Went here after the Marley concert. The deluxe cookies are where it's at. The birthday cake/sprinkle is the best by far.
China Morena
It is what it is..... a Warm Long Hug at 1, 2, 3 am... the worst part is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amber F.
Didn't give us napkins but other then that good service and told us to have a good night so probably a 3.5 if that was a thing
Aida C.
great, convenient spot in the city! kind staff, yummy cookies and quick service, i love coming here!
April Bowe
Parking: Keep circling the block until you find a space or bring someone with you how can go in to pick up order. Place your order online because parking is hard to find.
Had cookies delivered. They were delicious! Would highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tiana Durham
Always so fresh and warm each cookie I’ve gotten over the last 4 years. The staff are friendly. I was able to get a sample of a vegan chocolate cookie which I’d never usually try on my own and been hooked ever since thank you. Always quick as well, and the location is great so many things to explore and experience but even better ending the night with freshly baked cookies from you guys.
If you're looking for a late night dessert, Insomnia Cookies is the place to go! I always try to stop by any time I happen to be in New Haven, or after getting dinner at a nearby restaurant. On street parking is available in front of the store, but often there aren't any open spaces, so you'll have to park on a nearby street or parking garage. It's generally hit or miss with how busy it is. I've been plenty of times when the line is out the door, and other times when there's only a couple people inside. Considering it's such a popular spot, I wouldn't recommend stopping by if you're in a hurry. The menu consists of Classic Cookies, Deluxe Cookies (which are about $2 more each), brownies, ice cream, and "Wiches" (ice cream sandwiches made with cookies). I usually stick to the Classic Cookies, like the Chocolate Chunk, Double Chocolate Chunk, and White Chocolate Macadamia. While all are delicious, I like the good old-fashioned Chocolate Chunk the best. The cookies are stored in a warmer so they're always warm and gooey when you get them. They also have chocolate and regular milk available, as well as soda. As far as ambiance, there's not much to say... it's meant to be a takeout place, so there aren't any tables to sit inside, only one small counter area in the back of the store with a few stools. The staff are generally friendly. Despite trying many other cookies from different bakeries around the state, nothing really beats Insomnia Cookies!
Stephanie H.
Perfect way to end a night in New Haven. My go to spot after going to a show at the shubert or a concert at College Street music hall. Tonight was a concert and I got caught up in bringing more cookies home because of a great deal Insomnia was offering. Always warm and perfectly baked. My kiddos were psyched when they woke up to see cookies on the counter, though did question why so many. I blamed my friend, told them she made me get the deal. Worth it!!!
2 times I received rock hard cookies. Sugar and double chocolate
Arianna Mullings
I had went all the way frm Bridgeport to New Haven for my birthday and I tried the box of 6 and omg it was the best cookie I’ve ever tasted the milk was even better with it, truly the best cookie I’ve ever tried 1000/10 def
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
SoulDaily
Special Treat !!! Cookies always warm & super soft !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
siddanth rai
Amazing cookie. I also like their cookie ice cream.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Yahknewme Smith
Great deals for this season. They may still have the buy one 6 box or 12 box get one free. Cookies are always hot and delicious. I tried the vegan birthday cake cookie. This time, it was so moist and delicious. My husband got his favorite salted caramel cookie and confetti cookie.
Went here after the Marley concert. The deluxe cookies are where it's at. The birthday cake/sprinkle is the best by far.
It is what it is..... a Warm Long Hug at 1, 2, 3 am... the worst part is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Didn't give us napkins but other then that good service and told us to have a good night so probably a 3.5 if that was a thing
great, convenient spot in the city! kind staff, yummy cookies and quick service, i love coming here!
Parking: Keep circling the block until you find a space or bring someone with you how can go in to pick up order. Place your order online because parking is hard to find.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Insomnia Chocolate Cookie Butter, Chocolate Chunk, Cookie Selection, Snickerdoodle
Had cookies delivered. They were delicious! Would highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always so fresh and warm each cookie I’ve gotten over the last 4 years. The staff are friendly. I was able to get a sample of a vegan chocolate cookie which I’d never usually try on my own and been hooked ever since thank you. Always quick as well, and the location is great so many things to explore and experience but even better ending the night with freshly baked cookies from you guys.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake, Mint Chocolate Chip, Cookie Selection, Sample Box, Snickerdoodle
If you're looking for a late night dessert, Insomnia Cookies is the place to go! I always try to stop by any time I happen to be in New Haven, or after getting dinner at a nearby restaurant. On street parking is available in front of the store, but often there aren't any open spaces, so you'll have to park on a nearby street or parking garage. It's generally hit or miss with how busy it is. I've been plenty of times when the line is out the door, and other times when there's only a couple people inside. Considering it's such a popular spot, I wouldn't recommend stopping by if you're in a hurry. The menu consists of Classic Cookies, Deluxe Cookies (which are about $2 more each), brownies, ice cream, and "Wiches" (ice cream sandwiches made with cookies). I usually stick to the Classic Cookies, like the Chocolate Chunk, Double Chocolate Chunk, and White Chocolate Macadamia. While all are delicious, I like the good old-fashioned Chocolate Chunk the best. The cookies are stored in a warmer so they're always warm and gooey when you get them. They also have chocolate and regular milk available, as well as soda. As far as ambiance, there's not much to say... it's meant to be a takeout place, so there aren't any tables to sit inside, only one small counter area in the back of the store with a few stools. The staff are generally friendly. Despite trying many other cookies from different bakeries around the state, nothing really beats Insomnia Cookies!
Perfect way to end a night in New Haven. My go to spot after going to a show at the shubert or a concert at College Street music hall. Tonight was a concert and I got caught up in bringing more cookies home because of a great deal Insomnia was offering. Always warm and perfectly baked. My kiddos were psyched when they woke up to see cookies on the counter, though did question why so many. I blamed my friend, told them she made me get the deal. Worth it!!!
Lovely cookies and brownies. Staff is super nice.
Restaurantji Recommends
2 times I received rock hard cookies. Sugar and double chocolate
I had went all the way frm Bridgeport to New Haven for my birthday and I tried the box of 6 and omg it was the best cookie I’ve ever tasted the milk was even better with it, truly the best cookie I’ve ever tried 1000/10 def
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Special Treat !!! Cookies always warm & super soft !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing cookie. I also like their cookie ice cream.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great deals for this season. They may still have the buy one 6 box or 12 box get one free. Cookies are always hot and delicious. I tried the vegan birthday cake cookie. This time, it was so moist and delicious. My husband got his favorite salted caramel cookie and confetti cookie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Triple Chocolate Chunk Cookies, Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Cookie Sandwich, Birthday Cake, Vegan, Snickerdoodle