Great experience- food was delicious and brought out in a good time after ordering - our waitress was very attentive. A little noisy towards the end of our meal with a larger party coming in. Also appreciated having parking covered by the restaurant as well !
Food and cocktails are consistently good. Service varies by the person waiting your table - usually service is casual and does not rush; last time there service felt rushed and that we were being pushed out (albeit on a busy Friday night). Still a fave and would go back.
Ccccc
Atmosphere is lively on a Saturday. Mango margarita was excellent! Only disappointment is they advertise table side guacamole and table side salsa but they do not make it at your table.
Jenn
Food was delicious. Unfortunately service was lacking, especially given it was mostly empty. Drinks were ridiculously overpriced, $14 for a margarita on the rocks that was mostly rocks, maybe 4 ounces of actual margarita. Good but not worth the steep prices.
A Google User
Yummy food!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M T
Awesome all the way. And the bartender Jamie is amazing. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Zuchowski
Wide range of tequilla drinks and beyond. Loved the vibe and the decor.
Brian Gonzalez
Honestly the place was ok but wayyy wayyy overpriced for the food…place is more about making money than serving good portions for your buck…they have downsized on traditional plates and are over charging in my opinion…disappointing at a our bill for dishes that left our stomachs empty. Oh and before I forget RESERVATIONS ARE ONLY 2 HOURS LONG…and then they make it pretty clear…ITS TIME TO GO.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Taylor Land
By far our favorite tequila bar in New Haven. From the staff to the atmosphere this place has everything.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Guacamole to Share, Forest Mushroom Burrito, Geronimo Burger, Lobster Quesadilla, Geronimo Mac & Cheese, Chips & Salsa
JF Ortiz
Reservation is required. But I will return because their food is homemade. From the tortilla to the soup, it is made from fresh ingredients. Their service is attentive and cordial. All their cocktails are very good. ?
Food was bland even after adding some salt, drinks were just ok. Service was good but that's the best I can say. We had the Birria tacos, Geronimo Burger and Chicken Burrito...very disappointed.
Kasey Estella
Lobster risotto didn’t have enough cheese or milk, it was DRY like the sahara dessert & my date only had 1 bite of it. Luckily, i had the BIRRIA tacos which were out of this world amazing and the best i’ve ever had.The table side guac is CHEFS KISS. they made it fresh in front of us! We went for valentine’s day, not sure what was up with that risotto. If you do decide to go get their spanish/mexican dishes like guac and tacos , so good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Maria Zimmerman
Great Place For Lunch and Drinks. Bartender Makes Excellent Drinks.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DF MIX
We were super surprised by how wonderful the food is here. Best carne asada and Birria tacos in New Haven. The Birria taco especially was bursting with flavor and the dulce de leche cake was melt in your mouth delectable. We loved it here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lindsey R.
After being turned away from Harvest, we ended up going to Geronimo's for Valentine's and I'm so glad we did. We sat outside with heaters and the sides covered. We never get to sit outside because it's so packed sm during the summer so this was so nice to have it basically to ourselves. The food and drink we also so amazing and yummy. Our server was amazing but I didn't catch her name! We'll always come back here!
Great experience- food was delicious and brought out in a good time after ordering - our waitress was very attentive. A little noisy towards the end of our meal with a larger party coming in. Also appreciated having parking covered by the restaurant as well !
Food and cocktails are consistently good. Service varies by the person waiting your table - usually service is casual and does not rush; last time there service felt rushed and that we were being pushed out (albeit on a busy Friday night). Still a fave and would go back.
Atmosphere is lively on a Saturday. Mango margarita was excellent! Only disappointment is they advertise table side guacamole and table side salsa but they do not make it at your table.
Food was delicious. Unfortunately service was lacking, especially given it was mostly empty. Drinks were ridiculously overpriced, $14 for a margarita on the rocks that was mostly rocks, maybe 4 ounces of actual margarita. Good but not worth the steep prices.
Yummy food!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome all the way. And the bartender Jamie is amazing. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wide range of tequilla drinks and beyond. Loved the vibe and the decor.
Honestly the place was ok but wayyy wayyy overpriced for the food…place is more about making money than serving good portions for your buck…they have downsized on traditional plates and are over charging in my opinion…disappointing at a our bill for dishes that left our stomachs empty. Oh and before I forget RESERVATIONS ARE ONLY 2 HOURS LONG…and then they make it pretty clear…ITS TIME TO GO.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
By far our favorite tequila bar in New Haven. From the staff to the atmosphere this place has everything.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Guacamole to Share, Forest Mushroom Burrito, Geronimo Burger, Lobster Quesadilla, Geronimo Mac & Cheese, Chips & Salsa
Reservation is required. But I will return because their food is homemade. From the tortilla to the soup, it is made from fresh ingredients. Their service is attentive and cordial. All their cocktails are very good. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Tortilla Soup
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was bland even after adding some salt, drinks were just ok. Service was good but that's the best I can say. We had the Birria tacos, Geronimo Burger and Chicken Burrito...very disappointed.
Lobster risotto didn’t have enough cheese or milk, it was DRY like the sahara dessert & my date only had 1 bite of it. Luckily, i had the BIRRIA tacos which were out of this world amazing and the best i’ve ever had.The table side guac is CHEFS KISS. they made it fresh in front of us! We went for valentine’s day, not sure what was up with that risotto. If you do decide to go get their spanish/mexican dishes like guac and tacos , so good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Great Place For Lunch and Drinks. Bartender Makes Excellent Drinks.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were super surprised by how wonderful the food is here. Best carne asada and Birria tacos in New Haven. The Birria taco especially was bursting with flavor and the dulce de leche cake was melt in your mouth delectable. We loved it here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
After being turned away from Harvest, we ended up going to Geronimo's for Valentine's and I'm so glad we did. We sat outside with heaters and the sides covered. We never get to sit outside because it's so packed sm during the summer so this was so nice to have it basically to ourselves. The food and drink we also so amazing and yummy. Our server was amazing but I didn't catch her name! We'll always come back here!