Amity Brick Oven Pizza

144 Amity Rd, New Haven
(203) 397-9300

Recent Reviews

Jennifer Torres

Parking: It’s a shopping center so there is plenty of parking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, 12 Buffalo Wings

Chris Forbes

What is there to say... Brick oven pizza, big slices. Fresh and delicious. 5 stars man!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

DF MIX

The pepperoni pizza slice was honestly so good. Pretty perfect for a quick ready to eat New York style slice. Thin and crispy crust from a brick oven, super flavorful, very nice job. And they also have great brownies here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

saltystevo “Steve”

The pizza used to be very good. I haven't been there in a while but I'd never go back. The pizza was a $10 pizza that they are selling for $20. Dont

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Moustapha Z.

It's great food del Great pizza I recommend this place ****** The penne Ala vodka with shrimp was 10/10. Good portion

A E

First and last time ordering from here. I ordered a small “meat lovers” pizza, with sausage, bacon, and pepperoni. They failed to mention all the meat toppings were Turkey based. I have never in all my decades of life, had Turkey bacon, Turkey sausage, Turkey meatball pizza. And I never want it again. The taste and texture was soft and dry, and flavorless. The meat toppings were just thrown on top of the cheese, not baked together. The Laziest, nastiest pizza I ever had. 40$ bucks down the drain.

Food: 1

TRe Blah

The pizza is only ok, in my opinion. To be fair we ordered close to closing time so maybe not a good example of a usual pizza from here, but I thought it was mediocre considering all the other options available in this area. NY style instead of New Haven style but not enough cheese or sauce for NY style, in my opinion.

Food: 3

Service: 4

Marc M.

Service is always outstanding! The food is absolutely delicious and honestly their pizza... way better then Frank Pepe.. slices are affordable, servings are more then generous and the quality is second to none! If you have a chance to stop by I highly recommend to!

Terence McTague

Very nice place on the inside, but more importantly, the pizza is good! I am a diehard fan of Modern and general pizza snob, so this was a great find. Nestled in the Amity Stop & Shop plaza, this is a hidden gem. Super nice thin crust pizza, very “crushable”; I can eat a large by myself. Just FYI, the X-Large size is a typical large at many other places, but it’s only $1 more than a Large so it’s a great deal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Melinda Saller

I ordered a Pescatore SpecialtyPizza, there were no scallops or clams on the pizza as advertised and as I paid for. On the flip side, it did taste like a really good shrimp scampi

Food: 2

Service: 5

Jeremi R.

Terrible service. i live 15 min away and they took 1h and 45min and then tried to demand a tip.. then when i went to call them i apparently got blocked.. 0 stars if i could

Patricia Daney

Do not order from this place I spend 38 dollar on a pizza and chicken had it deliver and my food is cold and burnt and the person on the phone claim it’s out of their hands once it leave the store I like 3 minutes away so tell me how my food got cold that quick stay far away from here

Coco Coke

Pizza was burnt not brick oven! Literally burnt! Don’t not order from here!

Da'zjon Robinson

Best garlic knots in the area, cheese fries top tier. They use real cheddar instead of cheese sauce.

George Spader

not what I expected, won't be going again

Load More