Elm Hill Pizza
625 Maple Hill Ave, Newington
(860) 666-4649
Customers' Favorites
2 Items Medium with Chicken
Medium Pizza Half Meatball
Elm Hill Special Pizza
Small Vegetable Pizza
Elm Hill Special
Kielbasa Grinder
Hawaiian Special
Pepperoni Pizza
Eggplant Grinder
Pepperoni Half
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I’m new to the area and I must say the Hawaiian pizza was absolutely delicious the toppings were fresh and flavorful and the crust was top tier. The chef salad was not just a salad and the blue cheese dressing had to be made in house 10/10 recommend did not disappoint
We were in town for a funeral. Last minute order to the good people at Elm Hill pizza for 10 large pizzas. They were kind, understanding and gave us their condolences. Even offered to stay past if our big family needed to order more, which we ended up doing. During a very hard time for our family, they were amazing. The whole community as well. Pizza was absolutely delicious as well. Thank you!
Elm Hill Pizza is such a gem in Newington. As soon as you walk in, it just feels cozy and welcoming—like a neighborhood spot that’s been around forever. We ordered a pizza and a grinder, and both were seriously delicious. You can tell they really care about the food and the people. The staff was super friendly, and the whole vibe made it a great experience. Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to!
You May Also Like
Giovanni's Bakery - 456 New Britain Ave
![]()
Bakery, Custom Cakes, Cupcakes, Gluten-Free
Tokyo Cafe - 451 New Britain Ave
![]()
Sushi, Japanese, Salad, Sushi Bar, Pet Friendly