Atticus Market

771 Orange St, New Haven
(475) 261-4133

Recent Reviews

Tyler Kryzanowski

Best sourdough in CT! Many other loaves to try as well!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cate Asp

I definitely recommend Atticus Market! I had the mushroom sandwich which was so good. As a vegetarian, it can be hard to find good food of substance. This sandwich was well balanced and had good flavor! I also had a side of hash browns which are some of the best I’ve ever had - SO GOOD. My only complaint is that the store is cramped if there’s more than a handful inside.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Noah Daponte-Smith

Great coffee, great pastry. Vegan banana bread highly recommended. Service is atrocious. Expect 20+ minutes waiting for a coffee on a weekend. And on a weekday afternoon with the store empty, the cashier might place your cup next to the espresso machine but the barista might not show up for fifteen minutes.Also they should replace much of the obscenely expensive grocery - who is buying this stuff? - with a seating area, à la Guilford Marketplace.Dietary restrictions: Good for vegans

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

damefrmda203

very good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rohini G.

Fun coffee shop crossed over with a market/bookstore. This one felt like an upscale cornerstone (while the larger location in New Haven was more of a sit-down cafe). I tried the cheese danish which was flaky, nicely glazed, but not overly sweet. Generous amount of cheese fill as well!

Rob K

Everything is great. All breakfast and lunch items, and pizza. Pizza reminds me almost of a marriage of apizza and Neapolitan. Holds its own in a city of exceptional pizza. Nicely curated high end market items and gifts, too.

David Simon

Great bakery and excellent lunch options. Pricey, but that just helps to keep me from going there too regularly -- so it's always a treat

Ben M.

Please add it to the menu... the crispy goodness, not burnt, the basil is so flavorful... I need it again in my life but I'm embarrassed to explain it again

Francesco P Maratta

Excellent Food and Location on Orange St. in NH.

pau ardi

Always nice attention from cashiers and the matcha latte is just amazing, i like this place, im new in the city and is one my favorite places to go for a coffee in the morning

Gary Beaumont

Excellent coffee and breakfast food. Well worth it.

Wes Wazni

Eclectic market that has some interesting items not usually found in local markets. A big fan of their wheat sourdough bread and the tinned seafood. Pastries are great.

Maura Miller

Their pizzas are amazing and served Thursday-Saturday, however, they consistently are delayed 45+ minutes after the promised time of your order being ready. I have even tried arriving 30 minutes after the time my order should be ready and there have been times my order hasn’t been fired in the oven yet. Again, the taste is good, but not worth the hour wait past the time you are expecting

Robert Krause

Nice local market, cafe. A bit expensive but great location and good atmosphere

Emily Ventura

Just needed to a moment to give this place 5 stars! I’m on a bakery crawl today and this was my second stop. The first place I went had me in a diabetic coma already so I came in and asked what was most popular but also not super sweet. The person who helped me was the absolute sweetest! So helpful and charismatic! He helped me land on the kouign aman and the jam bun and let me tell you I will definitely be back! Everything is delicious I just wish there was somewhere to sit and enjoy inside but next time I’ll choose a sunny day so I can sit outside. I’m sorry I didn’t catch your name but the person with the curly pink hair 10/10 customer service, 10/10 baked goods 10/10 coffee ☺️

Load More