Fair Haven Oyster Company
307 Front St, New Haven
(203) 745-5741
Customers' Favorites
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
Grilled Mackerel
Seared Scallops
Alpine Arrows
Tin Mackerel
Tin Scallops
Raw Oysters
Menu
Photos
+18 photos
+17 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This was my first time dining at Fair Haven Oyster Club, and I must say I had an amazing experience! Our waitress was very attentive, and I also like how we were encouraged to order everything at once so it could be brought out course-style and in a timely fashion. I absolutely loved the tin fish(spiced mackerel), one of the best I've ever had....definitely a highlight for a tin fish lover like myself! My branzino was made to perfection, and the spicy tomato based sauce complimented...
Attention to detail, and fresh ingredients make Fair Haven Oyster a standout! The menu is eclectic and fantastic. Servers were friendly and attentive. Emily greets and chats with everyone. I love this place!
This one's on me. I feel bad writing a relatively negative review given that it was my decision to try another of Emily Mingrone's restaurants when I was so unimpressed with her much vaunted Tavern on State. Chef-owner Mingrone and I have never met, but after my second attempt, it's clear to me that my vibe and the chef's vibe simply don't mesh...and that's ok. First, to start with the positives. I loved the oyster selection that was both broad without...
You May Also Like
Q River Grill - 3-5, Clifton St
![]()
Wine Bar, Sports Bar, Cocktail Bar
Salsa's authentic mexican restaurant - 99 Grand Ave
![]()
Mexican, Salad, Seafood