Ashley's Ice Cream

280 York St, New Haven
(203) 776-7744

Recent Reviews

Sort by
jd

Worth it! Bitter Sweet was our favorite.

Food: 5

Ritvik Nag

This ice cream spot in New Haven, CT is the to-die-for spot for desserts.

If you have a dog, this is the #1 ice cream shop to bring them. They have treats and vanilla cream for pups. This shop was named after a dog, Ashley, and as such all the employees have so much patience and kindness for dogs. One guy came out, petted our dog and gave her a treat. You don’t get that treatment at any ice cream shop!

Plus, look at that wall of Dog Fame. So many dogs and they have a whole wall dedicated to that awesomeness. Hot damn.

Dog friendliness aside, their flavors are insanely good too. You can tell because I’ve rated this 5/5, which I rarely do.

Their best flavor I tried is Coffee Oreo. Lot of sugar but it’s so good. In fact we came back again, and I had it again.

First time I had: Butter Pecan + Coffee Oreo. Really awesome combo.

Second time: cookie batter + coffee Oreo. Cookie dough was bit too sweet but was nice.

I would rate ice cream itself as 4/5 and it’s not the best, and variety 3/5 because I feel they could have more, but given candor and general dog friendliness of all the staff (PS they do allow them inside!) I will rate up. After pizza from Wooster Street which is right down from Yale, this ice cream shop is nearby and it’s THE destination to stop by. If we bring our dog or ever visit CT again, we’ll definitely stop by Ashley’s in New Haven. High five!

Samuel Ramirez

Excellent

Martha C

Really delicious ice cream in lots of interesting flavors. Very reasonably priced. Great location near Yale campus.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Dan .Theman

I like the ice cream here and I like the fact that you can get a very small portion. The staff appears to be comprised of a bunch of kids who don't care very much. They would rather be texting on their phones then cleaning the tables.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aditi Rao

Really nice place to visit with a lot of options.

I had two scoops the Nutella chips and coffee Oreo. They were a perfect combination! Highly recommend trying it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chip, Nutella, Coffee Oreo

Lee Lee

Some really great ice cream at this spot. Black raspberry is the way to go.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wajiha

First time I went, I got the black raspberry. It was not good, way too sweet. Second time I went, I got the mint chip, so good. So glad I gave it another try! Best mint chip I've had.

Erika B.

Ashley's never misses, fresh, fun flavors, rich creamy ice cream, wide variety of toppings & their hot fudge is ??

Shruthi Govardhan

Loved the ice cream and the service as well. Definitely recommended

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Iris Peng

good sugar free options and soft serve

Adati Tarfa

One of the best ice cream spots around. Also reasonably priced. I had their milkshake it had more of the milk flavor than the icecream flavor but I think that is because of the flavor I chose. Otherwise a great ice cream spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Coffee Oreo

Parisa Darvishi

This ice cream shop in the heart of New Haven is a gem with a rich history. The variety of ice cream flavors and toppings is incredible, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The shop's nostalgic charm make every visit a delightful experience. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this iconic spot is a must-visit for ice cream lovers!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Black Raspberry

April Melio

So fresh, my mom and I stop by and stick our freezers every other week. super delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Butter Crunch, Butter Pecan

Dane Martel

Such a good experience! I love ashleys its my favorite ice cream shop ever. And their black raspberry ice cream is unbelievable my favorite flavor ever. And I hate raspberries. They staff is decent they could be nicer is my only feedback. Sometimes they look like they hate their job. This location doesn't have outdoor seating just in case the one in branford does though! It's retro style and cute.

Vegetarian options: All vegetarian

Dietary restrictions: All dairy heavy

Parking: Its right by Yale the parking is impossible

Kid-friendliness: Decent for kids but almost no seating so get takeout

Wheelchair accessibility: It's fairly open a bit cramped for a wheelchair

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Black Raspberry

Loading...