Sweet Mary's

129 Court St, New Haven
(203) 200-9519

Recent Reviews

Sort by
LaTanya Isler

It was good

Rae Grace

Stunning from start to finish!!! Excellent service and quality cakes!!

Montariel Minor

I bought a very strawberry, lemon curd, and strawberry cheesecake cupcakes for my friends and I and we all can agree that our cupcakes were amazing. I had the very strawberry one and it was really moist, the filling was delightful and filled with fresh strawberries, and the frosting was delicious.

Rose Richi

Popped in to see what the store was like; it’s so cute, smells amazing, and has a really inviting atmosphere. I bought three cookies and a card. We ate the cookies before thinking to take a picture but trust they were tasty!

AMOR VINCIT

It's better if you call before going to ask if they have anything

Samuel George

delicious cupcakes!

Lynn Pandolfi

We ordered cupcakes for two different parties in one weekend and Sweet Mary’s did not disappoint. Great, yummy, moist cupcakes and terrific service. Sweet Mary’s is the best for cupcakes hands down!!!

Joseph Gagliardi

We have been waiting to go to Sweet Mary’s for a long time and it was a fantastic experience!!!
The place is super cool and the owner was awesome helping us with our order.
We bought 24 cupcakes for a party and it was a huge hit!
The cupcakes taste great and not too sugary. We will be long time patrons for sure!

Preston

Cute bakery that had a ton of different cupcakes and some other desserts. We tried 3 cupcakes, lemon, butter cake, and Boston crème and they were all amazing but the butter cake one (Biscoff) was absolutely insane! I will think of that cupcake for a long time.

Roberto Caceres

This little shop is a heavy hitter, every cupcake I've tried (too many) has been excellent and doesn't kill you with sugar the way some do, perfectly sweet! Everyone inside is always so nice as well, we love Sweet Mary's!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcake

Andrea Louis

My daughter from Virginia ordered pink champagne cupcakes for me by phone. They were a special order. Beautiful and sooo yummy. Ready for me on my birthday. Parking was not a problem in and out in a snap. Now I have to stop eating every last one all by myself

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sara Louis

I reached out to them to see if they could make cupcakes for my mother's birthday, she wanted something very specific and I live in Virginia. Went above and beyond and my mother was extremely pleased with the outcome!

CTmaryB

The best cupcakes I’ve ever had!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Koobie “Koobie Ky” Ky

Just drop in and you'll see why it's 5 stars. Thanks for the lovely experience

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ken Harlan

Our chefs hats off to you Mary and your staff thank you for putting our rush order through
And adding the finishing touches, and taking the stress off our shoulders

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...