Elm City Social

266 College St, New Haven
(475) 441-7436

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dr. Edward

Sat on the roof deck. Staff was great. Explained everything and accommodated all of our requests. Food was excellent. So were the drinks.

Nadine

We went to Elm City for the first time on trivia night. Every staff member was extremely friendly and fun. Loved the drinks and the bites and will definitely be going back!

Cathy

The food was delicious. We had the chicken w waffles, amazing. (although we had to eat w our hands, as we never got silverware, and the server, was no where to be found ) bacon and eggs, and tacos.. all delicious. The service was poor. It took us just less than an hour to get a drink. We were in the bar area at a high top. Other tables that came in after us , received food and drink before us. The air was blowing so hard directly at our table that my hair was blowing. We asked to be moved, they said they would turn it down. I asked again, and then they closed the vent. I would go back and give it a shot, but would sit in the dining area , if possible, next time.

LesleyW

Very loud I ordered the chicken sliders and they were very salty so salty I couldn't eat them The server was great tho and took the sliders off the bill

carla

Food was good. The service was great. Our waitress was friendly, attentive and pleasant. It was a little louder than I thought it would be but we were close to the bar. The tacos and salmon sliders were great. Their drinks were really good too.

Rachael

Food was amazing! Service was disappointing because we were not told there was a happy hour menu and charged full price and would've preferred mix and match of sliders allowed only on happy hour menu. Second espresso martini taste was great, however drink was warm.

Morgan

The food was absolutely delicious and the service was fast and friendly. I had a hard time choosing what to order because everything looked delicious. We will be back for sure!

Anne

Nice selection of food, well presented and very tasty. Cocktails and selection of beers/wine was good. Prices very reasonable. Would order the Crispy Shrooms again - they were excellent.

John

Zucchini chips and deviled eggs were awesome. Dinner was also excellent. Service was fantastic.

Grace

We had an amazing brunch and the bottomless mimosas were amazing! Can't wait to return

Atira Cobbs

The service could have been better, but Anthony was very helpful with reconciling everything to make our experience way better. I will be returning!

Parking: Wish parking was free after 5pm

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Slider

Darlene L. Eason

The manager, Anthony, did an outstanding job resolving the mix-up caused by his staff. What started as a basic birthday turned into a great experience, and I will definitely be returning.

Dee (the bday girl)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

vintia mullen

There was an issue with my order however Anthony was amazing at correcting the issues and making the experience worth it ?!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken and Waffle Bites

Mike Malloy

It took 20 minutes for a waiter to come up to us after we were seated. The water glasses were approximately 4 ounces and I was never offered a refill. The duck drink tasted extremely watered down. I was charged a higher price for several items than what was stated on the menu. Very disappointing.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Caitlin

Worst dining experience we’ve had in New Haven. Truly terrible service. Our food came out an hour after we were seated. People around us were cancelling their food orders and leaving because it took so long. Others were walking their checks up to the bar to pay because the server never came back to their table. And this was when the restaurant was mostly empty!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Loading...