J&R Seafood Market

45 Williams Ave Ste. 1, Mystic
(860) 415-4656

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Andy Wegman

Friendly and delicious.
First time in, won't be the last!

Douglas Austin

Great prices for local catch!

Christy Ketchel

Best Lobster rolls around!

john thomas

We live right around the corner and love J&R seafood! Everything is the freshest quality and everyone who works inside is nice every time you see them!

Bonita Izen

J&R has the best assortment of seafood and accouterments to make a delicious fish dinner. And I’ve found it to be always very fresh .

sally knight

six to a pound jumbo shrimp...yum yum yum!

Brian Hembling

Lobster on the roll was tender with perfect chew texture.

EP

Best and most delicious warm lobster roll from Boston down to Rhode Island and down to Connecticut. Yummmmm. Must try!
Texans

Himalaya Don

1st time in the city I’m from Cleveland, it’s excellent the lobster rolls definitely a go to when I come back highly recommended I had 2 lol

Orion Talley

Lobster rolls (both hot and cold) were as good as they get. Lobster was tender and sweet, bread was perfectly toasted and buttery. Coleslaw was perfectly dressed.

Clams and shrimp cocktail were also excellent. You can taste how fresh everything is.

Shuyi Yuan

Tl;dr:
Solid 4.5 star lobster roll. Order the clam fritters too

Cook kindly fried 2 clam fritters upon request so that I could have pipping hot fritters.
Lobster roll was well buttered and meat was fresh tasting. Half a star off as claw meat tasted dry - was it reheated? Bun was delicious and fluffy.

Clam fritters
The long fry time gave the fritters a dark brown almost burnt look, but it is not! Great flavor and chew. And the craggy protrusions meant great crunch. They provide tartar sauce to pair with the fritters. Tasted house made, tangy and creamy.
Clams were sweet, fresh, slightly briny. Yummy.

JESSICA IMBROGNO

Delicious lobster rolls! We also bought fresh scallops & shrimp which were very good. I highly recommend this place!

Edward Siciliano

The seafood is always fresh and exceptional! Allison, the owner, and her team are fantastic and extremely accommodating.

Elizabeth Moran

I love J&R Seafood! Every time I go in, they are super friendly, knowledgeable & have a great, fresh selection to choose from. I am always happy with my delicious fish and equally happy that their prices are so reasonable. Highly recommend them!

Ellen Livesey

Such a local GEM ????
As a true new englander, and someone born and raised in Rhode Island I am always searching for the freshest seafood. I am 100% seafood snob, and J&R Seafood went above and beyond my expectations.

Last Friday I enjoyed their fish and chips, which was delicious, lightly battered and fried perfectly. Hand cut fries with a great seasoning on them! Clam chowder was great too, and even had bacon in it. Highly recommend.

I have also enjoyed their Spicy Tuna sushi, salmon, scallops, and shrimp! Everything is always great, next time your in town, vacationing, or a local GO SEE THEM!

Loading...