleetingly checked-in as she was walking on by to tend to the many other things she had to do. She was literally doing everything she could in her capacity but to take on that many tasks as one person is virtually impossible. I think it needs to be further thought out how many servers to have on hand especially on a holiday weekend.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

A delicious spot for breakfast or brunch. I haven't personally tried their lunch menu.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was good, but its overpriced for portion sizes and what you are getting. Ie. I only got two small pieces of bread with my shakshuka and was left with a huge bowl of the sauce with nothing to eat it with. Cute place, took brunch reservations which was nice. Service was eh. Waitress only checked on our table once then dropped the check and walked off. We would have ordered 1-2 drinks more per person, so they lost out on $60-120 plus tip. Also, the bathroom door doesn't lock and someone walked in on me basically exposing me to the dining room. So that was cool.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

*Pros: I've visited here several times, I usually order the Lox Toast, which I highly recommend. The ratio of the ingredients are a nice balance and very flavorful! Their Brioche French Toast with a side of bacon is also a must try. On my last visit I decided to order the Classic Pancakes. They are generously sized, fluffy, delicious, and amazing! I'm glad I ordered their sausage patty too, which was everything a breakfast patty should be and a great portion! I love that they serve whipped butter. I've always had excellent service, and the staff is friendly. The restaurant is clean and the atmosphere is comfortable. Nicely decorated, not over the top. *Cons: I'm not a fan of their coffee, I did try it a couple of times, not sure if it's the coffee beans, the water they use, or the machine/press. - I give T&T 5 stars because I really do like it there.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Order eggs Benny but got a fried egg too much hollandais sauce English muffin was uncooked and soggy and all that took over 25 minutes to come to my table. I would not recommend it for breakfast but they do make good lattes and brewed coffee

Service was terrible. Took us to the table and never checked on us. Food was disappointing. I got The lobster Benedict and it was dry, barely any sauce, the lobster was overcooked and the spinach was so starchy and the stems were so long it’s all I could taste. I would’ve asked my server for some more sauce but she never checked on us until another one had to go and get her to bring us the bill.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Toast + Tonic will inspire you. The food is uncanny. We went here twice in two days because we couldn’t resist the cravings. The menu is stacked with amazing meals, side dishes, drinks, and teas. Every option is a great option. The food is absolutely delicious. Breakfast, lunch, or dinner are all so, so good. The portions are perfect. The flavors are perfect.

The staff is really nice. Very attentive and courteous. We were there when it was packed and when there was an extra-large group (12+ diners). The entire restaurant was served well, served quickly, and served correctly.

There is some outdoor seating available as well. The inside gives off a mix of rustic and modern vibes. The colors and décor compliment the food and vibe perfectly. There is a small counter with baked goods and other items for sale.

Toast + Tonic is worth a trip by itself. And if you happen to be spending a day at the Olde Mystick Village shops area, make sure this restaurant is on your list of stops.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Crepes and breakfast sandwiches were very good coffee and cupcakes also delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

What a gem! Great food, great service and excellent location. Wonderful little place for kids and adults!!!

Solid brunch place. Would recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Went on a Sunday late morning when it was not busy at all. We sat down right away then waited 20 minutes before they took our drink orders. We waited another 25 minutes for them to bring 2 orders out then a few minutes later they brought 1 more order finally a few minutes later the final three orders showed up. A little over an hour from the time we walked in until we all got our food. The food was mediocre and luke warm. We got silverware with dried egg yolk on it and a hair in some scrambled eggs. The whole experience was kind of a shock but the we got the bill and noticed that they added 20 percent tip in top of the bill for a party of six (3 kids and 3 adults). They also never asked how everything was after we got the food which is food service 101. Definitely will not return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 1

Amazing meal with an amazing waitress. Loved the environment. Food was delicious, waitress was on point. Food came out a bit slow but we did get there at open. Seemed our waitress was the only one working when we arrived, shortly more crew arrived. Experience was great. Will most certainly visit again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Fantastic brunch! Every food item we had was delicious and they had great coffee options as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I hate to spill where to get my favorite items with the general public, so consider this a PSA: the carrot/apple/ginger juice here is among the best I’ve ever had (multitudes). Always remember to tip!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had reservations showed up 10 min early to be told our table was given to a bigger party and we had to wait but there was also 2 parties ahead of us for the same time slot. Will never return. Drove 50 min just to come here for brunch. Our visit was not on a holiday weekend and I spoke to no one on the phone about our reservation so whatever the owner wrote is a complete lie on their end.