Dayton Street Apizza

60 Dayton St, New Haven
(203) 389-2454

Recent Reviews

oʇɐǝq ʎǝlᴉɐq

Fantastic slices, if you don't feel like waiting forever for a pie from sallys or pepes this is a great

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jacob Delatouriere

pizza is good but it seems to me they do not have set prices on their pizza I get the samething xtra cheese xtra sauce pepperoni well done & over the course of a month my pizzas went from $24 To $27 & I called today & now it’s $28….. unfortunately I will not be getting pizza through them

Food: 4

Service: 2

Cyniece

Beautiful restaurant Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julian S.

Great pizza and usually pretty fast delivery for westville orders for delivery. The pizza toppings are pretty tasty as well

Justin C.

Food is fabulous, always cooked to perfection and service is just as great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Margherita, Meatball, Pesto Special Apizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Chicken Cutlet

Ashley Lesak

Great pizza. Fantastic sauce. Best pizza in Westville!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ethan Long

gotta give it to them, they've got the good chicken parm sub, with that warm toasted sub roll and perfect amount of cheese. chicken is also crispy!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ron Skurat

After Sally's, Pepe's, & Modern this is the very best in town, in a town full of good pizza. A neighborhood gem!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatball, Pesto Special Apizza, Sausage

Lawrence james

The Margherita Pizza is to die for . A satisfied customer 4real.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Margherita

Paul Defrances

Waited for a pizza i order on the phone for over an hour ordered 5:20 did not leave till 6:10 20 people walked in and everyone got they order whiles i was sitting there with no food. Spend over 35 dollars to wait and the front desk for Atleast 45 minutes. I will say pizza was decent i asked for wings fried crispy i got the gummiest wings in the world kinda gross. Guy at the front desk was very respectful .

Tristan Cyre

Got a slice of cheese there one day and it was Amazing. Went there again after that but the slice wasn't as good. Consultancy is not there but for $3 a slice it should be.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: It

Gordis

After ordering from Dayton for many years and considering it the best in our area, we were very disappointed with our first (and probably last) order of the new year 2023. Looks like the place has either transferred to new owners or management and the food was not very good. We ordered 2 pies, a wrap and a soda and gave a good tip for the driver, all in all $60+ later, the pizza was cold, salty, lacked enough cheese, the wrap looked more like a burrito and it was very salty and to top it off, the order came 2 hours late. Very disappointed, when I called to check on the order 1 1/2 hour later, no apologies or explanations given, just the driver just left and will be there shortly. We live 5 minutes away and yet it took another 30 minutes for the driver to show up with our cold food. Time to look for a new place.

Lamont Douglas

Pizza was dry barely any sauce,,,seem like toppings was barely cooked and it arrived cold! Small pizza with 2 20 once sodas $27 plus tip! Never again!

Michelle Walton

I usually order from them and there service is usually good.But when I went to pick up the usual the girl at the front desk was coughing and didn't cover her mouth and was scratching her head without gloves on and l thought that it was unprofessional and the food yeatarday was not good as it usually was.

J S

This is not the norm to get a soggy raw doughy crust so Im assuming Saturday night was busy, but i order all the time and its usually crisp and cheese and crust are all perfectly cooked, never the less its a disappointment to have a wet doughy crust that is soggy and needed to be cooked more. Throwing it in the toaster oven to crisp it didn't even work. This pie is a fail. Usually its amazing. Kind of a bummer to be craving pizza and get this mush instead.

Load More