Traveled from Scranton Pa to try the Pizza and it did not disappoint!
Joann Caires
Overpriced…hardly no toppings on pizza…fried calamari over battered and over cooked…mostly peppers… very disappointing…weth location
Bill Peden
3 couples went to dinner 2 couples were served ate and boxed before we the 3rd couple got our food
I asked for a manager and it took 10 minutes before he came I told him forget the pizza he gave me a lame excuse about we served quality and they probably had to remake it
He made me take the pizza home and IT WAS BURNT STAY AWAY FROM THE FAIRFIELD LOCATION
Simon Matney
Best pizza I’ve ever had. Old school vibe. Great experience.
Vw Guy
Pizza was OK. The ceaser salad was terrible. Sent it back but was still charged for it. Was not worth the hour we stood in line.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Phillip Neal
I mean, cmon, it’s Sally’s apizz. What else is there to say. This pizza will absolutely knock your friggin socks off.
Food: 5
Eddie Moy
Wanted to try the competition to Frank Pepe. Sally has half the seating and old ovens that don’t work well was what I was told by the manager after our order took over an hour to come. If I didn’t say anything to the waitress, it would have taken even longer. After I asked, the manager came over and told me they have old ovens and they sometimes don’t work well. She then gave us the meal for free and said no one should have to wait that long for their food. They should really tell you when you are ordering that your food may come 40-60 minutes after you order and if you want to wait. Some may not. Waiting that long after you just waited 30-40 minutes to be seated is insane. The place is old, doesn’t look like it has been updated before.
Now about the two pizza’s we ordered. One was the plain with sausage and mushroom, the other was a clam. The clam is pretty good. Heavy garlic. The plain with sausage and mushroom was really good. Both the crust is more like a Neapolitan crust, just not as fluffy. The outside is crunchy and inside is soft, little char on the bottom.
Was it with the wait? No, I don’t think anything is worth over an hour wait after you order. If they can improve the experience, would get a solid 5 star. I do actually prefer Sally’s pizza over Pepe’s, but the waiting is a killer for me.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Jacki Joyce
Absolutely delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Molly H
A bit of a wait, but that was expected and the pizza is well worth it! Also had a little mix up with the online ordering for pick up but the customer service was amazing, they went above and beyond to make it right. The pizza is soooo good!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley K
Very busy spot but we called in a medium pizza for take out and the pizza was gone before we even left the parking lot, very good, very fresh cheese pizza. 9/10
First time trying Sally’s and I was quickly disappointed. I stopped in on a Thursday 11:00am so we did not have to wait luckily. The pizza was so burnt under that even my 4 year old daughter who is obsessed with pizza told me “this pizza is nasty it tastes burnt mom”. The burnt flavor was so strong it took away from the pizza itself, and left an after taste almost all day in my mouth. The pepperoni was good and the cheese but the sauce was okay my mother had to add garlic and parm to give it more flavor. I prefer Modern down the road instead they have never disappointed. And in regards to the prices it’s a bit ridiculous a pitcher of soda and a medium pizza total was $40 plus tip obviously I could have had a nice steak dinner for that price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Buster
THE BEST pizza in New Haven, in New England, in the UNITED STATES
Basically, one of the best in the whole world and I don't care what other people think, this is the real deal
Anthony Bevilacqua
Unreal pizza! Pizza was delicious! I highly recommend calling ahead it did take awhile to get the pizza. It was worth every minute to have this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Channyra Than
First time at Sally’s. Of course it was raining, but totally worth it! My personal favorite is the pepperoni pizza. The sauce and the pepperoni were so fresh! You can never go wrong with plain and the potato pizza was delightful. Our server was so attentive, she knew her stuff and has been there forever! She totally made our day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Potato, Plain Mozzarella Pie
Guido A
For a New Haven style pizza it was great! I liked the sauce flavour, it was rich. But now, ordering a pizza... we ordered through the web cause the phone was always busy. The wait was 2 and a half hours. OK, we can wait. Now we come pick it up and they make us wait 15 minutes. That just wasn't OK. I know managing a place like that must be hard with the amount of demand but, if you know you are going to be delaying orders, just add 15+ minutes to the original time. Don't make us wait outside.
Traveled from Scranton Pa to try the Pizza and it did not disappoint!
Overpriced…hardly no toppings on pizza…fried calamari over battered and over cooked…mostly peppers… very disappointing…weth location
3 couples went to dinner 2 couples were served ate and boxed before we the 3rd couple got our food I asked for a manager and it took 10 minutes before he came I told him forget the pizza he gave me a lame excuse about we served quality and they probably had to remake it He made me take the pizza home and IT WAS BURNT STAY AWAY FROM THE FAIRFIELD LOCATION
Best pizza I’ve ever had. Old school vibe. Great experience.
Pizza was OK. The ceaser salad was terrible. Sent it back but was still charged for it. Was not worth the hour we stood in line.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
I mean, cmon, it’s Sally’s apizz. What else is there to say. This pizza will absolutely knock your friggin socks off.
Food: 5
Wanted to try the competition to Frank Pepe. Sally has half the seating and old ovens that don’t work well was what I was told by the manager after our order took over an hour to come. If I didn’t say anything to the waitress, it would have taken even longer. After I asked, the manager came over and told me they have old ovens and they sometimes don’t work well. She then gave us the meal for free and said no one should have to wait that long for their food. They should really tell you when you are ordering that your food may come 40-60 minutes after you order and if you want to wait. Some may not. Waiting that long after you just waited 30-40 minutes to be seated is insane. The place is old, doesn’t look like it has been updated before.
Now about the two pizza’s we ordered. One was the plain with sausage and mushroom, the other was a clam. The clam is pretty good. Heavy garlic. The plain with sausage and mushroom was really good. Both the crust is more like a Neapolitan crust, just not as fluffy. The outside is crunchy and inside is soft, little char on the bottom.
Was it with the wait? No, I don’t think anything is worth over an hour wait after you order. If they can improve the experience, would get a solid 5 star. I do actually prefer Sally’s pizza over Pepe’s, but the waiting is a killer for me.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Absolutely delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
A bit of a wait, but that was expected and the pizza is well worth it! Also had a little mix up with the online ordering for pick up but the customer service was amazing, they went above and beyond to make it right. The pizza is soooo good!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very busy spot but we called in a medium pizza for take out and the pizza was gone before we even left the parking lot, very good, very fresh cheese pizza. 9/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
First time trying Sally’s and I was quickly disappointed. I stopped in on a Thursday 11:00am so we did not have to wait luckily. The pizza was so burnt under that even my 4 year old daughter who is obsessed with pizza told me “this pizza is nasty it tastes burnt mom”. The burnt flavor was so strong it took away from the pizza itself, and left an after taste almost all day in my mouth. The pepperoni was good and the cheese but the sauce was okay my mother had to add garlic and parm to give it more flavor. I prefer Modern down the road instead they have never disappointed. And in regards to the prices it’s a bit ridiculous a pitcher of soda and a medium pizza total was $40 plus tip obviously I could have had a nice steak dinner for that price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
THE BEST pizza in New Haven, in New England, in the UNITED STATES
Basically, one of the best in the whole world and I don't care what other people think, this is the real deal
Unreal pizza! Pizza was delicious! I highly recommend calling ahead it did take awhile to get the pizza. It was worth every minute to have this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
First time at Sally’s. Of course it was raining, but totally worth it! My personal favorite is the pepperoni pizza. The sauce and the pepperoni were so fresh! You can never go wrong with plain and the potato pizza was delightful. Our server was so attentive, she knew her stuff and has been there forever! She totally made our day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Potato, Plain Mozzarella Pie
For a New Haven style pizza it was great! I liked the sauce flavour, it was rich. But now, ordering a pizza... we ordered through the web cause the phone was always busy. The wait was 2 and a half hours. OK, we can wait. Now we come pick it up and they make us wait 15 minutes. That just wasn't OK. I know managing a place like that must be hard with the amount of demand but, if you know you are going to be delaying orders, just add 15+ minutes to the original time. Don't make us wait outside.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Loading...